Less is More

Last Sunday, my husband finally broke.  Our schedule was packed, our luggage was not unpacked, the children were whiny and at least one of them could not find his shoes on the way out the door for Mass.  “The stuff” he said, as he says from time to time, “has taken over.”  Now, you know that we like to declutter and that we have done some re-arranging this spring, so we don’t have piles of random stuff all over, the “super-fling boogie” kind of stuff that you can quickly recognize as clutter, we were down to the good stuff, clothes that fit, toys and books that we use, but there was still just too much of it to manage.

As a city child, I was blessed to spend my summers in rental houses in the country.  You had fresh air, swimming lessons, and only as many worldly possessions as could fit in a suitcase.  This was the sort of summer I longed for, and our things were getting in the way.

After Mass, we had the children clean out the car while we made a nice breakfast.  Then, we all sat down to blueberry pancakes and mulled over the plan.  Dad would give you old moving boxes and trash bags, and you were to remove almost everything from your room.  Things could go to the basement, trash or goodwill, and the basement things could come back a little bit at a time if you succeed in keeping your bed made, towel hung up and wet swimsuit off the floor.

I started in the nursery, and removed everything but one small basket of books for bedtime stories.  I could see the carpet for the first time in months.  For me, it is still really difficult to “fling” toys which have sentimental value or which I know have good play potential, so I was freed by the idea of just putting the things in the basement, I didn’t have to make the tough choices.  Right now, I am telling myself that anything that sits in the basement for a year will be given away.

The big kids started on their own, but Dad and I eventually stepped in to help.  The girls were amazed that they filled one large black bag of just trash from their room — old art projects, silly bands (“no longer cool”), single barbie shoes, and the broken bins that had been holding all this junk.  All the books off of a bookcase were boxed up, whereupon the bookcase collapsed, probably in exhaustion from the strain.  We need a new plan/place for storing the early novels which are between children right now, but the closet floor was not a good answer.

I have to admit, this all felt extremely harsh while we were doing it, but the tone in the house was not tense or angry.  The children seemed to realize, as we did, that this was liberating.  We were not asking them to make choices about what they needed or loved, to worry about how long they had it or who gave it to them, everything was out.

After three hours of solid work, there were two or three bags in the trash, four bags on the porch for pick up, and about 10 boxes in the basement.  We headed off to a graduation party, leaving a clean house behind us.

The week which followed has been amazing.  I can’t say that the children make their beds without being asked, though some do, but when I ask them to do a simple task — make your bed, put away your laundry or get dressed, they do it without a moan and without getting distracted and stopping to play along the way.

We have been cheerfully up and out and on time for swim practice EVERY DAY, with NO YELLING.

We spent an afternoon at the library, and I have felt free, as I used to in our small apartments, to sit and read in the afternoons to the children, book after book after book, without worrying about what else needed to get done.

Here is what they have for toys right now:  In the school room, wooden blocks and one bin of matchbox cars. In the boys room, big bin of legos and brio trains.  In the girls room, friendship bracelet making supplies.  The first night they chose to take back a stuffed animal or two each to sleep with, but since then not much has been coming up from the basement, no one seems to want more stuff.

Winter will come, and with it more time to play indoors, and we will want the marble run or doll clothes from time to time, but in the fall I want to figure out a way to store these things in the basement or an extra closet so that they really get put away and taken out, so that they are not part of our decor each day.  I think that as I put the things into a permanent storage, it will be easier to make decisions about what we really want to keep.  That will take a whole weekend, I imagine.

From September-December we have 6 birthdays and Christmas, so I am already thinking of ways to ask for gifts which do not add to the accumulation.  I really do not want to lose the joy of these occasions while worrying about managing the stuff, and I want my children to feel loved and gifted by those relatives that want to show love in that way.  Hopefully a focus on experiences will help — I am thinking of giving them each an afternoon alone with me for their birthdays.

This week I also got a postcard from a local homeless organization asking for help with backpacks and other basic school supplies for the children they serve.  These children face want and stress which I cannot imagine, so it made me feel sort of sick to realize that we have been creating feelings of want and stress in our family by misunderstanding our blessings.  I hope to be able to channel my strong desire not to accumulate more stuff by cutting back on shopping and giving more to HomeFront.

