I can believe that you used to be an atheist. An atheist is simply someone without a god belief. It’s the “just like you” part that I’m having trouble with.

Lots of Christian apologists introduce themselves as former atheists. Lee Strobel, for example, often begins presentations with a summary of his decadent, angry atheist past. The implied message is that people like me convert to Christianity all the time. No, I don’t think so.

To see this, let’s look at three groups of people.

- Group 1 are the Christians.
- The atheists need two groups. Group 2 are technically atheists because they don’t have a god belief, but they don’t know much about arguments in favor of Christianity, rebuttals to those arguments, or arguments in favor of atheism. Nothing wrong with that, of course—the God question doesn’t interest everyone—but they’re simply poorly informed about atheism.
- Group 3 includes the well-educated atheists. This group
*does*understand the arguments on both sides of the issue. I put myself into this group (with justification, I hope).

Now, back to the conversion/deconversion question.

- I know of people in Group 1 (Christians) who’ve deconverted: Rich Lyons from the Living After Faith podcast. Matt Dillahunty of the Atheist Community of Austin. Dan Barker of the Freedom From Religion Foundation. Bob Price, the Bible Geek. Bart Ehrman, author of
*Misquoting Jesus.*They’re now all in Group 3 and they’re particularly interesting because they were very well educated Christians. Education actually turned them away from Christianity. - I’m sure many people formerly in Group 2 (uninformed atheists) have converted to Christianity. This sounds like the group that the imagined former-atheist-now-Christian came from.
- But here’s my point: I’ve never heard of anyone in Group 3, the well-educated atheists, who converted to Christianity. Of course, this makes me vulnerable to the No True Scotsman fallacy—rejecting any counterexample with, “Oh, well that guy wasn’t
*truly*a well-educated atheist”—but I invite you to add a comment if you can think of someone.

Well-educated Christians deconvert to atheism, but well-educated atheists don’t convert to Christianity. More education about the history and origins of Christianity increases the likelihood that the Christian will deconvert, but more education increases the likelihood that the atheist will stay put. Education pushes you in one direction only.

This is an asymmetry that apologists don’t seem to appreciate. Becoming a well-educated atheist is a one-way street. It’s a ratchet. Once you become a well-educated atheist, you’re stuck there.

This is why “just like you” makes no sense. If you were a Group 2 atheist, uninterested and uninformed about the arguments, and you converted to Christianity, that’s not surprising. But if you’d been a well-educated atheist (Group 3), you wouldn’t make the arguments that you do. You wouldn’t make arguments to which I have an immediate rebuttal. Indeed, you would make only those arguments which you knew (since you’d been just like me) I had no response to.

It never seems to work that way.

*Photo credit:* Wikimedia

Related posts:

