*In keeping with the Bayes Theorem dose of probability theory last week, here’s a very approachable probability problem.*

I first came across the fascinating Monty Hall Problem 20 years ago:

Suppose you’re on a game show, and you’re given the choice of three doors: Behind one door is a car; behind the others, goats. You pick a door, say No. 1, and the host, who knows what’s behind the doors, opens another door, say No. 3, which has a goat. He then says to you, “Do you want to pick door No. 2?”

Is it to your advantage to switch your choice?

Most people think that it doesn’t matter and that there’s no benefit to switching. They’re wrong, but more on that in a moment.

Humans have a hard time with probability problems like this one. You’d think that we’d be fairly comfortable with basic probability, but apparently not.

Here’s another popular probability problem: how many people must you have in a group before it becomes more likely than not that any two of them have the same birthday?

The surprising answer is 23. In other words, imagine two football teams on the field (11 per team) and then throw in a referee, and it’s more than likely that you’ll find a shared birthday. If your mind balks at this, test it at your next large gathering.

Now, back to the Monty Hall Problem. A good way to understand problems like this is to push them to an extreme. Imagine, for example, that there are not three doors but 300. There’s still just one good prize, with the rest being goats (the bad prize).

So you pick a door—say number #274. There’s a 1/300 chance you’re right. This needs to be emphasized: *you’re almost certainly wrong.* Then the game show host opens 298 of the remaining doors: 1, 2, 3, and so on. He skips door #59 and your door, #274. Every open door shows a goat.

Now: should you switch? Of course you should—your initial pick is still almost surely wrong. The probabilities are 1/300 for #274 and 299/300 for #59.

Another way to look at the problem: do you want to stick with your initial door or do you want *all* the other doors? Switching is simply choosing all the other doors, because (thanks to the open doors) you know the only door within that set that could be the winner.

One lesson from this is that our innate understanding of probability is poor, and a corollary is that there’s a big difference between confidence and accuracy. That is, just because one’s confidence in a belief is high doesn’t mean that the belief is accurate. This little puzzle does a great job of illustrating this.

Perhaps you’ve already anticipated the connection with choosing a religion. Imagine you’ve picked your religion—religion #274, let’s say. For most people, their adoption of a religion is like picking a door in this game show. In the game show, you don’t weigh evidence before selecting your door; you pick it randomly. And most people adopt the dominant religion of their upbringing. As with the game show, the religion in which you grew up is also assigned to you at random.

Now imagine an analogous game, the Game of Religion, with Truth as host. Out of 300 doors (behind each of which is a religion), the believer picks door #274. Truth flings open door after door and we see nothing but goats. Hinduism, Sikhism, Jainism, Mormonism—all goats. As you suspected, they’re just amalgams of legend, myth, tradition, and wishful thinking.

Few of us seriously consider or even understand the religions Winti, Candomblé, Mandaeism, or the ancient religions of Central America, for example. Luckily for the believer, Truth gets around to those doors too and opens them to reveal goats.

Here’s where the analogy between the two games fails. First, Truth opens *all* the other doors. Only the believer’s pick, door #274, is still closed. Second, there was never a guarantee that *any* door contained a true religion! Since the believer likely came to his beliefs randomly, why imagine that his choice is any more likely than the others to hold anything of value?

Every believer plays the Game of Religion, and every believer believes that his religion is the one true religion, with goats behind all the hundreds of other doors. But maybe there’s a goat behind *every* door. And given that the lesson from the 300-door Monty Hall game is that the door you randomly picked at first is almost certainly wrong, why imagine that yours is the only religion that’s not mythology?

*For reason is not just a debater’s tool *

*for idly refracting arguments into premises,*

*but a lens for bringing into focus the features of human flourishing. *

— “What Is Marriage?” by Girgis, George, and Anderson

*This is a modified version of a post originally published 11/28/11.*

Pingback: Homepage

Pingback: https://www.sarahomestay.com

Pingback: viagra

Pingback: mobile locksmith channelview TX

Pingback: Viio Balestier

Pingback: special info

Pingback: click here to read

Pingback: how to fix cracks in plaster walls

Pingback: Do you need a new web design San Antonio?