On Friday, it was time to pack to head to my parents’ house for the holiday weekend.  With an unpleasant, traffic filled and long drive ahead of us, this has always been a stressful task for me in the past, so much so that it almost ruins the weekend.  This year, it was totally different.  After lunch, I gave each child a small chore (take out the trash, see that windows are closed, etc).  Then I had them all bring their suitcases to my (clean) bedroom.  I gave them one small packing assignment at a time (bring me two pairs of pajamas, etc).  They were all doing the same task, so I did not have to keep track.  They brought the clothes as put them in the bag.  Even Leo, who is 3!  packed his own bag.  Bring me a church outfit, bring me a swim suit, bring me your toothbrush.  Now, that one threw me for a loop — Mary asked, should we put it in the little travel toothbrush bag — something I bought but which used to get lost in the shuffle?

Every child packed their bag, put it in the car and, when we arrived, brought it into the house — without being asked.  My kids have never carried their own luggage before.  For the weekend, they kept their bags with them and (more or less) kept track of their own things.  Except for a few cases of lost flip-flops, I did not find myself searching for or stepping over their things all weekend.  What an amazing difference this made to me.

I feel incredibly gifted by this decision to have less in our rooms right now, and amazed by the results.  I think I underestimated the toll that cleaning up was taking on all of us.  Now we have less stress, less anger, more time, more fun, more joy.  We are able to focus on what we should be doing at any given moment, not distracted by the mess, or just the stuff, around us.  We are more present to one another.

  • Julia Attaway

    I am SO with you on this! And the truth is, kids can play with a rubber band all afternoon if that’s all they have, and be happy. I’m about 1/3 of the way through a major purge here, and feel like I’ll be ready for a second round as soon as I’m done!

  • http://www.megnanimity.blogspot.com mjdmom

    This is what I needed to attack our playroom and bedrooms.u00a0 I am so the one who wants to keep the sentimental toys- like the plastic NOah’s arc I gave my first born on his first birthday oh so long ago.

  • Texas Mommy

    u00a0You wrote: “realize that we have been creating feelings of want and stress in our family by misunderstanding our blessings.”nMaryAlice, I think you are right on with this comment. I have very similar attacks of conscience when I realize that I slip into becoming a manager of stuff and schedules rather than a mother of children.u00a0Then we are constantly thinking on new organization systems to manage all the extraneous stuff.u00a0I think this is where books like Simplicity Parenting and A Mother’s Rule of Life are helpful to encourage us to purge those things which do not help us in our pursuit of holiness and unnecessarily burden us.u00a0nnWe recently instituted a no breakfast until your room is spotless and bed is made. This was always sort of the idea, but now I am going upstairs to check, which, of course, it very necessary.u00a0

  • Rightsaidred Builder

    I love this post.u00a0 We just did a major toy purge around here because Charlie threw up and I wanted to disinfect everything so that Gus didn’t get sick.u00a0 I washed every soft toy, wiped down every other toy, and anything that couldn’t be cleaned was thrown away!u00a0 We have a general rule against toys in the kids rooms.u00a0 But that rule is slowly broken over time and needs to be reinforced.u00a0 I think it is harder to enforce as the kids get a bit older…but the toddler do not need things in their room.u00a0 Your post has inspired me to continue getting rid of unnecessary things.u00a0 It really does make life so much easier and fun!

  • JMB

    I live in a pre-World war 2 colonial that has miniscule closets.u00a0 One of the things I did from the get go was not allow any toys in the childrens’ rooms.u00a0 Basically, just clothes, books, stuffed animals.u00a0 Now that the youngest is 9, the stuffed animals are on the death watch.u00a0 I will toss them soon.u00a0 I am not sentimental by nature, and I have found that my children rarely (if ever!) asked to play with toys that I had tossed or given away.u00a0 Maybe they are just very uncreative and simple, but they didn’t even notice.u00a0 The only stuff that I held onto was outside toys that could be passed down – bikes, scooters, tricycles, rollerblades, skate boards.u00a0 That stuff was used consistently.u00a0 nnAs for birthdays, we do trips or experiences now, rather than gifts.u00a0 I’ve taken each one of my daughters to Chicago to visit the AG store and sight see.u00a0 We started doing that before they built the store in NYC, and had such a great time that we’ve continued it.u00a0 My husband has taken my son to his favorite team’s stadium (in Texas) for a home game.u00a0 Those are far more valuable than getting a new toy.u00a0 We’ve also done Broadway plays and theme restaurants and concerts and stuff like that.u00a0 Also, once the child hits 10, no more elaborate friend birthday parties.u00a0

  • Rebecca Elmuccio

    Sounds like you had a productive and clarity-inducing weekend. We are huge fans of Pick Up Please. I love that it saves us a trip and gets the super fling boogie clutter out of our house!

