What Curious George, Oz, Huckabees Have to Teach Us About Pain

I remember clutching to my Curious George doll when I was five years old, tears falling in a cloud of confusion. One hand holding on to my dad’s shirt and wondering why my sister and I were being taken away. That night, I was in so much pain. I still wonder how in one moment, how one person can experience so much loss? Are we destined to feel pain, to lose, to get diseases and die? Is this our fate? These are very loaded questions. Below is merely an opinion in response to those questions…

Pain forces us to look outside of ourselves. Sometimes in the middle of searching for the thing outside of us, we sometimes the thing that lies outside of us isn’t some ideal heaven waiting for us, but that heaven lies in the person next to us. Heaven is the realization that we don’t have to go through this alone. that no matter how hard, painful, diseased life gets that we are part of something even bigger than death — humanity.

Because hollywood is good at finding ways to distort our desire, or because our Sunday School teachers have been trained to believe in non-existent idealism, we have come to believe the lie that perfection lies somewhere over the rainbow. That Oz is waiting for us to find it. Don’t get me wrong, I am open to the possibility that Heaven does exist, but I think its a lot different than we think.

I think its here, now.
When we choose to be there for one another, that is heaven.

Some look at the early parts of Genesis as a narrative about sin and why we experience this groaning within, but I think that that explanation might fall short not only of its context, but also castrate the power of realizing that pain, disease, death are part of our divinity. That to be divine is to experience and embrace what we have come to call our depravity or fallibility.

That to experience pain, pleasure, sadness, grief, loss, disease is a part of the experience of what it means to be humanly divine.

This doesn’t mean we don’t try to journey on and make sense of why we experience what we experience. To me, that is an essential part of the journey, but to reduce our life experiences down to the cause of sin almost cheapens life down to a process where we fix something we aren’t capable of fixing.

Death, disease, pain and loss are inevitable as sun in the summer. But, they aren’t the enemy.

The Hebrew word for pain is ahahh, pronounced a-haw. It means ‘Oh’ with an exclamation. Its like the ‘Oh’ not again. Or ‘Oh’ I can’t believe this happened. Its an exclamation and epiphany of powerlessness over that situation. Not a bad place to be. It’s a good place to be. Why? Because it reminds us that there is something bigger than now that is happening. That we aren’t the center of the story. That there is more to our own importance at stake. To experience ‘Oh’ is to experience liberation out of our need to be in control.

Notice that the Hebrew word for pain isn’t a way to fix the pain. It embraces the pain as part of the reality, yet it still honestly responds to it. Sometimes we have this idea that to be self-less means to never mention our struggles, but what if our silence is impeding others in their opportunity to be there for you? Your grief is their growth. Your growth is their grief.

Pages: 1 2

Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell is Unjust

Defend Equality - Love Unites

Watch the Video by Lady Gaga: on-the-radar-dadt-vote-ahmadinejad-chopper-crash

“Matthew is gay and it makes me feel uncomfortable” – One of Matthew Sheperd’s detractors

Don’t ask don’t tell is willful ignorance to not know the person next to us. The flimsy principal behind the “don’t ask don’t tell” is the abstract principal of abjection. The direct irony of such a principal hides in the rhetorical intention, whereby someone doesn’t want to know whether someone else is gay, because if they did know, there would be a space for judgement and persecution. The problem with this idea is that in the middle of their desire to try and promote inclusion they endorse the spirit of false inclusion.

It is in our discomfort that the exclusion of the other arrives.

Homosexuality gets treated as the inherent ‘dirty little secret’ that should be kept secret. It’s in the belief of the heterosexual soldiers who share that if they don’t know the sexual orientation they can remain true friends in their staged relationships. The fatal flaw in this way of thinking is two-fold: (1) The truth of their relationships with their fellow soldiers are masked in their desire of ignorance and therefore only have relationships based on a forced discomfort (2) Most fears are found in superstitition. We as people need to make sense of our fears, which are naturally unknown entities.

Homophobia is one such fear.

Much like when we were children and were told about the monsters in our closet, (although they didn’t really exist)), because someone in a position of authority said they should, we easily believed the lie. Homophobia is the monster in the closet to which it should never have resided. There should be no closet where the fabled monster lives.

