Michael Wyschogrod on the Land of Israel

I read this passage by Jewish philosopher-theologian  Michael Wyschogrod years ago and recently bumped into it again. You can find it in his essay on “Judaism and the Land” in the book Abraham’s Promise. His conclusion is eloquent in both its caution and confident faith:

In our time, the people of Israel has returned to its land. Was it justified in doing so? Does this return signal the beginning of the redemption promised by God or is it a human act of will resulting from impatience and the secularization of Jewish consciousness? These are difficult questions to answer and will ultimately be answered by history. But whatever the answer to these questions may be, they concern only the issue of whether we should have waited longer. But that sometime Israel will return to the land which it has been promised by God cannot be in question because God has so promised. And if all this is true, then no claim to the land of Israel other than the Jewish claim is divinely validated.

And this is so even if, therefore, God is temporarily interposing another people between Israel and its land. The people who have come to dwell in the land during the estrangement of Israel from its land have been drawn into the vortex of a theological drame not of theri making. Their pain must be felt by Israel and the compassion that is the deepsest dimension of Jewish consciousness must be brought to bear on the problem. But none of this can obscure the eternal link between Israel and the land, a link that must, sooner or later, be reestablished (102-103).

"Frank is probably the greatest OT scholar of my generation. He is thoroughly evangelical, thoughtful ..."

OT Scholar Francis I. Andersen on ..."
"Thank you for your reply.1. I see how the author could believe that Adam could ..."

Why I Believe in Monocovenantalism
"Thank you for this explanation. It prompts these questions for me:1. Do the Scriptures indicate ..."

Why I Believe in Monocovenantalism
"Thanks, Michael, for this exposition of the covenants. If one sees a spectrum of (non)covenant ..."

Why I Believe in Monocovenantalism

Browse Our Archives



What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Jeff

    How is the Jewish people living in Israel and only in part of the inheritance with the Dome of the Rock where the temple is supposed to be, in any way a sign of anything?!

  • Jeff

    How is the Jewish people living in Israel and only in part of the inheritance with the Dome of the Rock where the temple is supposed to be, in any way a sign of anything?!

  • This somehow explains of what is happening with the country and it’s people. Great insight you have there.

  • This somehow explains of what is happening with the country and it’s people. Great insight you have there.

  • Barry Smith

    I studied for years with this man at The University of Houston. He is a very humble person. Teaching by example as well as books. One of the great experiences of my life. I have gone on to teach Buddhism at a college in Thailand. Often in my classes I think back to the lessons I learned from him.