‘It is Not Good for Man to Be Alone’– Five Months Later

To the right you will see me and my family in an old style photo shot in Silverton Colorado. We were on our Wild West trip of a lifetime in 1992 which took us from New Orleans to San Antonio to Carlsbad Caverns to Tucson to the Grand Canyon to Four Corners, to Grand Junction and to various places in Colorado finishing in Denver. It was a terrific trip, and a good time was had by all. That’s my Christy standing behind me to the left.

But now she is gone to be with the Lord for five months, and some days it just seems unreal and impossible that this has happened. How is it possible my soul asks me? And some days I have no answers other than that life is fragile. I am reminded of a tombstone we saw in Silverton that said ‘Here lies the body of Lester Moore, shot in the back with a 44, no Less, no more.’ Some days I feel like I’ve been shot, but by the grace of God I’m still standing, still moving, still working.

There is a certain numbness, a certain emptiness that sets in when the ongoing reality of sudden death and it implications take hold. There are no do overs in such a situation, no reprieve, no going back. You can only go forward and learn to bear, and bear with your loss. Time does help, but honestly there isn’t a day that goes by that I don’t think about Christy and of course I miss her terribly. She was one of the main joys of my life, just to hear her voice among other things…. but now, quoth the raven– ‘never more’.

My friend Bill Arnold talked to me the other day about how grief comes in waves. Picture yourself on a beach minding your own business talking to a friend or family member. You are near to the ocean. Yes, you can feel the ebb and flow of the tide as it laps at your feet, but it seems inconse-quential. Inconsequential, that is, until suddenly a big wave comes and knocks you down. You stand, it knocks you down again. The tide is coming in, and you were unprepared for it. Grief is like that.

I was sitting in my office the other day just before Father’s Day and there was a card from some 10 years ago, a card 2 feet high and 1 foot wide, sitting on my filing cabinet. It was from my sweet pea Christy. She of course was wishing me a very happy father’s day. Just seeing her signature at the bottom ‘love Christy’ and thinking of when she wrote that—- well it was a big wave. There will be no more Father’s Day cards from Christy.

I guess one of the main lessons I have learned from this whole devastating experience is that we were made for relationship by God, and when one of your most intimate relationships vanishes, is snatched away in an instant, you feel the absence of that person’s presence viscerally, vitally, on-goingly. And it hurts, it aches, it nags at you again and again like the tendinitis I have in my right elbow. It is not good for man to be alone says Genesis, and how very much I feel that truth these days.

It’s a funny thing– being left alone. In one sense when you have a devastating loss you want to be ‘left alone’ to some extent. You can do without the platitudes or the pity. But in another sense you do not want to be left alone. Indeed, its unhealthy to be left alone when you have such a deep shock and grieve so deeply. Then, above all times, you need someone to give you a hug, to reassure you that there is more to life, to remind you that Christ came that we might have life everlasting, and so on. The experience of Christy taking an early exit from this world while I am ‘left behind’ has given new meaning to that phrase for me as well.

Why was I left behind, I keep asking myself? Why couldn’t I have taken this embolism for her? There are no adequate answers to such questions. None. Its important to remain honest and real in such a circumstance and not give way to delusions, but honesty in this case is a bowl of grits served cold and three days old. It leaves no good taste in my mouth and hardly seems nourishing.

As the legal process, and the process of selling off Christy’s things winds down now, there is some relief, some ability to exhale and feel that the worst of the initial disaster is behind us. But there is still the ongoing sadness to cope with, the ongoing ‘neverness’ to deal with (as Nicholas Wolterstorff says)— never to see my sweet pea again in this life, never to hear her voice and feel her hug, never to go to Carolina game with her again or share a song with her again. Never is a very long time.