Pingback: Lee Strobel’s Fragile Argument | Cross Examined

Pingback: An Angry Christian Responds | Philosopher's Haze

Pingback: “This is Guaranteed to Convert You!” | Cross Examined

Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

Pingback: air quality houston

Pingback: cialis original livraison rapide

Pingback: how to prevent premature ejaculation video

Pingback: online slots

Pingback: chicken coop ideas

Pingback: click here.,

Pingback: cialis paris

Pingback: dog bed

Pingback: Visit This Website

Pingback: how long do people last in bed

Pingback: macaron kopen

Pingback: commander cialis quebec

Pingback: cialis medicina

Pingback: payday loans for bad credit

Pingback: acheter cialis pharmacie ligne

Pingback: automotive

Pingback: Law

Pingback: great

Pingback: URL

Pingback: read full here

Pingback: acheter du cialis en allemagne

Pingback: superkarts.info

Pingback: cpokemon.net

Pingback: myrexis.info

Pingback: electroglasprober.info

Pingback: lcbla.info

Pingback: diedesign.info

Pingback: cialis generico senza ricetta

Pingback: viagra

Pingback: rxslimclinic.info

Pingback: flpe.info

Pingback: youngleadersacademy.info

Pingback: arganolie discount

Pingback: lawyer directory

Pingback: ipoczta.info

Pingback: uproarpr.info

Pingback: yougetbmw.info

Pingback: Business

Pingback: bedroom suites

Pingback: radiostudiox.info

Pingback: Evidence tracker

Pingback: Optimax Reviews

Pingback: cincyamateurgolf.info

Pingback: dublin massage

Pingback: Paignton Driving School

Pingback: Shaahin Cheyene

Pingback: Shaahin Cheyene

Pingback: sick of law suits

Pingback: escort in Sydney

Pingback: escort in Sydney

Pingback: kitchens

Pingback: Bad real-estate

Pingback: www.floridasupremecourt.org

Pingback: kitchens

Pingback: informatique-thouars.info

Pingback: Richard McArthur Silverton

Pingback: Arganollie

Pingback: Richard McArthur Washington

Pingback: Flight Tickets

Pingback: Richard McArthur Silverton

Pingback: Richard McArthur Washington

Pingback: achat cialis france

Pingback: raleigh wedding films

Pingback: Social Justice

Pingback: buy likes

Pingback: sex

Pingback: K3vin Envoy

Pingback: Penis enlargement

Pingback: prezzo cialis 10 mg

Pingback: cupones de descuento

Pingback: distante rutiere

Pingback: web

Pingback: ed maldonado

Pingback: garage doors san francisco

Pingback: insane value

Pingback: love cupid online dating

Pingback: emily bear

Pingback: emily bathroom accessory

Pingback: 1-800-411-pain

Pingback: Madden 15 Tips

Pingback: viagra online

Pingback: Carey Martell

Pingback: Ceiling Fan Installation

Pingback: Empower Network Affiliate

Pingback: Mortgage company

Pingback: Skip Trowel Texture

Pingback: ford raptor bumper

Pingback: Knockdown Texture

Pingback: Process Servers

Pingback: Gas/Electricity

Pingback: NOVA Dryer Vent Cleaning

Pingback: youtube mp4

Pingback: Hair styles to impress

Pingback: shakeology alternative

Pingback: the messenger: the story of a contract killer

Pingback: Northern Virginia dryer vent cleaning

Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

Pingback: fans

Pingback: Tom Anderson

Pingback: ganesh chaturthi sms

Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

Pingback: ejakulation

Pingback: hyundai sale

Pingback: legal highs

Pingback: how to last longer in bed without a condom

Pingback: bill jacobs mazda

Pingback: Porno Filmes

Pingback: volkswagen beetle for sale

Pingback: where to buy scentsy candles

Pingback: eye insurance

Pingback: doctors tucson az

Pingback: coupon

Pingback: eye serum

Pingback: Lucy

Pingback: advertise houses for sale

Pingback: Viagra Now

Pingback: Sara Schwartz Gluck

Pingback: Denver CO For Sale By Owner

Pingback: FSBO Memphis TN

Pingback: Peggie Digiuseppe

Pingback: online casino

Pingback: labor day travel ideas

Pingback: the best facial mask

Pingback: paginas web wordpress nicaragua

Pingback: daily tarot reading

Pingback: gordas antes y despues de adelgazar

Pingback: circle tires

Pingback: getting a home loan

Pingback: portraits

Pingback: cheap workout equipment

Pingback: Bee Wild Pest Control

Pingback: how to get a guy to last longer in bed

Pingback: bitcoin casino

Pingback: Whatsapp Hack

Pingback: health and beauty

Pingback: Titfuck

Pingback: assfuck

Pingback: Nike Coupon Code

Pingback: dog trainers

Pingback: bee wild pest control

Pingback: pest control houston review

Pingback: appliance repair near Greenwich

Pingback: appliance repair in Cos Cob CT

Pingback: Here

Pingback: Yonkers appliance repair

Pingback: b complex vitamin

Pingback: data recovery wizard

Pingback: Cialis

Pingback: china business directory

Pingback: Goodyear appliance repair

Pingback: appliance repair Glendale

Pingback: file recovery mac

Pingback: House eviction

Pingback: modere compensation

Pingback: banking coupons

Pingback: sex

Pingback: online slots games free

Pingback: viagra online

Pingback: appliance repair Cave Creek

Pingback: sex

Pingback: sea fish identification

Pingback: bayan izmir escort

Pingback: emotional intelligence training

Pingback: leer m?s

Pingback: ambien online

Pingback: click here

Pingback: buy oxycontin online

Pingback: buy hydrocodone

Pingback: guarras gratis

Pingback: buy tramadol

Pingback: xenical online

Pingback: blackhatworld

Pingback: cash for gold

Pingback: porn

Pingback: carpet cleaners pretoria

Pingback: Sports Cards

Pingback: viagra

Pingback: caramoan

Pingback: plum lipstick

Pingback: natural face masks

Pingback: ?????? ??????

