Christmas Spirit and Ecclesia: What Christmas Movies Can Teach Us about the Church
What is the Church? It's a question with which denominations and individual congregations wrestle, with which theologians and church leaders struggle. But it's also a question that literary and popular narratives have tackled, whether peripherally or head-on, and in one perhaps justly-maligned type of narrative, the Christmas movie, we can actually find useful wisdom on what it means to be both church and Church.
What is the Church? Well, going back to the gospel record, we can see that Jesus told his followers to remember him; he empowered them to bless and forgive, to heal and to cast out demons. He said that upon Peter (or upon Peter's confession of faith) he would build his church, and Jesus' words indicate that he meant something universal rather than merely local. He gave his followers a commission to go into all the world and preach the good news of the Kingdom of God, and the Book of Acts and the Pauline epistles show us a people attempting to do just that. The gathering of those who follow Christ became a group participating in the body of Christ, and with it, they gained the real sense that their fullest knowledge of Christ—and perhaps of themselves—came in community.
While over the years, members of the Church argued (early and often), over worship, over spiritual practice, and over practically everything else, the universal church of Christ remains. It has been divided, particularly since the Protestant Reformation, and in America, denominationalism and individuality have stolen much of a sense of a holy, catholic, and universal apostolic church.
But the body of Christ is more than a set of denominations, more than a few national headquarters plopped down in Nashville, Louisville, or New York. It is where most Christians encounter God—and find God in the faces and voices of others who also seek God—and it is our link with all others who profess Christ as their path to God. As William Sloane Coffin wrote in Credo
It seems to me that in joining a church you leave home and home town to join a larger world. The whole world is your neighborhood, and all who dwell therein—black, white, yellow, red, stuffed and starving, smart and stupid, mighty and lowly, criminal and self-respecting, American and Russian—all become your sisters and brothers in the new family formed in Jesus. (143)
Like the little church shown at the end of Places in the Heart, filled with black and white, redeemed and sinning, even alive and passed on, the Church is the one place in human existence where we are all promised to belong, to God and to each other.
It is an imperfect institution, because it is made up of imperfect people. And still, the Church is the hope of the world.
In The Gospel According to Hollywood, from which this piece is drawn, I suggested that we can sift popular Hollywood films for their spiritual meaning, and argued that even in films that seem to have nothing to do with religion, we can find hints of divinity or life wisdom that have spiritual power. Paul Tillich was one of many modern theologians who have argued that we can discern "prophetic voices" in works of the culture, and he spoke often about a Latent Church in which "the ultimate concern that drives the manifest Church is hidden under cultural forms" (The Essential Tillich, 110). Although, until recently, faith and belief weren't explicit subjects in most movies, they can still be found.
Greg Garrett is (according to BBC Radio) one of America's leading voices on religion and culture. He is the author or co-author of over twenty books of fiction, theology, cultural criticism, and spiritual autobiography. His most recent books are The Prodigal, written with the legendary Brennan Manning, Entertaining Judgment: The Afterlife in Popular Imagination, and My Church Is Not Dying: Episcopalians in the 21st Century. A contributor to Patheos since 2010, Greg also writes for the Huffington Post, Salon.com, OnFaith, The Tablet, Reform, and other web and print publications in the US and UK.