Progressive Christian Channel
A New (Old) God, Quantum Physics, and Riding the Big Waves: Breakfast with Rob Bell
So these electrons firing randomly and forming pathways only when observed, leads you to say...?
Well, one of the things in the book I explore is simply involvement. For many people the fundamental way we see things is that we are these individual autonomous units. But when quantum physicists start talking about how things are affected when they're observed, that just puts us all much more into a relational space. So there is the power of the scientists in the lab and a white coat with a clipboard standing objectively over something, and there is a time and a place for that and we have lots of luxuries and conveniences because of this sort of understanding of things. But, at its core, the universe is far more inter-subjective; we are way more involved than we first realized. So, when people of faith have been talking about the relational dimensions of our existence and the importance of relationships and the awareness that things are shaping us and we are shaping other things, this isn't a crazy idea—this is actually really well founded. So, when people talk about "good vibes" and being positive and other people being a "drain" and being toxic, we have this sort of loose language about the way we operate in the world, but there's actually a lot of truth to it.
I love how you talk about joy, and that joy is central to your experience and expression of God. You talk about someone having a good "vibe," but it's not just language, it's actually biblically grounded as you say, and also scientifically, energetically founded.
Yeah, we talk about joy as "contagious." And it may actually be. When we talk about, "Man, I was in-spired," which essentially means "I breathed in life," you may actually have breathed in life; there may have been way more going on there. So you know how many people, when they talk about who they are, will go back somewhere in their history and tell of how somebody spoke an affirming word over them or somebody told them "you know what, you're really talented at this," or "I could see you doing that" and it altered the entire trajectory of their life? Did the person just speak, or was there some sort of exchange, in a way in which their consciousness was seared with this new announcement of who they could be?
So it just heightens the importance of our interactions. I talk about the body being a highly sophisticated radar system with a sub-cortical awareness we have called intuition; for thousands of years people trusted this. Somewhere along the way, for a lot of people it became, if you can't rationally analyze it and articulate it then it's probably suspect and it essentially cuts us off from this whole world of intuition that is way more trustworthy maybe than we first thought.
You're starting to talk more and more like a Californian every day! (laughter) I'm from California so I can say that. But seriously, where do you locate yourself in Christianity these days? I mean...
I don't! It's not even remotely interesting to me.
Say more about that.
I've just never even found it even a small bit compelling to try and talk about myself or where I fit or...
Like a label, or identifying yourself...
Someone else can do that.
How do you self-identify as a person of faith?
I'm a Christian.
I actually heard these Jesus stories when I was young, like the cross and resurrection and "come follow me," and I believed from an early age. Jesus was utterly compelling and believable and worth following, whatever that looked like for a kid. So I didn't come into this through a denomination or a dogma or a systematic theology; I came in through my own experience and believing trust that there's a God who loved me, and loves us, and calls us to a great life—a full, overflowing, vital life. It's actually just this last year that I'm more in tune with that.
So when people are like "well you didn't say it this way," I don't know what you're talking about. I guess I don't measure up to these eleven propositions or these nine theological statements. There is this love that flows among all of us and that is our job, to be channels and vessels of it to others, and this is what Jesus told us to do, and when he could have summarized it in a million different ways, he said "love your neighbor, love God." So that's sort of how I came into it; so I still am sort of floating along in this particular river and it's good and it's worth it.
Staying with Jesus for a minute—as a Christian, as somebody who has written a book called Love Wins that made a nod toward Christian Universalism by suggesting that there might not be a hell and that we all might get into heaven after all—do you still believe that Jesus is uniquely salvific? For you, is Jesus the way, or a way?
Yeah, I take very seriously Jesus announcing that he has done something for all of humanity. Paul talks about the reconciliation of all things, and Jesus talks about the restoration of all things, and the New Testament says that he holds all things together. So, there is a particularness to his universality, but how that exactly plays out, I have no idea.
But I don't see him somewhere other than present with all of us, and that is a great mystery. I think a lot of people in the Christian faith think Jesus is somewhere other than in the midst of all humanity, so you have to get people to him or get him to people. That isn't how he talked, and I don't think it's how the first Christians talked. When Paul is writing "His blood is shed on the cross for the reconciliation of all things in heaven and on earth," that's about as expansive as it gets.
So I want to go back to science and God, for a minute. I was having lunch recently with some friends of mine, one of whom is a former Presbyterian minister, who is now an atheist, or a "free thinker" as he prefers to call himself. He was saying that he just doesn't see the need for the supernatural. For him, science, the world, is so amazing in and of itself; when you look up at the stars, why do you have to say, "Isn't God so great that He created that?" Why can't you just look up at the stars and say, "That's amazing"? What would you say to the atheist or skeptic about why we make that move to God at all?
Because when a tsunami hits, and it wipes out thousands of innocent people, our fellow humans, does this man say "that's awesome"? Or when you're in a village in sub-Saharan Africa, where 27 percent of the people are HIV positive, does he say "isn't this awesome"? So, creation is awesome, but if creation is God, there are some things that are really wrong. The Hebrew view is we don't say God is the mountain, the volcano, the pasta, the sunset, the embrace; it's about creation that is free to actually be a creation. Which means there's all this potential for horribleness. That's probably how I'd begin to answer it.
I also secondly would say it depends on what you mean by "miracle." The whole thing is miraculous, and that is where his critique is really powerful. He's simply saying, "I don't need to go to mythological supernaturalism to have wonder and awe." And, he's right; I actually think his thinking is quite biblical. I would also argue that if this is a retired pastor, who sounds like a brilliant, interesting man, I would be interested to know who hurt him. Because my experience has been that intellectual issues often have their roots . . . he may be not believing in a God he experienced in a denominational setting. I probably don't believe in that God either. He may actually have rejected things that we should reject.
Deborah Arca joined the Patheos team after more than ten years managing programs for the Program in Christian Spirituality at the San Francisco Theological Seminary. Deborah has also been a youth minister, a director of Christian Education and music/theatre programs for young people and has served as a music director for worship and special retreats.
You may also be interested in these stories:
- The Longing...for What? Reflections for the First Sunday of Advent: Isaiah 64:1-9
- On Recognizing the Shepherd: Reflections on Christ the King Sunday (Ezekiel 34:11-16, 20-24)
- Things Are Seldom What They Seem: Reflections on Judges 4:1-7
- Organ Donation, Persecuted Churches, Choice: Reflections on Joshua 24:1-3a, 14-25