Mainline Protestant Channel
Is 'Twilight" Bad News for Girls?
Elaine Heath is the author of numerous articles and books, including the forthcoming The Gospel According to Twilight: Sex, Gender, and God in the World of Stephenie Meyer (Louisville: Westminster/John Knox, 2011) from which this article is partially excerpted.
The books grew into a dark tower on my coffee table, one vampiric novel after another. It was Christmas time, hardly the season of the year to focus on the undead, but I was getting ready to teach a new class on the Gospel in Pop Culture, and I needed to find out why Twilight broke publishing and box office records. Second only to Harry Potter in its worldwide reach, the saga is a romantic adventure about a girl, Bella, who falls in love with a vampire, Edward, and is best friends with a werewolf, Jacob. I was barely a page into the first novel when I realized that there was more going on than just a romance. This was a theological story, too. And it was full of messages about gender. Though the theology intrigued me and the story is compelling, by the middle of the first novel I began to wonder, is Twilight bad news for girls?
The theme of violence against women runs throughout the Twilight series and is even more pronounced in Stephenie Meyer’s subsequent book The Host. From relatively mild boundary violations to gang rape, most of the women characters in Twilight have been victimized by men. What is most disturbing about Meyer’s treatment of this theme is that it is presented in ways that normalize, even romanticize such violence. Esme, Rosalie, Emily, and Alice have all been victims. Of these, Rosalie’s story is most disturbing with its fallacies about rape.
As Rosalie explains, before she was turned into a vampire she was happily engaged, dreaming of her future as a wife and mother. Then one night her drunken fiancé and his friends found her walking down a dark street. Overcome with desire for her because of her beauty, the men gang raped her and left her for dead. When Carlisle found her, she was about to die, so he changed her into a vampire.
Even as a “resurrected” vampire with more than human perspective, Rosalie believes that the sexual assault that took her life was initiated because of her beauty and desirability (Eclipse, 132). While she exacted vengeance upon her assailants, torturing and murdering them after she was a vampire, she still sees her own body as partial cause for what happened to her.
This is not the message readers need to hear. Rape is a crime of violence, not an act of sexual intimacy. Rape victims are never to blame for the violence of their perpetrators. Rape is never excusable because of a woman’s clothing, beauty, vulnerability, location, speech, or any other aspect of her person. There is never a justification for rape. It is telling that rape is widely used as a weapon in warfare because it utterly humiliates and devastates its victims.
My greatest disappointment with the Twilight series is Stephenie Meyer’s thematic representation of violence against women in a way that minimizes and normalizes abuse. No matter how wonderful it is that Meyer promotes sexual abstinence before marriage, a fact that elicits praise from many religious leaders about the series, she offers a terrible message about violence against women at the hands of their intimate partners. Few of those enamored religious leaders who praise Twilight even notice the saturating theme of violence against women in the novels.
Elaine A. Heath is an ordained minister in the United Methodist Church, the McCreless Associate Professor of Evangelism at Southern Methodist University, and the director of the Center for Missional Wisdom. She is the founder of New Day, a growing network of missional micro-communities of prayer and action in the United Methodist Tradition, and of the Epworth Project, a scholarship that provides seminary and college students opportunities to experience monastic rhythms of prayer and hospitality while living in households of intentional community. Visit her Expert Site at Patheos.