There’s an old saying that when all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail. And when Islamophobic wingnuts like Pam Geller only have one narrative — ZOMG! Sharia law is upon us! — every single thing that happens is obviously leading right to that result. Including the decision to turn control of domain names over to ICANN.
The Wall Street Journal reported Tuesday that “the Obama administration made the surprise announcement it will relinquish its oversight of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, or Icann, which assigns and maintains domain names and Web addresses for the Internet. Russia, China and other authoritarian governments have already been working to redesign the Internet more to their liking, and now they will no doubt leap to fill the power vacuum caused by America’s unilateral retreat.”
Global governance of the Internet. “Global governance?” As in the U.N.? And who and what drives the U.N.? The largest voting bloc at the U.N. is what drives its policies, and that is the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, or OIC. The historian Bat Ye’or describes the OIC this way: “The OIC is one of the largest intergovernmental organizations in the world. It encompasses 56 Muslim states plus the Palestinian Authority. Spread over four continents, it claims to speak in the name of the ummah (the universal Muslim community), which numbers about 1.3 billion. The OIC’s mission is to unite all Muslims worldwide by rooting them in the Koran and the Sunnah – the core of traditional Islamic civilization and values. It aims at strengthening solidarity and cooperation among all its members, in order to protect the interests of Muslims everywhere and to galvanize the ummah into a unified body.”The Organization of the Islamic Cooperation will undoubtedly demand the suppression of websites that “insult Islam” or “encourage hatred,” and they won’t be referring to jihad forums that foment violence and incite to slaughter. The WSJ explains: “According to the administration’s announcement, the Commerce Department will not renew its agreement with Icann, which dates to 1998. This means, effective next year, the U.S. will no longer oversee the ‘root zone file,’ which contains all names and addresses for websites world-wide. If authoritarian regimes in Russia, China and elsewhere get their way, domains could be banned and new ones not approved for meddlesome groups such as Ukrainian-independence organizations or Tibetan human-rights activists.”
First of all, the decision to let ICANN become entirely independent of the government was done instead of turning control over to the UN, which is what China and Russia wanted to have done. Secondly, the idea that the OIC controls the UN is absolutely laughable. The UN is a lapdog for the most powerful countries, particularly us. It was created that way on purpose.
But most obviously, shouldn’t they be happy that Obama is giving up control of this? I mean, the entire narrative of Geller’s column is that Obama is an evil dictator trying to shut down conservatives. So shouldn’t it be a good thing that he won’t have control over ICANN after next year? Not very consistent or coherent, these people.