The Christian Guide to Dealing With Toxic Family Members

The Christian Guide to Dealing With Toxic Family Members May 25, 2018

Christians often struggle in relationships for the right and godly thing to do. Sometimes, we fall into the worldly narrative that we need to cut off “toxic people” from our lives. Yet, is this the biblical approach when the toxic individual is a family member?

Is there someone in your life whom you consider to be “toxic”?  If you do not love this difficult individual, or don’t have to deal with him or her being in your immediate circle, then draw your boundaries to eliminate or reduce any interactions. Life is too short to be wasted on trying to please everyone or making people love you when they don’t. However, if the individual in question is a family member or someone in your close social circle whom you love, then the following guidelines** may be helpful to Christians.

**see disclaimer at the end of this blog

  1. Refuse to see the individual as toxic. Choose to see the person or behavior as confusing at worst. Labeling them negatively puts them in a box, robs them of their humanity, gives you the false notion that you are excused from self growth, or that there is nothing you can do to improve the difficult relationship.
  2. Separate the behaviors from the person. We are more than the sum of our behaviors.
  3. Understand that not everyone reacts to a certain situation with the same emotions. The confusing person may seem toxic to you, but a wonderful, loving, completely relatable person under other circumstances.
  4. Identify the feelings these behaviors are invoking in you. Most likely, underneath the anger and stress is hurt and fear, possibly even grief from past rejection or loss.
  5. Listen to and accept your feelings. Respond to them rather than suppress or reject them.
  6. Identify the thoughts these behaviors are invoking in you. Thoughts are made up from neuron activities in the brain, but they also affect our physiological states, therefore our reality, our lived experience. Pay attention to them. Eastern Buddhists call this being mindful.
  7. Consult with a trusted friend or therapist regarding your thoughts. Reject the ones that are not true, honorable, right, pure, lovely, or admirable (see Philipians 4:8).
  8. Deny the temptation to stay in your echo chamber by venting or complaining with the same people about the same “toxic” individual. This is especially important when the confusing person is in the same family or close knit social circle with you. Who needs perpetual drama or strife when we can live with joy, love, and peace? It is especially important that parents model seeking peace and harmony in family relationships for their young children.
  9. While working to better understand and connect with this confusing person, set temporary boundaries to protect yourself from future hurt. One example is to choose to have someone else present when interacting with this individual (to keep your behaviors accountable, keep open communication, and give you a sense of security that deters any overreacting tendencies on your part). Another choice might be to temporarily limit communication to written ones, which give you more time to be thoughtful.
  10. Resist the urge to react out of anger, burning bridges, or making other hasty, impulsive choices that can have long term destructive effects (see Ecclesiastes 5:2).
  11. Refrain from thoughts of judging the individual negatively, blaming him for your suffering, attempting to change her, getting him to “pay” for his behaviors (see Romans 12:19).
  12. If you are a Christian, pray for the individual. Do not tell them in anger, “I’m praying for you!” Instead, quietly ask God to help you forgive this individual for the hurt you feel, and/or to humbly apologize and seek forgiveness. Pray for God to help you have a better, closer relationship with this person. Ask Him to bless and protect this individual. Ask God about how you can love this confusing individual better.
    pray for insight, wisdom, and courage
All this is difficult to do. It may involve a lot of tears and anguish, even feelings of despair, a sense of injustice, being forgotten, crushed from all sides, misunderstood, and feeling completely alone, weak, and inadequate. But I have found that with God, all things are possible. This is true not just for me, but for the folks I love, and for the clients I serve in the counseling office. There is hope for change, for a better, restored and healed relationship. But it starts with you not seeing your loved one as toxic.
**Disclaimer: these guidelines are not appropriate for situations of domestic violence, sexual abuse or unrepentant emotional abuse (no help sought).
Do you have a story of how you’ve done this and restored your relationship with someone? Can you think of anyone in your life for whom these guidelines might be helpful?
""Patriarchy" throughout sinful human societies has never, does not now, and cannot, deliver on God's ..."

Patriarchy Is Not A Bad Word
"Many Euro-American Christians do not understand the myriad of issues that impact people of color, ..."

Decoding Social Justice Warrior Language
""Lusitania" is the old Roman designation for what is now called "Portugal." The term "lusophone" ..."

Decoding Social Justice Warrior Language
"Yes, the woman at the well is one of many examples of how Jesus elevated ..."

Patriarchy Is Not A Bad Word

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Evangelical
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Brianna LaPoint

    Ironically, my christian family were the toxic ones. I guess people dont seem to comprehend that sometimes they cause their own chaos.

  • ScienceRules

    Seems to me that praying is a waste of time. Be proactive about the problem.

    Also, ask if your religious beliefs and/or practices are contributing to the problem? If so, stop believing or practicing them.

  • Daniel G. Johnson

    I suspect that a main reason for this kind of article in recent months is that many evangelicals are experiencing being cut off because of their support for Trump. For some reason, such evangelicals think that being cut off is irrational and not fair and not nice. For some reason, these evangelicals imagined there should be no personal consequences for joining a present day fascist movement.

    Well, like Mick Jagger said: You can’t always get what you want.

  • DDRLSGC

    Gee, how come the bible or the church authorities don’t talk about dealing with toxic people particularly if they are your bosses and family members? This article is of no value to millions of us who have to deal with toxic people on a daily basis which is why we have laws on the books to regulate their behavior which is no help since many of those toxic people are in positions of authority not to enforce the laws.

  • George

    And/or it could be that bitter Hillary voters, such as yourself, continue to be over-the-top verbally abusive toward anyone who doesn’t obey you.