Pingback: id-pf

Pingback: Premium Domain Broker

Pingback: click here

Pingback: Top mediums van parastars voor duidelijk advies

Pingback: boiler installation vancouver

Pingback: elsevier & parship

Pingback: waarzegsters

Pingback: hyper link

Pingback: Helderzienden online: Live helderziende - Heldervoelende helderziende

Pingback: paragnost/klikhier/

Pingback: Websiteoptimalisatie/websiteoptimaliseren

Pingback: Bitcoin Hosting

Pingback: paragnost/klikhier/

Pingback: Think Build Websites

Pingback: create a page

Pingback: PunBB

Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

Pingback: blucarpet.com

Pingback: best online slots

Pingback: dog bed

Pingback: video

Pingback: payday loans direct lenders

Pingback: automotive

Pingback: goat fucking

Pingback: Real Estate

Pingback: related

Pingback: reference

Pingback: hcmay.com

Pingback: sysgration.info

Pingback: texasedtea.info

Pingback: siestabeach.info

Pingback: video bugil

Pingback: golfweekcincinnati.info

Pingback: bigelaw.info

Pingback: cheap facebook followers

Pingback: penis enlargement pills

Pingback: yogaitalia.info

Pingback: flpe.info

Pingback: pctoptips.info

Pingback: netpsychologist.info

Pingback: optionking.info

Pingback: hunivers.info

Pingback: appspaybig.info

Pingback: estrategiasmarketingonline.info

Pingback: yougetbmw.info

Pingback: sonos connect review

Pingback: xlovecam telecharger generateur de code

Pingback: MODS

Pingback: Fashion

Pingback: Travel

Pingback: rporecruitmenttoronto.info

Pingback: Alex Begum personal injury attorney

Pingback: rayannespeaks.info

Pingback: this post

Pingback: Robert Shumake

Pingback: Top 100 Songs

Pingback: cincyamateurgolf.info

Pingback: thai massage

Pingback: Slendera

Pingback: Orlando vacation rentals near disney

Pingback: roz grammes

Pingback: seo training

Pingback: Shaahin Cheyene

Pingback: Penis enlargement

Pingback: Penis enlargement

Pingback: belizia.info

Pingback: small business financial loan

Pingback: kitchens

Pingback: kitchen cupboards

Pingback: midweststudramsale.info

Pingback: psychologist1.info

Pingback: flowerworks.info

Pingback: nutramedixmedical.info

Pingback: in here

Pingback: camilo concha

Pingback: best wireless speakers

Pingback: Arganollie

Pingback: Richard McArthur Reid Realty

Pingback: Richard McArthur Port Orchard

Pingback: mortgage broker

Pingback: raleigh wedding films

Pingback: cupones

Pingback: cult education

Pingback: Viagra

Pingback: payday loans

Pingback: sap jobs in the usa

Pingback: buy fb likes

Pingback: house

Pingback: descargar juegos

Pingback: bay area garage door

Pingback: ed maldonado

Pingback: media partner

Pingback: garage doors san francisco

Pingback: how to find success in online dating

Pingback: Madden 15

Pingback: salsa en malaga

Pingback: Technology

Pingback: Home Improvement

Pingback: Photography

Pingback: emily bailey

Pingback: dbz movie times of grace

