Phil Plait: Where the Sun Never Sets

Worth repeating, Phil Plait’s sterling words from 2005:

In April, I was asked to give a short speech to a group of local students who participated in a science fair. I wasn’t sure what to say to them, until I saw a newscast the night before the fair. The story was some typically inaccurate fluff piece giving antiscience boneheads “equal time” with science, as if any ridiculous theory should have equal time against the truth.

I sat down with a pad of paper and a pencil and scribbled down this speech. I gave it almost exactly as I wrote it.

I know a place where the Sun never sets.

It’s a mountain, and it’s on the Moon. It sticks up so high that even as the Moon spins, it’s in perpetual daylight. Radiation from the Sun pours down on there day and night, 24 hours a day — well, the Moon’s day is actually about 4 weeks long, so the sunlight pours down there 708 hours a day.

I know a place where the Sun never shines. It’s at the bottom of the ocean. A crack in the crust there exudes nasty chemicals and heats the water to the boiling point. This would kill a human instantly, but there are creatures there, bacteria, that thrive. They eat the sulfur from the vent, and excrete sulfuric acid.

I know a place where the temperature is 15 million degrees, and the pressure would crush you to a microscopic dot. That place is the core of the Sun.

I know a place where the magnetic fields would rip you apart, atom by atom: the surface of a neutron star, a magnetar.

I know a place where life began billions of years ago. That place is here, the Earth.

I know these places because I’m a scientist.

Science is a way of finding things out. It’s a way of testing what’s real. It’s what Richard Feynman called “A way of not fooling ourselves.”

No astrologer ever predicted the existence of Uranus, Neptune, or Pluto. No modern astrologer had a clue about Sedna, a ball of ice half the size of Pluto that orbits even farther out. No astrologer predicted the more than 150 planets now known to orbit other suns.

But scientists did.

No psychic, despite their claims, has ever helped the police solve a crime. But forensic scientists have, all the time.

It wasn’t someone who practices homeopathy who found a cure for smallpox, or polio. Scientists did, medical scientists.

No creationist ever cracked the genetic code. Chemists did. Molecular biologists did.

They used physics. They used math. They used chemistry, biology, astronomy, engineering.

They used science.

These are all the things you discovered doing your projects. All the things that brought you here today.

Computers? Cell phones? Rockets to Saturn, probes to the ocean floor, PSP, gamecubes, gameboys, X-boxes? All by scientists.

Those places I talked about before? You can get to know them too. You can experience the wonder of seeing them for the first time, the thrill of discovery, the incredible, visceral feeling of doing something no one has ever done before, seen things no one has seen before, know something no one else has ever known.

No crystal balls, no tarot cards, no horoscopes. Just you, your brain, and your ability to think.

Welcome to science. You’re gonna like it here.

Print Friendly

  • davidct

    There is nothing accomadationist about Phil when it comes to his passion for science and truth.

  • shouldbeworking

    I quit. There is no way I could ever top that in any of my science classes. Wow.

  • http://www.electricminstrel.com Brett McCoy

    Phil rocks! ‘Bad Astronomy’ should be on everyone’s blog reader

  • den1s

    that is the Phil I used to love.

  • Jeff Sherry

    Phil has a brilliance, but I’m still angry about his don’t be a dick lecture/stance.

    • http://freethoughtblogs.com/camelswithhammers Daniel Fincke

      Phil has a brilliance, but I’m petty and can’t handle the slightest philosophical disagreement or any criticism of my right to be a total asshole if I want to be.

      Fixed?

      • Jeff Sherry

        Dan, I don’t think that smoothed the philosophical waters.

      • Emburii

        No, not ‘fixed’.

        Maybe if Phil Plait had provided examples of what was so ‘dickish’ about ‘New’ Atheism people wouldn’t have objected nearly so much, but instead he just kind of tarred anyone vocally disagreeing over religion with gendered slurs.

        Also, cute how Jeff keeps it civil and focuses on his disagreement, and yet you attack Jeff as a person and his motives for being upset rather than discussing the actual point of the comment. You’re the petty one here.


