The Malleable Magesterium

The Malleable Magesterium August 29, 2016

Is kicked around by Dale Price, in response to a rather hefty analysis of Amoris Laetitia in light of previous teachings on the subject.  Religion isn’t easy.  Personally, sometimes I wish I wasn’t a believer.  Life is so much easier when you get to pick and choose.  Religion demands a final answer to ‘who do you say I am.’  And then, of course, you’re supposed to live the answer.  Not that we remain static.  The world changes, knowledge changes, times change.  Just look at the rebounding popularity in human slavery nowadays.  Back when I was a tyke, we thought slavery was something like butter churns or patriotism – they all went out with those old timers who weren’t awesome like we are.

And yet, it’s back – assuming it ever went away. So are many other things.  Some new, some old and repackaged, some the result of discoveries or forgetfulness.  But like all periods in history, the world is different than it was, and somehow the faithful need to remain on firm ground while being able to speak to the needs of the latest generations.  Good luck finding the flawless formula with that one.

Which is what the links above touch on.  For some, the developments and changes in perspective and priorities that Pope Francis has demonstrated are met with ‘about time!’   For others, it’s sackcloth and ashes.  And yet for others, there are no changes, just good old Catholic teaching the way it always should have been taught.  Most, of course, don’t have time for details, what with working two or three jobs in order to keep up with our improving economic fortunes.  You decide.  Read the links.  If nothing else, they’re food for thought.

Hat Tip to Don McClarey at The American Catholic


Browse Our Archives