Pingback: بفركس نصب

Pingback: sex sites

Pingback: $25 Payments

Pingback: in here

Pingback: in here

Pingback: Ceiling Fan Installation

Pingback: Faucet Repair

Pingback: Bakersfield CPR

Pingback: Omega Locksmith Chicago

Pingback: Northern Virginia dryer vent cleaning

Pingback: Anonymous

Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

Pingback: tech

Pingback: best forex robot

Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

Pingback: kalsium

Pingback: irvine auto repair

Pingback: Music & Audio apps

Pingback: website

Pingback: blog

Pingback: info

Pingback: Porno Filmes

Pingback: http://www.law.fsu.edu/library/flsupct/91325/op-91325.pdf

Pingback: blog

Pingback: blogs

Pingback: Jual Perbanyak Follower

Pingback: fish oil omega 3

Pingback: my site

Pingback: resources

Pingback: Criminal Lawyer

Pingback: alternative medicine

Pingback: blogs

Pingback: website

Pingback: advertise houses for sale

Pingback: my site

Pingback: http://minecraftlikegames.com/

Pingback: resources

Pingback: link m88

Pingback: Viagra Pill

Pingback: 32 weken zwanger

Pingback: games app

Pingback: online casino

Pingback: Viagra Now

Pingback: Odelia Amelang

Pingback: website

Pingback: resources

Pingback: source website

Pingback: viagra

Pingback: Free android games

Pingback: juicy couture outlet

Pingback: organic skincare

Pingback: top quality leading label label wheels

Pingback: pirater un compte facebook

Pingback: bitcoin casino

Pingback: webmaster

Pingback: free mp3's

Pingback: banners

Pingback: beauty and health

Pingback: source website

Pingback: MovieStarPlanet Cheats

Pingback: pre-foreclosure list

Pingback: how twitter makes money

Pingback: bee wild pest control

Pingback: appliance repair in Greenwich CT

Pingback: juicy couture outlet

Pingback: appliance repair Greenwich

Pingback: resources

Pingback: find out this here

Pingback: Domainmarket

Pingback: Furniture Parts & Accessories

Pingback: porn videos

Pingback: in here

Pingback: info

Pingback: diving cyprus

Pingback: email databases sale

Pingback: appliance repair Avondale

Pingback: Free Download Register Software's

Pingback: Cialis

Pingback: resource

Pingback: viagra online

Pingback: Surprise appliance repair

Pingback: buy xenical

Pingback: buy adderall

Pingback: buy adipex online

Pingback: enhance your love life

Pingback: video training course

Pingback: m?s info

Pingback: guarrillas gratis

Pingback: buy oxycontin

Pingback: sinema izle

Pingback: appliance repair near Alhambra

Pingback: cash for gold

Pingback: Anik Singal

Pingback: Annuaire des particuliers

Pingback: bookmarks

Pingback: buy used car in dubai

Pingback: website designers perth

Pingback: porn

Pingback: wordpress perth

Pingback: tarot si o no

Pingback: Pest Control Houston Texas

Pingback: Payday Loans

Pingback: Chicago Appliance Repair Best Rated Best Rated appliance repair Chicago