Perhaps for the first time I have really begun to understand why some older people choose to live in the past. It’s because it’s the only place they can find their dearly departed loved ones. It reminds me of a song by Elton John entitled Talking Old Soldiers. One of the verses asks—-

“Well do they know what it’s like
To have a graveyard as a friend
`Cause that’s where they are boy, all of them
Don’t seem likely I’ll get friends like that again”

The other day I went to the graveyard. I touched the spot where I laid my Christy to rest. I said a prayer. I saw someone had left a vase of purple flowers below the spot. They were beautiful and Christy, the purple girl, would have loved them. I have no idea who did that or even if they were for Christy, but they sure were appropriate. You want to ask— how can the sun still be shining and living flowers still be beautiful and yet Christy is dead?

What is needed above all in this situation is love. Lots of love and understanding from remaining family and friends. And perhaps an extra measure of patience by the aforementioned group. I am not myself quite yet. Perhaps I will never entirely be my old self again. Indeed, I will predict I will not be that self again.

Christy won’t need my fatherly advice any more. She’s now got better help than I could offer. And the mundane things of life don’t trouble her any more thank goodness. She has no more debts to pay, praise the Lord. She is not hurting any more, thank God. But I am hurting precisely because there was so much love before, and right now– it’s not good for me to be alone. And that’s a fact. And that’s alright. Thanks to all who have been helping us cope with such cold hard facts, including of course God’s secret agent— the Holy Spirit.

  • CJ Tan

    Dear Dr Ben,

    Thanks for your sharing. Your faith and obvious devotion to the Lord Jesus even in the midst of suffering this grevious loss is a blessing and encouragement to me and I’m sure to many.

    May our Resurrected Lord grant you a fresh vision and hope of Christy bodily raised with an immortal, glorious body in the day of our Lord Jesus Christ. Amen.

    Blessings,
    CJ Tan

  • Tom Schuessler

    Ben: My guess is that I am not alone among those who follow you in saying that I wish I could meet you face to face so that I could offer my deepest sympathies to you and Mrs. Witherington and your son. Tom Schuessler, Mayville, WI

  • http://patricklmitchell.wordpress.com Patrick Mitchell

    Dr. Ben, as you have ministered to many of us reading, may our prayers be a ministry to you and yours.

    Patrick

  • http://www.banditsnomore.com Richard Heyduck

    I think not only of the huge holes in our lives when those closest to us “leave us alone.” I also think of the many friends and others to whom we’ve been attached who simply disappear. Every year at annual conference it seems that another person I know has dropped out, with no explanation, never to be seen or heard from again. I think of church folks, apparently happy families, that suddenly aren’t, but all going their separate directions.

    Thanks for the good words.

  • Kathi Branahl

    Thank you for sharing your insight and your faith with us, even as you experience such an overwhelming loss. I am praying that God would flood your heart with his peace.

  • Ross Bailey

    Wish we were able to visit Wilmore at this moment to give you a ‘Canadian’ hug and buy you a cup of your favorite coffee.

    Ross & Carol Bailey

  • Wyatt E Fenno

    Ben,
    The Lord be with you…. May all your memories be filled to overflowing with the everlasting hope of the gospel.

  • Ben Witherington

    Thanks Ross and Carol: We miss ya’ll…..

    Ben

  • Carol

    Dear Dr. Ben,

    My name is Carol and my husband is Jim. We lost our 19 year-old daughter, Sarah, quite suddenly to pulmonary embolism on December 16, 2011. It has been by far the most unimaginable pain ever and has caused us to have to make a decision concerning our faith: this is where the rubber meets the road–either we believe He is who He says He is or we don’t. We choose to believe and have asked God to give us what we need to represent Him well in this worst of all nightmares. My pastor forwarded your article to me and I then purchased your book. I have read it four times now. My husband has also. It has provided us grounding and hope and such wonderful assurance of the scriptures and a hope for the future. Thank you for sharing your experience…we know we are not alone in our grief and so appreciate your faith and words of hope. It still hurts so very much ….

