Doctor Who’s Doctrine, Part 3: Exterminating Evil

Before “Doctor Who” officially turns 50 this November, Christ and Pop Culture will spend 12 weeks delving deep into the science-fiction series phenomenon. Read Part 1. Then read Part 2

Whenever I talk about Doctor Who with others, the conversation often turns to the show’s cheesiness. As a fan, I don’t mean that disparagingly, but fellow fans, let’s be honest, shall we? From the special effects to the set designs, from the alien costumes to the overwrought acting (e.g., Matt Smith’s twirling and flailing), Doctor Who can be a bit on the corny side. Of course, that’s all part of the show’s charm, but it can be an understandable obstacle for newbies to overcome.

When I started watching the show — and more specifically, Russell T. Davies’ 2005 revival — I experienced a bit of a disconnect. On the surface, the show seemed like a lark when you considered the technobabble about “sonic screwdrivers” and “spatio-temporal hyperlinks,” the outlandish storylines and characters, i.e., that cheesy stuff. And yet, a darkness and sense of tragedy lurked on the show’s edges, ready to storm in without any warning.

When you first meet the Doctor, in any of his incarnations, he seems like a walking bag of eccentricities, from his fashion sense to his mannerisms. But what has been part of the revival’s brilliance is its revelations that the Doctor, for all his brilliance and derring-do, is a shell of an alien. All his eccentricities actually conceal a demi-god who verges on breakdown, and he’s certainly more than the benevolent-yet-eccentric savior we may think. He’s a “mad man with a box” — and the emphasis is on mad.

The Doctor vs. The Daleks

Fans glimpsed this early on during “The End of the World,” the rebooted series’ second episode. The Doctor, now in his ninth incarnation (Christopher Eccleston), takes his new companion Rose (Billie Piper) on her first trip in the TARDIS, five billion years in the future to witness Earth’s final moments. Of course they are soon caught up in a dangerous caper, during which we learn that he is the last of his race, the Time Lords.

Later in that season, during the episode “Dalek,” the Doctor reunites with his greatest foe, the Dalek race. Now we find that not only is the Doctor the last Time Lord, but that he caused his race’s demise as a gambit to save the universe from the consequences of their long war with the Daleks. After the Doctor spews his hatred for the Dalek race, a captured Dalek makes a devastating observation: “You would make a good Dalek,” it slowly intones. It isn’t until Rose prevents the Doctor from committing further genocide that we may see the Doctor for what he truly is — something potentially worse even than the evil Daleks.

YouTube Preview Image

The Doctor vs. The Doctor

Traveling in time and space, the Doctor has faced many evils: Daleks, Cybermen, Sontarans, a Devil-like entity, even Hitler. But as River Song says in “A Good Man Goes to War,” after the Doctor’s great victory:

You make them so afraid. When you began all those years ago, sailing off to see the universe, did you ever think you’d become this? The man who can turn an army around at the mention of his name. “Doctor,” the word for “healer” and “wise man” throughout the universe. We get that word from you, y’know. But if you carry on the way you are, what might that word come to mean? To the people of the Gamma Forests, the word “doctor” means “mighty warrior.” How far you’ve come. And now they’ve taken a child, the child of your best friends, and they’re going to turn her into a weapon, just to bring you down. And all this, my love, in fear of you.

The Doctor can generate such fear at the mere mention of his name that his greatest enemies, many of them galactic butchers, join together to trap him in a perfect prison, lest he bring about the end of the universe. Their sins, it seems, are nothing compared to his wicked potential.

Sometimes this fearful wrath is shown as good — a force of true justice and almost sacred punishment. In one of my favorite displays of the Doctor’s unchecked power, the Tenth Doctor (David Tennant) coolly and silently consigns a group of aliens that have been hunting him to eternal punishments. For example, he forces one to live in a collapsing galaxy’s event horizon and traps another in every mirror in existence.

YouTube Preview Image

However, while the Doctor often provides justice and has saved the universe many times, he can resemble a war criminal in his narcissism, manipulation, and deception. What prevents the Doctor from sinking into his own evil, madness, and despair? Only lowly humans offer him what nothing else in the universe provides: true community, with its exclusive love, forgiveness, and grace.

Some fault Doctor Who for depicting the Doctor traipsing around the cosmos whilst accompanied by at least one beautiful young woman. Yes, this may be pandering to that all-important male demographic. But to its credit, the series has played up the companions’ competence, their calming effect on the Doctor, and the fact that the Doctor often needs his companions more than they need him. Rose, Donna Noble, Wilfred Mott, Amy Pond and Rory Williams, River Song, et al. keep the lonely Doctor company in the truest sense of the word. With them he can share the universe’s wonders, but in turn they protect him from himself, call out his faults, and prevent him from unleashing a Time Lord’s devastating damage.