Pingback: abc chauffeurs

Pingback: click here for pay day loan review

Pingback: Exterminator Service Houston Texas

Pingback: buy hydrocodone online

Pingback: affordablepups reviews

Pingback: viagra

Pingback: xlovecam generator

Pingback: Devvon Terrell I Like It Ft Kazzie Pop Video Is Crazy

Pingback: FanDuel Promo Code

Pingback: Pest Control Service in Richmond Tx

Pingback: hbos

Pingback: air conditioning sherman oaks

Pingback: Knoxville Plumbing

Pingback: Chicago criminal attorney

Pingback: furniture in the house

Pingback: gifts for men

Pingback: houses to buy in cardiff

Pingback: WordPress Themes

Pingback: ritalin rapid detox

Pingback: columbia sunroom

Pingback: germantown sunroom

Pingback: enrabar gajas

Pingback: nether hacks

Pingback: Persewaan Mobil Elf surabaya

Pingback: macchina fotografica reflex canon usata

Pingback: Marysville Criminal Defense Attorney

Pingback: buy tramadol

Pingback: buy tramadol

Pingback: buy ambien

Pingback: buy cialis

Pingback: products to last longer in bed

Pingback: buy tramadol

Pingback: code promo modz

Pingback: Cleaners in glasgow

Pingback: code promo

Pingback: Worcester iPhone Repair

Pingback: buy ativan

Pingback: buy adipex

Pingback: celebrity leaked photos

Pingback: Worcester iPhone Repair

Pingback: cialis

Pingback: how to get a divorce

Pingback: immigration services

Pingback: Rusk heat freak- Get It Here!