  • Jurismater

    Agreed. This is great, bravo MaryAlice. The most hospitable family in our school is able to be so hospitable because they have a beautiful, orderly, and MOST inviting home. Not fancy, but beautiful. I was sitting in their extra bedroom nursing the baby recently during a pool party, reflecting on what makes their home so inviting. It’s clean lines. The tabletops and counters don’t have knick knacks, only a carefully-considered picture frame, a holy statue, or a fresh vase of flowers. The bookshelves aren’t vomiting books, they are neat and well thought out. The beds are simple, but made. As we rearrange to accommodate our new baby, I’m focusing on the same thing: clean lines. Anything that regularly interrupts a clean line needs to be stored (if it will be used soon) or donated (if it won’t be used soon).

    • Cecilia

      I’ve had our house on the market this spring, and I like it a lot better prepped to show for just the reasons you give. I found lots of helpful tips online for house staging & showing that are all about clean lines, no clutter, etc. There’s plenty of good stuff at the HGTV website, but some real estate sites have more concise principles or rules for inviting, simplified space organization.n

  • http://www.buildingcathedrals.com Kat

    When we went on vacation in June, someone had given the advice that we pack light, especially in terms of activities for the kids. This made a huge positive difference in our travel experience!u00a0nAlso, JM, I love that you say that we should either donate or store items…There is, of course, a time to throw away items that are no longer able to be used by anyone, but I’m all for re-purposing if at all possible! Otherwise, the items will end up in a landfill, and I just hate that idea! We’ve done our fair share of throwing old items away, but I always feel badly seeing the piles of trash bags in our driveway – a good incentive not to accumulate too much stuff in the first place!

    • Mary Alice

      Vacation always inspires me to simplify — I love living in hotel rooms, where there is so little extra stuff.u00a0 It makes my mom laugh, all this about the clean lines, because she prefers when a house looks like people actually live there.u00a0 Wealthy, sophisticated, neat people, but still personal stuff around.u00a0 It is hard to find the right line here, because our personal stuff is just not so attractive at this stage.

  • Lisa

    Hello ladies.u00a0 Interesting topic, MA – decluttering seems to be a theme in your posts, and an issue that appears to resonate with many of us.u00a0 My question for anyone who can share — do you have suggestions on how to avoid accumulating this stuff from the beginning?u00a0 My husband and I aren’t yet parents, yet we’ve already had several discussions on how to avoid the toy build-up that so many friends have.u00a0 An idea I read on a listserve once for Christmas gifts is to implement a 3-gift policy — Jesus got 3 gifts (there were 3 wisemen), and surely a child doesn’t need more than Jesus received!u00a0 I plan to share that philosophy with our extended family, explaining we’d love a single gift from each side of the family and we as parents will give a single gift as well.u00a0 What I wonder, though, is if there are other suggestions you all can offer to help avoid toy clutter — whether received via gifts or self-purchased.u00a0 Thanks ladies!u00a0

  • JMB

    I used to periodically rotate toys in and out of circulation.u00a0 I also threw out (and still do) anything that breaks, is missing a crucial piece, or makes weird loud random noises.u00a0 I don’t think you need to tell people not to send gifts- people do that from a place of love and generosity and that is good- but what you can do is manage it from your home.u00a0 That is easier to do than offending people. nnAnother way to look at the toy problem is to accept that toys, like food, wine, clothing and books, can and do have a shelf life and it’s ok to look at that $10 piece of plastic and say “wow, we’ve gotten our ten dollars worth out of that toy and now it’s time to say goodbye”.u00a0

  • Kaitlin

    My mom gave me a “day alone with her” for my birthday one year. I have never forgotten how much fun we had that day!