Rowan Williams: Faithful Citizen
The Archbishop offers, on the page and in person, a gentle voice, but he does not shy away from prophetic words and telling hard truths. Like Stanley Hauerwas, he recognizes that our Western obsession with freedom has made it into a secular religion—and it has deformed our faith lives, or any possibility for them. In explaining, for example, why the spiritual seems more appealing to many people than the religious, he begins with a quotation from Bono about experiencing God individually, and he elegantly builds his argument from there:
Bono's remarks provide an obvious starting-point. Religion is a matter of the collective mentality, with all that this implies about having to take responsibility for corporately-held teaching and discipline; so religious allegiance can be seen as making over some aspect of myself to others in ways that compromise both my liberty and my integrity. It may be seen as committing myself to practices that mean little to me, or subjecting myself to codes of conduct that don't connect at all convincingly with my sense of who I am or what is creative and life-giving for me. It may mean being obliged to profess belief in certain propositions that appear arbitrary and unconnected with the business of human flourishing. (84)
It is, simply put, easier and less dangerous to our freedom-loving selves to be individually spiritual than it is to give up any of our autonomy and enter into the life of a religious community. But religious life is also the source, as Williams goes on to say, of gratitude, obedience, joy, yielding, relational intimacy. (92) As one might expect from the leader of millions of the world's Christians, the Archbishop locates much of the world's good in the teaching and practice of Christianity.
He also, however, believes ardently in conversation. He has convened multi-faith gatherings, and calls for the State to permit and encourage pluralism (an irony, since he is the head of England's established state church). Each of us, he notes, who take on a faithful religious identity, whether Christian, Hindu, Muslim, Jain, or whatever, "inhabit and accept an identity that is believed to be in tune with how the universe most deeply is, or with what God intends or desires . . . To belong in this way is to be a particular kind of human being." (134) We choose these ways of being, because we see something sacred and useful in them.
It is the interaction of these particular kinds of human beings that offers hope for the State and for the world in what Archbishop Williams calls "a fruitful context for an interreligious encounter that does not compromise convictions, but is also ready to envisage growth and change." (135) And he gives us in this book a beautiful and faithful example of how one can be consciously and determinedly religious—and still seek to love and learn from others.
Greg Garrett is (according to BBC Radio) one of America's leading voices on religion and culture. He is the author or co-author of over twenty books of fiction, theology, cultural criticism, and spiritual autobiography. His most recent books are The Prodigal, written with the legendary Brennan Manning, Entertaining Judgment: The Afterlife in Popular Imagination, and My Church Is Not Dying: Episcopalians in the 21st Century. A contributor to Patheos since 2010, Greg also writes for the Huffington Post, Salon.com, OnFaith, The Tablet, Reform, and other web and print publications in the US and UK.