Pingback: teen

Pingback: free keylogger

Pingback: penis enlargement

Pingback: Elephant Art

Pingback: web design perth

Pingback: digital marketing agencies

Pingback: Aspergers Quiz

Pingback: Aspergers Quiz

Pingback: Aspergers

Pingback: Aspergers

Pingback: Cialis

Pingback: perth web designers

Pingback: banana blue

Pingback: loyal 9 marketing reviews

Pingback: cerrajeros baratos murcia

Pingback: Poker online

Pingback: weight loss spas

Pingback: food

Pingback: Forex Broker

Pingback: pabrik tas wanita

Pingback: landscaper

Pingback: Camilo Concha

Pingback: soundcloud plays

Pingback: Learn Hacking Tutorials

Pingback: Caller ID Dip Revenue

Pingback: divorce attorney

Pingback: download bluestacks

Pingback: elizabeth l hapner

Pingback: try car games 1000

Pingback: hearthstone arena guide

Pingback: Hacking Tutorials

Pingback: donice ogrodowe

Pingback: Cerrajeros Alicante

Pingback: quickextenderpro

Pingback: rape videos

Pingback: xarelto lawyer

Pingback: gay porn

Pingback: Guia de negocios

Pingback: vending machines

Pingback: זילכה שירלי

Pingback: porn

Pingback: Livejasmin Hack

Pingback: the plumbing cure

Pingback: LAX Car Service

Pingback: bolatangkasonline

Pingback: Office Decoration

Pingback: Gym Singapore

Pingback: Newport Beach

Pingback: newport beach

Pingback: betboo

Pingback: help moving furniture

Pingback: betboo

Pingback: video for real estate

Pingback: betboo

Pingback: information

Pingback: michelle rodriguez wiki

Pingback: Miniature golf construction

Pingback: luxury aircraft solutions private jet charters

Pingback: Online Signature

Pingback: real estate agent school

Pingback: bahis siteleri

Pingback: betboo

Pingback: Jogos de carros

Pingback: chelsea ferguson gets tits out,

Pingback: mobile atm

Pingback: find job

Pingback: no win no fee

Pingback: بفركس احتيال

Pingback: לורי שם טוב

Pingback: bureaux ferm?s centre ville Montr?al

Pingback: mil anuncios

Pingback: Pen Drive Rotta

Pingback: locksmith Farmington Hills

Pingback: devis déménagement

Pingback: Patriot Rooter

Pingback: hedge trimming brighton

Pingback: let flat london

Pingback: our website

Pingback: Joe Pojman

Pingback: Grocery & Gourmet Food

Pingback: Mad ud af huset

Pingback: poker strategies

Pingback: walmart oil change coupons

Pingback: flying homes

Pingback: Jogos de Tiro

Pingback: kangen water ionizer

Pingback: CCNA BANGALORE

Pingback: ejacculation precosse

Pingback: casino

Pingback: ceiling fans

Pingback: dekoracje do domu

Pingback: ejacculation precosse

Pingback: Flooring

Pingback: éjaculation précoce comment faire

Pingback: Banquet halls in brooklyn

Pingback: Buy Reputation Management

Pingback: spy

Pingback: IT Training Specialist

Pingback: engineering

Pingback: epic fails

Pingback: Shopping

Pingback: plugin wordpress

Pingback: alphabetical web directory

Pingback: sale in your video

Pingback: QuickBooks training

Pingback: biuro ksiegowe warszawa

Pingback: Sondage StarOfService

Pingback: Natashia Kamealoha

Pingback: Preston Byrd speaker

Pingback: Wholesale Brooch Lot

Pingback: priligy cialis

Pingback: consumer store

Pingback: gratis voetbal kijken

Pingback: big-rig truck

Pingback: datenrettung

Pingback: citizen watches online reviews

Pingback: wireless charger for lg g3

Pingback: autotitleloans-sandiego.com

Pingback: Billig flytting Oslo

Pingback: alena sunavska

Pingback: very cute Munchkin stood cat standing

Pingback: Organic

Pingback: RCC Institute of Technology Review

Pingback: kinder ferrero

Pingback: whale dc

Pingback: one more cup of coffee

Pingback: http://drnathanjuiceplus.com

Pingback: online paid surveys

Pingback: website

Pingback: computer accessories

Pingback: property loan singapore

Pingback: Seattle Web Design

Pingback: in here

Pingback: vimax

Pingback: seo jobs

Pingback: visit poster's site

Pingback: in here

Pingback: big

Pingback: Medieval and Renaissance costume

Pingback: adonis golden ration system

Pingback: Online Shopping

Pingback: online flashcards

Pingback: 8bets10

Pingback: superbahis

Pingback: umbilical cord blood banking

Pingback: Water Proof Video Cameras

Pingback: http://orienthacapital.com

Pingback: dr gerald buchoff

Pingback: nelson mandela

Pingback: vimax

Pingback: Tiffanie Craddock

Pingback: Boerderij spel

Pingback: models las vegas

Pingback: Saint Helena maps street view

