The Rampage of Sloth

Nowadays, we tend to associate the capital sin of sloth with laziness and listless inactivity. Because of this association, there is a tendency to associate its opposite, which is vigorous activism, with virtue. The more active, the better one’s moral disposition is.

In the face of this, it is interesting to note the writings of the fourth century ascetic Evagrius of Pontus – parts of which will be covered at a course on moral and sexual integrity at Campion College – who is one of the earliest authorities on the vice of sloth, or what he called acedia and also termed “the noonday demon”. In reading a famous passage in his Praktikos on how the “noonday demon” acts, the reader may notice thatacedia was never associated with inactivity. Rather, for Evagrius, the “noonday demon” acts by causing the Christian to engage in fidgety and meaningless activity. It is precisely through such activity that the sin of sloth is made manifest. And what the person will see is not idle lazing, but wanton destruction. This will explain why Psalm 91, on which Evagrius’ writing on sloth is based, refers to sloth in active terms, as a “scourge that lays waste”.

One gets a sense of this when reading the devastating introductory chapter of a new book on acedia by RJ Snell entitled Acedia and Its Discontents, published by Angelico Press. Snell uses passages from Cormac McCarthy’s novel Blood Meridian, describing a blanket of rape, torture, murder, mob violence and pillage covering a post-apocalyptic earth. The reason suggested is not profound: it is because one simply can.

Despite appearances, Snell says that this chain of seemingly meaningless activity is the stuff of the sin of sloth. Sloth is not passive indolence, but is a “frenzy of pointless action”. Moreover, it is an action that is motivated by an active “disgust at the actual work given them by God”.

What this points to is a link between sloth as a “frenzy of pointless action”, and what Snell calls a “breezy lightness of freedom”. More accurately, it is the desire to save one’s freedom – defined as the exercise of the will with no end – at any cost, which he links with a love of self overtaking the love of God.

Thus, counterintuitive though it may seem, our drive for greater productivity, our drive for more forms of entertainment, our tendency to respond to “how are you” with “busy”, our drive to “do something” for every thing, is part of the institutionalisation of sloth. Snell writes later in the book that “sloth seeps into our loves and lives in virtually every domain, before finally transforming itself into boredom and nihilism.

It is because it is so pervasive, yet so unnoticable, that acedia was regarded by Evagrius as the most insidious of demons.

"Great stuff Matthew! I think that St. Evagrius was spot on by identifying the "thoughts" ..."

How Should Christians Respond to “the ..."
"Nice Matthew! Now can be bumping shoulders with The Anchoress and Mark Shea!"

Changes Afoot
"Did Aquinas think that hearing was the most trustworthy faculty? I haven't had a chance ..."

When What We See Is What ..."
"It's one of the most wonderful readings in the breviary. Does anyone know the source ..."

The Lord's Descent into Hell

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • https://www.blogger.com/profile/05379084345072314738 Eric Lee

    Also: Kathleen Norris' book on Acedia is one of the best things I've read in recent memory.

    Great post, Matt!

    Peace,

    Eric

  • https://www.blogger.com/profile/16463267750952578888 John Médaille

    I'd comment on this, but I have so many things to do right now. I'll put it on my calendar.

  • https://www.blogger.com/profile/02632900943920330793 Matthew Tan

    I know there was a chapter in her “Cloister Walk” on Acedia, but didn't know she did a whole book on it. I will need to look it up. Thank you for the tip!

  • https://www.blogger.com/profile/02632900943920330793 Matthew Tan

    Looking forward to your thoughts on this

  • https://www.blogger.com/profile/07908294088572535508 Katie B.

    Neat timing – I was just at a talk a few days ago by one of the Madonna House priests, Fr. Denis Lemieux, which included a section on this very topic. There's a chapter on acedia in his book “Idol Thoughts”.

  • https://www.blogger.com/profile/17084516830138438823 Paul cannon

    I like the “pointless action” for too long acedia has been misplaced as indolence, nice piece Matthew

  • https://www.blogger.com/profile/02632900943920330793 Matthew Tan

    I just got the joke…