Phil Plait: Where the Sun Never Sets

Worth repeating, Phil Plait’s sterling words from 2005:

In April, I was asked to give a short speech to a group of local students who participated in a science fair. I wasn’t sure what to say to them, until I saw a newscast the night before the fair. The story was some typically inaccurate fluff piece giving antiscience boneheads “equal time” with science, as if any ridiculous theory should have equal time against the truth.

I sat down with a pad of paper and a pencil and scribbled down this speech. I gave it almost exactly as I wrote it.

I know a place where the Sun never sets.

It’s a mountain, and it’s on the Moon. It sticks up so high that even as the Moon spins, it’s in perpetual daylight. Radiation from the Sun pours down on there day and night, 24 hours a day — well, the Moon’s day is actually about 4 weeks long, so the sunlight pours down there 708 hours a day.

I know a place where the Sun never shines. It’s at the bottom of the ocean. A crack in the crust there exudes nasty chemicals and heats the water to the boiling point. This would kill a human instantly, but there are creatures there, bacteria, that thrive. They eat the sulfur from the vent, and excrete sulfuric acid.

I know a place where the temperature is 15 million degrees, and the pressure would crush you to a microscopic dot. That place is the core of the Sun.

I know a place where the magnetic fields would rip you apart, atom by atom: the surface of a neutron star, a magnetar.

I know a place where life began billions of years ago. That place is here, the Earth.

I know these places because I’m a scientist.

Science is a way of finding things out. It’s a way of testing what’s real. It’s what Richard Feynman called “A way of not fooling ourselves.”

No astrologer ever predicted the existence of Uranus, Neptune, or Pluto. No modern astrologer had a clue about Sedna, a ball of ice half the size of Pluto that orbits even farther out. No astrologer predicted the more than 150 planets now known to orbit other suns.

But scientists did.

No psychic, despite their claims, has ever helped the police solve a crime. But forensic scientists have, all the time.

It wasn’t someone who practices homeopathy who found a cure for smallpox, or polio. Scientists did, medical scientists.

No creationist ever cracked the genetic code. Chemists did. Molecular biologists did.

They used physics. They used math. They used chemistry, biology, astronomy, engineering.

They used science.

These are all the things you discovered doing your projects. All the things that brought you here today.

Computers? Cell phones? Rockets to Saturn, probes to the ocean floor, PSP, gamecubes, gameboys, X-boxes? All by scientists.

Those places I talked about before? You can get to know them too. You can experience the wonder of seeing them for the first time, the thrill of discovery, the incredible, visceral feeling of doing something no one has ever done before, seen things no one has seen before, know something no one else has ever known.

No crystal balls, no tarot cards, no horoscopes. Just you, your brain, and your ability to think.

Welcome to science. You’re gonna like it here.

Print Friendly

  • davidct

    There is nothing accomadationist about Phil when it comes to his passion for science and truth.

  • shouldbeworking

    I quit. There is no way I could ever top that in any of my science classes. Wow.

  • http://www.electricminstrel.com Brett McCoy

    Phil rocks! ‘Bad Astronomy’ should be on everyone’s blog reader

  • den1s

    that is the Phil I used to love.

  • Jeff Sherry

    Phil has a brilliance, but I’m still angry about his don’t be a dick lecture/stance.

    • http://freethoughtblogs.com/camelswithhammers Daniel Fincke

      Phil has a brilliance, but I’m petty and can’t handle the slightest philosophical disagreement or any criticism of my right to be a total asshole if I want to be.

      Fixed?

      • Jeff Sherry

        Dan, I don’t think that smoothed the philosophical waters.

      • Emburii

        No, not ‘fixed’.

        Maybe if Phil Plait had provided examples of what was so ‘dickish’ about ‘New’ Atheism people wouldn’t have objected nearly so much, but instead he just kind of tarred anyone vocally disagreeing over religion with gendered slurs.

        Also, cute how Jeff keeps it civil and focuses on his disagreement, and yet you attack Jeff as a person and his motives for being upset rather than discussing the actual point of the comment. You’re the petty one here.


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X