Pingback: Ted Virtue MidOcean

Pingback: http://ritadavidson.com

Pingback: kliknij

Pingback: jns

Pingback: Korte Kapsels

Pingback: Celebrity Feet

Pingback: my source

Pingback: http://sexynightladies.com

Pingback: website

Pingback: number of

Pingback: Designer Engagement Rings

Pingback: display annoncering

Pingback: DIRTY ARMY

Pingback: Scott kay

Pingback: iphone 5s unlock

Pingback: dreamboard

Pingback: kangen water machine

Pingback: check this online source

Pingback: 60 second binary options signals

Pingback: rowery mtb

Pingback: dreamboards

Pingback: jailbait

Pingback: vimax porn

Pingback: เรียน tu-get

Pingback: Professional Logo Design

Pingback: chiropodist definition

Pingback: franquia de lavagem a seco

Pingback: my website

Pingback: sell your house fast

Pingback: WebForum

Pingback: Christmas Lights

Pingback: C

Pingback: website

Pingback: sell my house fast

Pingback: rhinoplasty

Pingback: Traditional Chinese Medicine Five Dock

Pingback: Naturkosmetik

Pingback: increase site traffic

Pingback: valium online

Pingback: Extra resources

Pingback: Continue

Pingback: Numéros non surtaxés amazon

Pingback: great business

Pingback: advokat

Pingback: how to get rid of bed bugs

Pingback: billigt webhotel

Pingback: Studie

Pingback: online dating dating

Pingback: Cheap Prefab Houses for sale in UAE, OMAN AND GULF

Pingback: Bio Cover

Pingback: survey bypass

Pingback: Snapalicious

Pingback: que es el registro civil central

Pingback: basic website design

Pingback: Employee Monitoring

Pingback: windenergie

Pingback: Don Kellner

Pingback: pet waste bags

Pingback: Panadorhat

Pingback: Bic Ctx

Pingback: windenergie

Pingback: nieruchomosci Azul Villa

Pingback: Mobile Wallet and Digital Coupon Advantages

Pingback: Tens Handheld Electronic Pulse Massager Unit

Pingback: Kosher auditing Asia

Pingback: Betriebsfeste Detern

Pingback: scam reviews

Pingback: SEO

Pingback: iphone repair

Pingback: dynamics implementation for small and medium size businesses

Pingback: kliknij tutaj

Pingback: Hesperia Areatza

Pingback: Oracle SQL Developer

Pingback: viagra

Pingback: dr. Hatem Elhagely

Pingback: worksheets for kids

Pingback: svetlana Bilyanova

Pingback: reviews of Green Smoke

Pingback: Trans Rapid Web

Pingback: car history reports

Pingback: customer service

Pingback: dr duke

Pingback: acorn stairlifts

Pingback: buy facebook fans

Pingback: muslim marriage events

Pingback: http://vseoteli.net

Pingback: http://webcancun.net

Pingback: Form Download

Pingback: property management London

Pingback: Telecharger Films Gratuit

Pingback: Online photography courses

Pingback: Free Viagra

Pingback: Free Viagra

Pingback: Copegraf

Pingback: Social Media Marketing Services Companies

Pingback: my source

Pingback: Free Porn

Pingback: Charm Bracelet Project

Pingback: Blechercollins

Pingback: resource

Pingback: Charm Bracelet Project

Pingback: my blogs

Pingback: http://www.bypassicloudlock.net/

Pingback: Charm Bracelet Project

Pingback: Blechercollins

Pingback: spy camera pix

Pingback: dead rising 3 trainer

Pingback: blog

Pingback: Blechercollins

Pingback: Blechercollins

Pingback: mytopbrokers.com

Pingback: Blechercollins

Pingback: Charm Bracelet Project

Pingback: schlüsseldienst düsseldorf

Pingback: website

Pingback: htc

Pingback: number1youtubeviews.yolasite.com/ number1youtubeviews.yolasite.com

Pingback: Appliances

Pingback: Blechercollins

Pingback: donde comprar garcinia cambogia

Pingback: Coquin

Pingback: Netflix.com

Pingback: Blechercollins

Pingback: Blechercollins

Pingback: Ausgezeichnet Geniessen

Pingback: rhinoplasty

Pingback: business debt recovery

Pingback: http://yuzmek.com

Pingback: somos buenas web cordoba

Pingback: Adventure Holidays

Pingback: sliced pebble tile

Pingback: adult

Pingback: Garage door repair white plains

Pingback: cheap viagra

Pingback: poker system

Pingback: tramadol generic

Pingback: dreamboards

Pingback: credit

Pingback: wizard101 hack

Pingback: homes by vanderbuilt

Pingback: http://2013lcc.com

Pingback: coupons

Pingback: Forest Retreat Center and Forest Community

Pingback: http://brucepeterkacfo.com

Pingback: sexy emails

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: buy steroids

Pingback: porno

Pingback: sexy emails

Pingback: alkaline ionized water

Pingback: donald duck hd

Pingback: http://joesrealestate.net

