Self Destructive Humanity: The Stone Gods by Jeanette Winterson

Self Destructive Humanity: The Stone Gods by Jeanette Winterson April 25, 2018

Why does humanity have to wreck everything?

In The Stone Gods, British author Jeanette Winterson wraps a chilling environmental cautionary tale in a plot that mixes elements of sci-fi, dystopian fiction, and the postmodern novel. She’s examining the history of human folly and our dire future prospects. The title refers to the Easter Island moai sculptures, huge statues that the natives created at the cost of the ecosystem of their island itself. Is there something deep in humanity that leads us inexorably toward disaster?

The first part of The Stone Gods is called “The Blue Planet.” We find ourselves on Orbus, a planet much like ours: ruined by pollution and war. Cosmetic technology is so advanced that humans, jaded by the ubiquity of perfect beauty, can no longer muster interest in sex. Nevertheless, humans have developed technology to harvest new people, and as a result the planet is threatened with overpopulation as well as environmental catastrophe. Government operative Billie Crusoe is assigned to fly to the newly discovered Blue Planet with a telepathic female-looking robot named Spike on a reconnaissance mission; the planet appears as amenable to human habitation as Orbus once was, except for the existence of dinosaurs that may impede colonization by humans. An ingenious attempt to eradicate the dinosaurs by steering an asteroid into the planet goes awry and the mission ends in failure.

On With the Story

Winterson’s fiction has always depended on folkloric elements: she tells stories within stories and has characters tell stories that echo throughout the narrative. Here, the stories are all recursive: people tell tales of second chances and squandered opportunities to make amends. Even DNA recombination is characterized as a sort of storytelling, the constant development and redevelopment of a text whose meaning changes with humanity itself. A spaceship captain talks about outer space in terms that sound more poetic than scientific:

‘There are valleys that lead to the bottom of the world, so it seems, but what world is that? The universe has no sides, no end, can’t be mapped. Enough to make a man talk about God, make a man superstitious and worship an idol. The science never gets as far as the strangeness. The more sophisticated my equipment, the stranger the worlds it detects. I sometimes think I’m sailing through a vast thought.’

In the wake of the first part, “Easter Island” tells the story of an eighteenth-century British sailor stranded on the island by mistake, who witnesses the suicidal folly of the islanders first hand. The Stone Gods are the products of misguided communal human endeavor, humanity’s attempt to make something greater than itself, and the compulsion always ends in disaster. Winterson has no love for religion, obviously, but her condemnation extends to government and technological progress too. She shows us that our creations may outlast us because of our short-sightedness in wanting to create them in the first place.

Our simian heritage has given us a lot of ingroup-outgroup instincts, and a warlike mentality that civilization only intensified. Religion has led to tribalism and the concept of unquestionable authority. Technological progress has made conquest and domination more efficient for the people in control. Revolutions only replace one form of oppression for another. Is there any hope?

War To End All War Until the Next War

In the final parts of the novel, Billie is once again narrating the story. However, this time she’s on Earth, a British woman who’s in charge of programming a sentient robot named Spike to be a more objective and rational version of a human. She recalls growing up in London, playing in the craters left by WWII; as an adult, she survived the war that left society in the chrome plated grip of corporate technocrats. As our narrator wanders in the dangerous outskirts of Tech City with Spike’s head in a backpack, the narrative connections start to implode and we’re confronted with questions about these intricately interwoven storylines and their characters. Did Billie herself write “The Blue Planet” as a plea for a fresh start for humanity (she says she found it on the Circle Line, another reference to recursion)? Will she obey her overlords and program Robo sapiens to replace us?

The Stone Gods is brilliantly written, with empathy, wit and great literary imagination (a verse by Donne recurs throughout the novel, and Billie Crusoe’s surname evokes the pitfalls of progress and exploration). Lovers of speculative fiction, literature, and black humor will find a lot here to enjoy.

"I cannot disagree with you that chemical weapons like VX are monstrous.I'm still going to ..."

The A-Bombs and the Downside of ..."
""Can you give an example of science producing a more violent or destructive invention than ..."

The A-Bombs and the Downside of ..."
"I guess a peer reviewed paper in psychology journals about ESP obviously legitimates ESP:https://www.petermcgraw.org...Or a ..."

Academic Hoaxes and Intellectual Dishonesty
"See? You cannot engage or discuss or even watch the videos.Listen to yourself for a ..."

Academic Hoaxes and Intellectual Dishonesty

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!