  • Ross Bailey

    Wish we were able to visit Wilmore at this moment to give you a ‘Canadian’ hug and buy you a cup of your favorite coffee.

    Ross & Carol Bailey

  • Ben Witherington

    Thanks Carol. It’s amazing but I have had more than a few testimonies like yours in this email, and so yes, we are not alone, and we have decided to respond in the same way. Blessings, Ben W.

  • http://Oppfumc.org Charles Satterwhite

    Your teaching at the Alabama West Florida Annual Conference was sterling. I am always touched by your profound anointed teaching. John 8 was a wonderful reminder of His powerful Grace. I was deeply touched how the Comforter touched you during the loss of your daughter Christy. What a reunion we all will have one day…thanks for sharing.

  • http://jeffreymark.typepad.com Jeffrey Taylor

    Dr. Witherington,
    I have been following your grief now off and on since the death of your daughter. I am pastor at 1st UMC in Plainview, Tex. and 1982 ATS graduate. Its been three years now since my son Adam died in Austin, Tex. alone by a heroine overdose. Those waves of pain continue. In fact I write this note with tears streaming down my face. My wife’s father died a few months after Adam. Plus, that same year we moved from a very difficult ministry situation to one much more positive. The pain will continue. My world was blown to pieces. My thoughts and emotions are like a jigsaw puzzle and I’m trying to put this puzzle together. I will probably end up getting a counselor. I too feel the need for affection at times. I want someone to hold me. Not a good thing when you are a pastor because plenty of seductive women out there would like to oblige you. The tragedy makes us strain at emotional gnats. My wife and I have become sensitive to little things. That’s good when empathizing with others; bad when a couple desperately needs each other. So far God’s grace has been most recognizable through the openness and cooperation of my current congregation. And, when Im still, late at night, I sense the Comforter’s presence. To me he really is real. He does walk or in this case lay beside me and is even in me. Its a mystery. I do not understand. But, he’s real, that’s all I can say.

    I guess I write this because I’ve been there and done that. I too hate platitudes. No amount of spiritual platitudinal talk will ease the pain. Others simply do not understand. You will, however, be ok. Something inside me, (God’s spirit) assures me I will be ok. Don’t ask me how or why. And of course we preach the resurrection as the crowning point of our faith. I guess we must hold on with all the emotional muscle we can muster, to this great truth.

    Just know that there are others out there like myself who are walking with you.

    In Christ,
    Jeff Taylor

  • Dee Dowdy

    Dr. Ben,
    Thanks for writing this. Can’t imagine the pain but please know you’ve got two people in Alex City AL who love, respect and thank God for you being in their lives.
    Dee
    Phil 1:3

  • RickC

    Not being a parent I can’t fully empathize with you and your kin on the death of your daughter. The pain, no doubt, is deep and probably long to heal for all involved. But in thinking of her death I can’t help but think of all those children in the world who have never had the love and attention and fondness Christy had. I can’t help but think of all those children in the world that have never known the love and friendship and guidance and discipline a parent gives to a child. I can’t help but think of those children that might have been a Wesley or a Spurgeon or a Newton or a Jobs or an ordinary joe loving his own children. To me the death of any child is a terrible loss whether 3, 13 or 32. I also wonder why God allows it and what purpose is achieved. What hurts the most I suppose is that some have had a chance to live even though they haved died young but some have never had a chance to live or love or serve. Yet somehow, in all of this, is God’s purpose. There is purpose in the death of child?!? Seems so incongruent with a loving God. Especially when you think about all those tender and loving and caring and devoted moments one gives to a growing child. A homeless child with no parents is the worst! To me that’s a living death! Jesus said, when you have done it to the least of these you have done it to me! That’s what makes christianity so alive to me. I don’t think any christian that will ever traverse life without experienceing/knowing 1 Thess 5:18. Yes I suppose it is hard to give thanks for the loss of a daughter. I’m not sure I could be strong enough to do that.