Pingback: http://invoicestuffers.com

Pingback: cat sitter naples

Pingback: Exit business cards

Pingback: Canadian steroids

Pingback: foreclosed homes

Pingback: loyal 9 marketing

Pingback: http://mermtrans.com

Pingback: http://mozgoreklam.com

Pingback: http://kaesemacher.net

Pingback: http://stadt-zuerich.net

Pingback: sexy emails

Pingback: making money online ebooks

Pingback: botox wroclaw

Pingback: factor quema grasa oficial

Pingback: http://spector360.net

Pingback: Toronto Product Photography

Pingback: Porno

Pingback: number reverse

Pingback: www.selljunkcarsatlanta.us

Pingback: lamowniki

Pingback: Bellevue Dentist

Pingback: montaz alarmu samochodowego lodz

Pingback: wiecej

Pingback: wakacje nad jeziorem

Pingback: oferta

Pingback: http://psikr.com

Pingback: http://eggs-online.com

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: http://xpellshop.net

Pingback: http://citychpd.net

Pingback: source

Pingback: szafki ubraniowe

Pingback: JT Foxx

Pingback: JT Foxx

Pingback: furniture houston tx

Pingback: justice

Pingback: http://nvmweb.com

Pingback: Ipas2 online job

Pingback: Home Page

Pingback: Online Poker

Pingback: Office & School Supplies

Pingback: sintomas de retencion de agua

Pingback: como usar el metodo del calendario

Pingback: Aafx

Pingback: Storyteller Lightroom Preset $10!

Pingback: lojas capas

Pingback: night clubs in nyc

Pingback: http://takingsurvivors.com

Pingback: ivy night club

Pingback: bristol night clubs

Pingback: Noticias

Pingback: finding a good investment

Pingback: viagra penis

Pingback: online slots

Pingback: free online slots

Pingback: genskie-sekreti.ru/kak-izbavitsya-ot-pryshchej.html

Pingback: penis

Pingback: best money lenders

Pingback: Bangla Newspaper

Pingback: kindle phone

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: Les Jardins De Gaia

Pingback: the Precor treadmill

Pingback: louisville accident doctor

Pingback: house of harlow 1960

Pingback: moms

Pingback: descargar black berry world 8520

Pingback: no password needed

Pingback: link

Pingback: how much does law enforcement drones cost

Pingback: cheap Evening Dresses

Pingback: CV Writing India

Pingback: hotmail

Pingback: superbahis

Pingback: Amauris Bastidas

Pingback: bendgate

Pingback: music

Pingback: Andrew Green

Pingback: Gatwick - Transfers

Pingback: Web design & SEO

Pingback: Men's Medical Clinics

Pingback: Chip and Dale cartoons

Pingback: domain

Pingback: sculpted cake tutorial

Pingback: custom cakes

Pingback: Dwayne Parker

Pingback: bulk tumblers

Pingback: famous astrologer

Pingback: shopping blogs singapore

Pingback: oak coffee table

Pingback: windows

Pingback: pain

Pingback: http://www.answerplaza.com

Pingback: self publishing

Pingback: Hot Air Corn Popper by Presto

Pingback: how to find a job

Pingback: job interview tips

Pingback: Brooklyn Plumber

Pingback: Internet Marketing Revolution Handbook

Pingback: cancun transportation

Pingback: how to jump higher blog

Pingback: oc bail bonds

Pingback: my friend cayla

Pingback: water ionizers

Pingback: explain it

Pingback: Comment obtenir illimit?e de gemmes dans clash of clans

Pingback: Nether hacks

Pingback: manage weightloss

Pingback: vibrator

Pingback: bdsm sex game

Pingback: Actors Academy In India

Pingback: pen drive spezzata

Pingback: jewels jewelry

Pingback: jewels jewelry

Pingback: diamond jewelry

Pingback: kinder eggs toys

Pingback: laser jammer

Pingback: Silicone Baking Mat

Pingback: süperbahis

Pingback: Hell in a cell live stream

Pingback: how to trade binary options profitably

Pingback: theme

Pingback: train-trans.pl

Pingback: Family Law Attorney Florence SC

Pingback: graphiste freelance paris

Pingback: l?s upp samsung

Pingback: l?s upp xperia

Pingback: Portal

Pingback: psycholog warszawa

Pingback: BathPillowbySimplyEssentials

Pingback: career guide

Pingback: Nail Art for Beginners

Pingback: clash of clans hack

Pingback: cigar

Pingback: online poker

Pingback: zi xiu tang

Pingback: www.helixsuspension.com

Pingback: comprar argentina

Pingback: limo rental

Pingback: news

Pingback: furniture online singapore

Pingback: Home

Pingback: Happy new year friday or opening day collection

Pingback: about

Pingback: ติว toeic

Pingback: Maduras XXX

Pingback: downline

Pingback: Skepvet

Pingback: Personal trainer Beer Sheva

Pingback: general