In the series 5 episode “The Beast Below,” the Doctor and his new companion, spunky young redhead Amy Pond, find themselves in the 33rd century aboard Starship UK, a giant craft carrying the entire United Kingdom. Later they find that Starship UK is, in fact, built around a colossal “star whale” that the starship’s citizens have tortured for centuries. Furious at the poor creature’s fate, the Doctor spurns all humanity — until Amy speaks through his rage and reveal a better way. Her wisdom and compassion not only saves the star whale and Starship UK, but reminds the Doctor of his better nature.

YouTube Preview Image

So this demi-god’s worst enemy is himself, and he needs humans more than they need him. Yes, this focus on community is very humanistic, no doubt influenced by Doctor Who’s writers’ secular outlook. (We will likely never see the Doctor making supplication to a Higher Power, if one even exists in the Doctor Who universe.) But nevertheless, there is still great truth to be found here, and admired.

Time and again, we see that the one thing that constantly surprises and amazes the Doctor is self-sacrificing love. (The most touching example of this is Rory William’s willingness to guard the love of his life for thousands of years.) We see the Doctor and his companions risk life and limb for each other, even to the point of allowing themselves to be written out of existence to save those they’ve come to love. Indeed, it is self-sacrificing love — a concept that Christians can certainly respect and admire — that may very well be the most powerful force in Doctor Who’s universe, for only it can prove capable of saving the mad Time Lord, and the rest of the universe, from himself.

About Jason Morehead

Jason Morehead lives in the lovely state of Nebraska with his wife, three children, zero pets, and a large collection of CDs, DVDs, books, and video games. He's a fan of Arcade Fire and Arvo Pärt, Jackie Chan and Andrei Tarkovsky, "Doctor Who" and "Community," and C.S. Lewis and Haruki Murakami. He's also a web development geek, which pays the bills — and buys new music and movies. Twitter: @jasonopus. Web: http://opus.fm.

  • rj_anderson

    That sequence where the Doctor judges the Family is actually one of my most strongly disliked moments in the entire new series, and one of several things about the Tenth Doctor that brought me closest to giving up and walking away from the show entirely — a show I’ve been watching avidly since Tom Baker played the Doctor back in the 70′s. Why? Because the Doctor is NOT God, and has no right to consign people to eternal punishment. Especially not when he does so for murky, arguably selfish reasons (i.e. the Family’s evil robbed him of his chance to live out a happy life as a human with Joan, therefore they are the WORST and deserve a more lingering and terrible punishment than any other villains he has ever defeated — uh, no). Certainly, the Family are horrible and deserve to be punished for their misdeeds, but to me, that sequence made the Doctor look not only self-righteous but sadistic. That is not the Doctor I grew up loving, and it’s not the Doctor I want to follow on adventures around the universe. I don’t require the Doctor to be perfect and always do the right and best thing, but I do require him not to be a self-righteous, hypocritical jerk.

    (All of this is no discredit to David Tennant, who I think is a fantastic actor and did the best job of making a silk purse out of this particular sow’s ear that anyone could. I blame the showrunners and scriptwriters for losing sight of what makes the Doctor different from your average postmodern antihero, and giving the Tenth Doctor a lot of really dreadful things to say and do.)

  • Stuart Blessman

    I’ve been a fan of the show for about a year and a half, and the number one thing that bugs me is the 21st century liberal self-righteousness that the Doctor won’t ever use a gun. Oh, he’ll have others slaughter millions, but to use a gun himself? He’s “above that”. Bull.

  • E. Stephen Burnett

    And yet current showrunner Steven Moffat seemed to acknowledge the inconsistency, and roll it back, in the series 6 episode “Day of the Moon.”

    Oh, and this is my friend River. Nice hair, clever, has her own gun, and unlike me, she really doesn’t mind shooting people. I shouldn’t like that. Kind of do a bit. […] I know you’re team players and everything, but she’ll definitely kill at least the first three of you.

    It makes sense because regeneration.

  • Stuart Blessman

    To be fair, it sort of bugs me with Batman too, the refusal to use a gun, but I give him a pass because it was a gun that killed his parents and he won’t use the same weapon. It’s just the mindset of “guns are so bad never use them” that bugs me, when there are legitimate times firearms are needed.

  • Stuart Blessman

    Is the Doctor a pacifist?


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X