As I write this, the massive hunt to find the remaining suspect in the Boston Marathon bombings, 19-year-old Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, has just ended. When the Tsarnaev brothers’ photos were circulated this past Thursday, catalyzing the extraordinary efforts to capture them, I experienced a number of emotions and thoughts. And among them was a reflexive, admittedly selfish prayer: “Thank you, God, that the suspects are not Asian or Asian-American.”
I was remembering 2007 when Seung Hui Cho unleashed violence on Virginia Tech’s campus, and how my heart stopped to see a fellow Korean-American was the perpetrator of such an unspeakable act. And I was also thinking of my fellow citizens who were also very likely relieved not to see someone who looked like them in those widely circulated FBI photos.
The Boston Globe featured a column on Thursday that quoted a local imam who asked, “What will happen to us if they arrest someone and that someone turns out to be a Muslim?” And as it turned out, the suspects did have ties to Islam. Older brother Tamerlan is believed to be associated with a YouTube channel featuring videos “embraced by Islamic extremist(s)”, according to The Boston Globe; younger brother Dzhokhar self-identified as a follower of Islam on his VKontakte (the Russian equivalent of Facebook) page.
However, whenever people imagine what a Muslim extremist looks like, they probably do not envision ethnic Chechens. In a city on-edge from the blatant, brazen attack on one of its beloved sporting traditions and the subsequent manhunt, Bostonians began making their own judgments and enacting their own form of vigilante justice: a Muslim woman was punched and verbally abused in the Boston area by someone who shouted, “F*** you Muslims!” and “You are involved in the Boston explosions.”
She was not the only one. Some of the earliest post-bombing reports showed other individuals of Middle Eastern descent under suspicion, most notably the Saudi international who found himself a quick target of the initial investigation supposedly due to his suspicious post-bombing behavior. It’s more likely that it was due to his ethnic background, to how he looked.
Here in America, we pride ourselves as being a nation of immigrants, as we all are unless we are direct descendants of American Indians. How often have we heard the President wax eloquently on our country’s openness to people of all races, creeds, and religions, that it is this very openness that makes our nation great? Yet at the same time, America still has an immature understanding of what it means to consider all Americans truly American.
(These tweets are some of the tamer ones. Go to this site if you have the stomach to see the more offensive and profane ones.)
If this is the reaction of Americans to a made-up example of terrorism, just imagine the outcry and outrage had the Boston Marathon bombing suspects been of Asian descent, or Middle Eastern, or black, or Hispanic, or any other non-white American or national.
As it turned out, the prescient title of the Salon piece was nearly spot on. On April 19, the police captured 19-year-old Dzhokhar, naturalized last year. In other words: a white American. And as far as I can tell, there has been no collective outrage from other “white Americans” that one of their own is the alleged cause of Monday’s mayhem in Boston. While I’m glad that there has been no evident increase in anti-Chechen sentiment here in America, I wish I could trust that this same restraint would manifest itself when suspects are non-white as well.
Perhaps the next time something like this happens — and tragically, it’s guaranteed that somewhere, someone is plotting their own twisted take on what Boston recently experienced — we will have learned both from this whole horrifying incident as well as from the accompanying rush to inappropriate and misguided judgment. Perhaps we will have reached a maturity level in which we avoid knee-jerk stereotyping that only hampers justice rather than further it.
That is a future worth prayers from us all.