Some questions that seem to need rewording in my charismatic spectrum questionnaire

Pop over to the charismatic spectrum post first before reading this one.

I have looked at the first batch of survey entries, and it seems clear that some of my questions are eliciting more “Yes’s” than they should, especially the beliefs section. So, any thoughts on why and how these selected questions need rewording so that a cessationist is more likely to disagree with them? This process of understanding what we do and do not believe is where the previous spectrum posts have proved most helpful, I feel. So given what I am driving at in these items, how should I make them less agreeable to non-charismatics? I have written some ideas below, would that do the job?

  • “I believe that God intends us to have an experiential relationship with him”
  • I believe that clapping and/or raising hands in worship is acceptable biblically
  • I believe that dancing in worship is acceptable biblically
  • I believe that God heals today in response to prayer
  • I believe that all the ministries of Ephesians 4 (apostle, prophet, evangelist, pastor and teacher) can still be given by God to his church

Possible rewrites that might make these statements less acceptable to cessationists:

  • “I believe that God invites us to pursue an ever deeper personal relationship with him”
  • I believe that the bible requires us to include clapping, and/or raising hands at times in our worship today
  • I believe that dancing before the Lord in worship is a biblical model that can and should be followed today
  • I believe that God heals supernaturally today in response to prayer
  • I believe that all the ministries of Ephesians 4 (apostle, prophet, evangelist, pastor and teacher) are still being given by God to his church
  • "Thank you for understanding that bipolar is an illness that does need medication and also ..."

    God’s word for the agitated and ..."
    "I am admittedly not a frequent or fervent faster, so take this with a grain ..."

    Jesus Commands: Fast, but not to ..."
    "Re 2, Christianity is not about personal 'happiness'."

    Jesus’ Commands: Be Born Again
    "Eh no. You are born once physically, and born again once into God's kingdom. You ..."

    Jesus’ Commands: Be Born Again

    Browse Our Archives

    Follow Us!


    What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment