Druid Thoughts: The Influence of Story

The vast majority of us will never read a book detailing the laws of the land we inhabit. Most of us will not study sociology or anthropology, either. Citizenship is on the syllabus for teenagers in the UK, but this is a relatively new thing. The norm and regulations that hold our cultures together are not formally taught, for the greater part. Social etiquette, expectation and the nuances of human interaction will never be part of those citizenship classes, either.

We learn a great deal by observing the behaviour of those around us. Our families and immediate neighbours supply us with information from the moment we are born. With the acquisition of language comes a vast array of tradition, assumption, belief, prejudice and ‘socialising’ alongside plenty of useful information about how the world works and how we should act. School introduces us to further social learning alongside the formal subjects. Sometimes what we pick up there doesn’t fit with what we already know, which can make life complicated. All new experiences have the potential to make us reconsider our views. Work spaces, neighbourhoods, and fashions oblige us to undertake lifelong learning just in order to fit in.

The Storyteller, by Eddi Van W.

For many people, the birth family also includes a technological member, beaming a whole array of tradition, assumption, belief, prejudice, social norms and useful things into our minds: many of us learn our core cultural ideas from our televisions and the internet. Before that, radio, books and newspapers filled a similar niche. Go back further and broadsheets, song sheets, the church and travelling theatre provided a similar, if reduced service. This pattern must go all the way back to the story tellers around the first camp fires, and I like to think it’s a lineage that includes the Druids of old. I’ll be back to dabble further in wild speculation later on. For now, let’s focus on what we know.No one sits a child down and explains to them the entirety of what is right and what is wrong by the standards of the society they live in. However, messages about how to behave are spoonfed to children from their earliest days.

Once upon a time, there was a beautiful princess, who was good and kind and liked soft, furry mammals. She had a lazy sister who was greedy and mean.

Fairy stories are full of these figures – characters who uphold virtues and are rewarded, alongside others who represent vices and are there to be punished. It is to a large extent through stories that we convey cultural values and absorb our earliest notions about how the world works.As we grow up, the stories and characters shared with us tend to get a bit more complex. However, every story (book, film, play, TV program, video game) that comes out of a culture is born to some extent from that culture’s values and assumptions. Consider the way in which the American film industry celebrates the hero with a gun in his hands. Think about the entirely unrealistic romance stories we keep generating. We give children the most surreal, brightly coloured, patronising and inane content to teach them… What? Not about the real world outside their doors, of that I feel certain. Then there are the soap operas and daytime reality and talk shows, full of angry and disrespectful language, verbal abuse, freak show treatments and a lot of shouting. The stories we tell to each other frequently scare me. So often, the solutions we’re offered revolve around violence, death, or having the loudest voice and the least willingness to listen or compromise. We offer abusive, destructive relationships as some kind of romantic ideal (Twilight, Fifty Shades), and we play games about killing things.

Stories are incredibly powerful things. They give us archetypes to draw on as we try, in our earliest years, to develop a sense of self. Stories take us outside immediate experience and show us a wider world, giving models for behaviour and ideas about how we may want to live our lives. Stories in any form have the potential to inform, inspire, uplift and enrich. This should be food for the soul. Turn on your television and watch the angry, the shouty, the attention-hungry, and the violent, or yet another advert-story that will sell you ideas of your own insufficiency to create demand for some needless product. Soul food stories are in short supply for many people.

Once upon a time there was a person who everyone had previously thought wasn’t clever or talented or important in any way. That person got onto a TV program. Everyone fell in love with them and voted for them, and so they became rich and famous and lived happily ever after.

This is the fairy story of our times in which no one mentions industry wolves, dragons of mental breakdown or the wicked step mother media. Once upon a time the fairy stories had grains of useful truth in them: Stay on the path. Don’t steal from witches. Be polite. Get off your arse and make an effort, because success will not beat a path to your door. Now we make marketing fairy tale about impossibly perfect families who live in impossibly perfect homes, and depression is a widespread ailment.

We have every reason to think that the Druids of old were keepers of knowledge – law, history and story were all part of that mix. Back before the advent of all this current technology, in a culture that refused to write things down, I imagine the importance of story may have been better understood. Here I dare to speculate a little. I imagine the bards, with their tales of heroism and tragedy, telling stories full of heart and truth. Stories to inspire and uplift. Tales of setback and struggle to guide the listeners through the trials of their own lives: Never give up. Be true to your beliefs. Don’t steal from witches. Show gratitude. Stories full of ideas to help people live alongside each other in peaceful and productive ways. Not so much of the angry, shouty violence, perhaps. In all fairness though, there were plenty of battles, and the Celts liked a good punch up as much as the next culture.

I come back, as I so often do, to the image of Cu Chulain and Feridad at the ford, fighting because honour demands it, duty demands it, but not killing each other for days because love and honour demand that too. Violence was part of the real lives of our Celtic ancestors. It wasn’t a fantasy game to them, but a harsh reality. I can’t imagine they would have a lot of time for our stories of shouty disrespect, hubris and blind stupidity.

Of course there are good modern stories out there too. Tales of heart and integrity are still being created, where a gun is not the only answer to conflict, and pain is not offered in pornographic terms. I rather suppose that our ancestors knew enough about suffering not to want or need to indulge in graphic representations of it. Our lives can be so far removed from the most essential things, it’s little wonder, perhaps, that so much modern story making now is intensely visceral in depicting sex and violence. Too many people are not grounded by close contact with the natural world. Our culture is not grounded, and so many stories offer us back only sickness and madness, in varying guises.

Telling stories has never been more important. It is from stories that we absorb so many of our assumptions and cultural norms. Stories can therefore be used to subvert and redirect the dominant thought forms in a culture. Consider the subversive work of Russian authors under communism. Remember Scheherazade, storytelling to survive a potentially lethal marriage. Storytellers have always included voices for counterculture, quiet rebellion and radical revision, not least because it’s tricky telling stories without intrinsic conflict in them. When there is conflict, there is always room to challenge the normal. All too often our modern storytellers do that by playing out established beliefs about how things work, rather than questioning them. The hero with the gun in his hand shoots the bad man, who also has a gun. The story of film so easily becomes the story of politics as well.

What are religions, if not a collection of stories gathered together for a specific purpose? Any religion, is a cluster of stories explaining how the world works, offering up archetypes and ideas for followers to emulate. Taking story out of a religious context does not make it any less a method for explaining things, but when we have religion wrapped around a story, it is easier to spot that there will be some kind of a point, some kind of message. I don’t think it’s possible to create stories that are free from assumption, moral framework, belief and intentions about how the world should be. It is all too possible to put stories into the world without considering that aspect of them, though. Or perhaps, in the quest to churn out an exciting best seller or blockbuster, the meaning comes a poor second. Just throw in a few more explosions and up the body count, that’ll keep them interested…

The morals of stories don’t tend to be pleasing when they’re too ‘in the face’. Subtler approaches can draw people in and smuggle ideas into heads without preaching or overwhelming. I’m particularly inspired by the work of Japanese film maker Hayao Miyazaki and his Studio Ghibli. Films like Spirited Away, Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind, and My Neighbor Totoro are soulful fairy stories full of green consciousness and compassionate humanity. These films attract a wide audience, proving that more thoughtful stories can be shared to good, commercial effect. I love the way that in Miyazaki films, violence is the problem, not the answer. We could use a lot more stories with that basic shape.

We are all storytellers. We share tales of our own lives, jokes, anecdotes and news. Even if we aren’t consciously telling stories, our unconscious narratives all contribute to and are part of the same process. Each of these more personal stories is an expression of culture, belief, and assumptions. Jokes have long been a medium for conveying and upholding prejudice – racism and sexism all find their audiences through supposed ‘comedy’. (Why does a woman have legs? So she can get from the bed to the sink.) When that kind of idea can (or is supposed to) provoke a laugh, even the smallest joke can create the society we live in. Dignity and power can be stripped away by ‘comedy’. But jokes and personal storytelling can also be used to subvert and re-imagine, to poke fun at prejudice, laugh away fear, and steer us towards mutual understanding. Laughter can be serious, political stuff.

We all have the option of thinking about the sorts of stories we pass on, from jokes to novels. Every story conveys a message about how the world could be, or how we think it is. Even if we aren’t innovating, most of us engage in the transmission of ideas. In so doing, we lend our hands to shaping the culture we live in, which shapes the stories that shape the culture. There’s incredible power in that process, one with which we could achieve a lot more than we currently do.

Once upon a time, there was a Druid…


Druid Thoughts is published on occasional Wednesdays on Agora. Follow it via RSS or e-mail!

About Nimue Brown

Druid blogger, author of Druidry and Meditation, Druidry and the Ancestors and Spirituality without structure (Moon Books) Intelligent Designing for Amateurs (Top Hat Books) and Hopeless Maine (Archaia). Book reviewer for the Druid Network and Pagan Dawn. Volunteer for OBOD. Green, folky, Steampunk wench with a coffee habit. www.druidlife.wordpress.com and www.hopelessmaine.com @Nimue_B and can be hunted down on facebook.

  • http://twitter.com/vogelbeere + Yvonne Aburrow

    This is a really great article, and I agree that stories are really important.

    Fairy tales often reinforce patriarchal messages, but they can be retold in more helpful ways, as Clarissa Pinkola Estes demonstrated with Women who run with the wolves.

    However, the thing that is bad about Fifty Shades of Grey is that the main character is a stalker and an abuser, not that it presents pain pornographically (it’s also unrealistic in that Christian Grey is “cured” of kink at the end). Most people in the BDSM community make an effort to ensure that their kinky activities are consenting and pleasurable for the parties involved.

  • Adam Sargant

    Splendid article, thank you… I’ve been spending time recently thinking about the obligations of the storyteller… while I think an artist’s first obligation may be considered to be to their art, we seem to have lost track of the obligations we have to the story… and to its audience. We don’t seem to want to ask what is right fro the storyteller to do, only what works, what has impact

  • JWalls

    This is a lovely article. You put in words what I always think about how our values came to be and how important story is in all forms. I myself am not a pagan or a druid (I’m a weak atheist that broke away from a fundamentalist christian background), but I really like and feel a connection with “Druid thoughts.” I appreciate articles like this.

    • http://www.facebook.com/chkraemer13 Christine Hoff Kraemer

      Thanks for this comment! As Pagan channel editor, feedback like this warms my heart. :)

  • Pingback: yellow october


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X