When I joined a new gym, I was given a questionnaire from the personal training department. Was I joining the gym to: lose weight, gain fitness, increase endurance for a specific sport, make friends, rehab an injury, manage stress?
The statement underneath this question said “Participants who know their goals are more likely to stick with an exercise program.”
I thought that this was great advice, and I have taken to applying it to other activities that I choose for myself and my family. We can’t do everything, and we have discussed that there are times to push and times to quit, but those decisions are complicated and nuanced and sometimes it helps to think about the goal of the program in the first place.
For example, if my kid does not excel at a sport but enjoys the social atmosphere of the team, and the coaches and other athletes are kind and supportive, that team might be worth doing IF socialization and fun are the goals. If skill building or gaining confidence at the sport are the goals, time might be better used in private lessons for a while.
If fitness is a goal for a sedentary child, it might take some work to find an activity that they really enjoy and will participate actively in. That child might not be a good fit for baseball where he might day dream in the outfield, he may be better off in a sport like swimming where he is forced to keep moving all the time.
I don’t really have a value judgement to make about various goals — developing a star athlete might be an appropriate goal for some, but inappropriately intense for others; being part of a community might be important to a homeschooled child, but a child who is totally peer driven might be better off forgoing an activity in favor of dinner and a board game with mom and dad sometimes. Your child might need to gain confidence by being good at something or on the contrary might really benefit from the resiliency learned from losing from time to time. Some children need to learn to relax and have fun, others need a push towards applying some focus and intensity, and different programs, as well individual coaches, will be better fits for different goals.
When I am driving my children around, when I am leaving a sink full of dirty dishes and spending my limited babysitting money on childcare during late night activities rather than date nights, I’d better be sure that it is worth it, and I can only know that if I figure out why we chose the activity in the first place.