Pingback: angry birds free online game

Pingback: Exterminator Service Houston Texas

Pingback: FanDuel Promo Code

Pingback: dead sea mud mask

Pingback: Marijuana seeds canada

Pingback: DIRTY ARMY

Pingback: air conditioning sherman oaks

Pingback: modern treadmill reviews

Pingback: wedding candles uk

Pingback: right move cardiff

Pingback: suboxone detox forum

Pingback: home insurance zip

Pingback: WordPress Themes

Pingback: payday loans

Pingback: sunroom yorktown

Pingback: sunroom springfield

Pingback: alexandria sunroom

Pingback: sunroom centreville

Pingback: nether hacks

Pingback: free online slot games for fun

Pingback: kitchen store

Pingback: sunroom hagerstown

Pingback: White Tights

Pingback: buy accutane

Pingback: Cleaners in glasgow

Pingback: cialis

Pingback: Child sex abuse

Pingback: buy xenical

Pingback: live sex

Pingback: articles

Pingback: separation agreement

Pingback: xlovecam token generator

Pingback: hearthstone arena guide

Pingback: banana blue

Pingback: How Much Mortgage Can I Get

Pingback: meditational songs

Pingback: CHEAP VIAGRA

Pingback: search engine optimisation perth

Pingback: free chakra meditation music

Pingback: payday loans

Pingback: easy kundalini awakening

Pingback: penis enlargement

Pingback: shaving

Pingback: web marketing perth

Pingback: Aspergers Quiz

Pingback: Aspergers Quiz

Pingback: Cialis

Pingback: iphone 5c layer case

Pingback: canciones para bodas

Pingback: binary

Pingback: meditation music healing

Pingback: gum without xylitol

Pingback: seo sem

Pingback: http://www.Ath-M50.net

Pingback: Best Rated Best Rated appliance repair Chicago

Pingback: Offroad

Pingback: plymouth bjj

Pingback: increase soundcloud plays and comments package

Pingback: lose weight

Pingback: numéro de téléphone particulier

Pingback: code promo sarenza

Pingback: Betsey Hapner

Pingback: Learn Hacking Tutorials

Pingback: download bluestacks

Pingback: Betsey Hapner

Pingback: descuentos web

Pingback: criminal attorney

Pingback: Hack Facebook Account

Pingback: adaptacja poddasza

Pingback: Home Improvement Company

Pingback: podpis kwalifikowany

Pingback: download all ios firmware

Pingback: quickextenderpro

Pingback: informative post

Pingback: commonwealth towers showflat location

Pingback: Mesa Appliance Repair Directory

Pingback: thailand top up

Pingback: easy 100 reviews

Pingback: sex, porn

Pingback: videos

Pingback: Guia de negocios

Pingback: free porn

Pingback: make money

Pingback: ????? ????

Pingback: free mass email software

Pingback: garden shed plans

Pingback: tuppersex

Pingback: stopthestresstoday.com/contact

Pingback: Patriot Rooter

Pingback: pitts roofing fort worth tx

Pingback: Dubia Roach Sale

Pingback: bolatangkas

Pingback: coconut butter

Pingback: Decoration Ideas

Pingback: Noah Pluhar

Pingback: buy seo

Pingback: online flashcards

Pingback: online flashcards

Pingback: Newport Beach CA

Pingback: Hair Transplant

Pingback: Wigs Denver

Pingback: forever living clean 9

Pingback: sprawdz sam

Pingback: vince stanzione

Pingback: indicizzazione google

Pingback: video 360 interactive

Pingback: Guide to miniature golf construction

Pingback: buy drysol

Pingback: betboo

Pingback: aluminium gutters

Pingback: betboo

Pingback: bforex احتيال

Pingback: outsourcing projects

Pingback: Novi locksmith

Pingback: comics de signo editores

Pingback: WP Profit Builder Bonuses

Pingback: Aspergers Quiz

Pingback: Redford locksmith

Pingback: alaska fishing

Pingback: accident claims

Pingback: web url

Pingback: cheap viagra

Pingback: Patriot Rooter

Pingback: scam reviews

Pingback: Technology

Pingback: Website

Pingback: MANSION88

Pingback: M88

Pingback: best Wilmington photographer

Pingback: bikini workouts

Pingback: marketing firm prices houston

Pingback: astrology

Pingback: Garage door opener repair Denver CO

Pingback: navigate to this website

Pingback: gerald buchoff

Pingback: Gate repair

Pingback: Julefrokost

Pingback: dr hatem elhagaly

Pingback: Fachanwalt Wrestedt

Pingback: vaincre éjaculation précoce

Pingback: Mogul PR

Pingback: camera spy

Pingback: fails

Pingback: It learning

Pingback: homes for rent

Pingback: trail gear

Pingback: miscoin

Pingback: Sondage StarOfService

Pingback: andalemexico

Pingback: Preston Byrd

Pingback: Preston Byrd

Pingback: Look at this

Pingback: Magnetic Messaging

Pingback: How to make money online

Pingback: Condensatieketel info

Pingback: lees meer

Pingback: datenrettung hamburg

Pingback: danske webhoteller

Pingback: anonymous web proxy

Pingback: citizen watches online review

Pingback: complementary medicine

Pingback: Clash Of Clans Gemmes Illimite

Pingback: teen sex

Pingback: Coupon Codes

Pingback: Product Reviews

Pingback: Confections

Pingback: Jeff Arsenault Old Greenwich CT