The Great Enemy to Leadership: Flattery (Julius Caesar)

The Great Enemy to Leadership: Flattery (Julius Caesar) April 30, 2016

Bill Box U4 W78 1864-65, no. 2a
Bill Box U4 W78 1864-65, no. 2a

There are some men so great that even when they are hardly involved in an event, they dominate it. So it is with Shakespeare’s play Julius Caesar. The great man gives his name to the play, but was assassinated early. Death doesn’t keep a Shakespearean character from making an appearance later, but it does limit the number of lines. Brutus, the noble Roman who helps kill his friend in an attempt to save the Republic, is “there” far more than Caesar, but the play is all about Caesar.

Why?

Brutus loves Caesar, recognizes his greatness, yet cannot tolerate his friend’s lust for power.

He listens to lesser men who hope to use his rectitude to screen their jealousy of Caesar. Says Cassius:

Tis just:
And it is very much lamented, Brutus,
That you have no such mirrors as will turn
Your hidden worthiness into your eye,
That you might see your shadow. I have heard,
Where many of the best respect in Rome,
Except immortal Caesar, speaking of Brutus
And groaning underneath this age’s yoke,
Have wish’d that noble Brutus had his eyes.

Brutus is an honorable man, eager to save the Republic from a man who would be king, but he is vain about his honor. As a result, he is easy to flatter into a hopeless project: murder Caesar and save the Republic. Sadly, the Republic can no longer be saved. The decay is too great and the alternative to Caesar is simply a different dictatorship, perhaps an oligarchy under Cassius using Brutus as a genial frontman.

Compounding Brutus’ problems is that Caesar trusts him. He betrays his friend in the name of his cause. Brutus has no real alternative to Caesar but a hopeless civil war, but he deludes himself into believing he can revive the Republic. Brutus makes the same critical error that tempts many of us: we know what is bad, but we do not always know what is good. Brutus comes to believe that his friends and (especially) Brutus are the last true Romans.

He loves Rome, but not as it is. He thinks the Romans to be as they were and will not accept what they are or do the hard work of changing the times. He looks for one grand stroke that will redeem everything and is foolish enough to believe that he can do it. The fault is not in the stars, perhaps, but is also not just in Caesar or in his unwillingness to take Caesar out. The fault may lie in the Romans.

We can oppose evil, but we must also advance an alternative that is better. It is never good to let a bad man rule, but men like Julius Caesar are a mixed bag. A Christian facing Caesar must make a hard call: can the old political ways be saved or is Julius Caesar the best of bad alternatives.

Nobody wants to live at the fall of a regime, but if you do then you must measure what will work. Do not kill Caesar based on flattery and delusions that you can replace him only to plunge the state into two civil wars as his heirs squabble over who will replace him. Brutus is, as Antony points out, “an honorable man,” but he finds himself in the company of less honorable men than Caesar.

He confronts one thus:

Remember March, the ides of March remember:
Did not great Julius bleed for justice’ sake?
What villain touch’d his body, that did stab,
And not for justice? What, shall one of us
That struck the foremost man of all this world
But for supporting robbers, shall we now
Contaminate our fingers with base bribes,
And sell the mighty space of our large honours
For so much trash as may be grasped thus?
I had rather be a dog, and bay the moon,
Than such a Roman.

Brutus has destroyed a flawed man to empower a worse man. Americans must pause at this truth. In this election, like every other, let us be careful not to end the career of a great man simply because we fear him without an alternative.

We never have a chance to vote for a saint, even Abraham Lincoln was flawed and he was our greatest leader. He ignored habeas corpus and stretched presidential powers in other ways to win the War.  John Wilkes Booth assassinated Abraham Lincoln under the same delusion shared by Brutus. The tragedy of Booth is that he had performed as Marc Antony, but learned nothing from Shakespeare. He did not recognize that murder of a great man only immortalizes him and does nothing for your cause. Of course, the liberty that Booth was defending, the right of some men to own other men, was far worse than the cause of Brutus.

Brutus and Booth both needed to stop listening to the Devil’s flattery and face reality. You can oppose a great man, and sometimes you should, you can fight a great man, but you must never think death will stop him. Honor and betrayal cannot go together. Never save a ministry, a business, or a nation by stabbing a friend in the back. If we must fight, then as honorable men let us avoid conspiracy with bad men and fight above board and openly.

To kill Caesar in a cabal or smoked filled room . . . to stab him in an act of betrayal is to make a martyr of him. A Julius Caesar cannot be murdered safely. He will come back a legend in the hands of worse men. Flattery, especially about virtues, destroys many a good Christian leader to overreach himself and do harm. Yet this is true: even a mistake or failure done for honor’s sake is better than an action done for graft or envy. In his death Brutus (unlike the more wicked Booth) was recognized as a great and decent Roman. Says Antony who brought him down;

This was the noblest Roman of them all:
All the conspirators save only he
Did that they did in envy of great Caesar;
He only, in a general honest thought
And common good to all, made one of them.
His life was gentle, and the elements
So mix’d in him that Nature might stand up
And say to all the world ‘This was a man!’

Perhaps it is a sign of our decadent age that Brutus, a man ruined by listening to flattery and conspirators, is better than most of us in his approach of politics. He was unwise, but never for evil. May we do so well, but God spare us from flatterers and the errors of Brutus.

————————————————–

William Shakespeare went to God four hundred years ago. To recollect his death, I am writing a personal reflection on a few of his plays. The Winter’s Tale started things off, followed by As You Like It. Romeo and Juliet still matter, Lady Macbeth rebukes the lust for power, and Henry V is a hero. Richard II shows us not to presume on the grace of God or rebel against authority too easily. Coriolanus reminds us that our leaders need integrity and humility. Our life can be joyful if we realize that it is, at best, A Comedy of Errors.  Hamlet needs to know himself better and talks to himself less. He is stuck with himself so he had better make his peace with God quickly and should stay far away from Ophelia. Shakespeare gets something wrong in Merchant of Venice . . . though not as badly as some in the English Labour Party or in my Twitter feed. Love if blind, but intellectualism is blind and impotent in Love’s Labours LostBrutus kills Caesar, but is overshadowed by him in Julius Caesar. 


Browse Our Archives