I think we have to come to a place where we meet truth without our superstitions.

The philosophy of ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ enforces a duplicitous engagement with our existentialism. It promotes a life where we are compelled to live in a non-existent reality and accept it as real, valuable and truthful and to deny the reality that is real, truthful and beautiful. The scandal of such a philosophy, is that it is completely unjust which is masks itself as justice. Ignorance isn’t justice.

Ignorance is distance.

Ignorance is violent abjection that seems to keep the peace but in reality endorses more violence than it seems to curb. It is in the abstraction of such a concept that we notice it denies the concrete ideology of Christ’s invitation to love our neighbour as ourselves (Matthew 22:37-39).

It seems Christ has an idea of what love looks like.

It has flesh, in this regard it is counter-cultural to the abstract idea that is perpetuated in the philosophy of don’t ask, don’t tell. To Christ, love is concrete rather than abstract. Also, I think its important to remember that Christ spoke Aramaic more than he probably spoke Greek. When Christ invites us to love our neighbour it is a term of vulnerability and radical openness. The word in Hebrew is ahab. It is very close to the Greek rendering of this word which tends to be agape. Embedded within the spirit of each definition is the idea of self-sacrifice.

A self-subverting revolution hidden in this one word.

A dying to ourselves. To our ideas. To our pride. To our ignorance. To love. To openly accept and embrace the person next to us. In Hebrew, the idea behind the word neighbour finds its redemption in how we treat the other. It isn’t the person across the fence or someone who borrow sugar, its a brother or sister who might have a need you could meet. This was a new kind of radical hospitality that informed how we relate to one another. In this moment of love, of ahab, the person who borrows a cup of sugar now becomes the brother or sister who helps inform our existence. The person who has a direct affect on how see the world and those others around us.

One of the best things that the American government can do is to participate in this rule of love by repealing the law that would create the very division that Jesus so vehemently spoke against. To truly ahab one another means we are willing to break down the very fences we so readily make to save us from changing our own worldviews. If the government does nothing, than they agree that to be human is to be contained, constrained and imprisoned by a mass majority who is uncomfortable with what it means to be human and wants to allow the discomfort of ignorance to lead us into an era we were never meant to be in.

My time in the US Navy involves the awareness of the unnecessary tension between the gay community. I remember hearing stories of the homosexual persecution by the heterosexual community and how it seemed so acceptable and unquestioned as a normal behaviour. How is ostracizing another human ‘normal’? How can defining what equality is be considered equal? In the midst of such a violent silence there is a spirit of denigration that overshadows this ignorant uknowing.

When we choose to not know our neighbour, we are choosing to devalue them and to agree with the lie that we are more valuable then they are because they don’t fit a certain definition. This should not be so.

If we as Christ’s follower are to help make this world a better place, I pray we can intentionally participate in this new kind of reality where there are no gays or heterosexuals, but the human family that exists as one because that is how we were created to be. If we deny this truth, than we deny the very fabric of our being. If we embrace this, than we accept that the world has the ability to be what it always could be.

Pakistan, Denying Them Answers, Job & God Overwhelmed

Fatal Tragedy / Beyond This Life

Pakistan is still reeling from the destruction of the floods. I have personal friends who are struggling through and offering their presence to these families. I think that’s the key, not offering them answers; answers can be destructive. Peace isn’t finding an answer to your problem, its knowing that you’re not alone.

The last thing we should do is offer the victims answers. We can’t control nature. If anything, nature reminds us time again that we are exiled from our illusions of power. Nature reminds us that we are truly unsovereign beings. Powerless, without answers to fix it all.

I recently watched 2012 with John Cusack, another apocalyptic narrative of humanity rescuing the world from the end of itself. But, I think that’s where the movie errs. I think we need to the world reach the end of itself. The more we sustain the world in the matrix of its empty promises, the more we become the sentient beings who exist only to insure its survival.

Much like the woman in the CNN footage who is mourning the tragic loss of her ‘Golden Boy’, I think Christianitys’ golden boy is the idea that we are meant to offer answers. If anything, we are more like the local fisherman who are there ‘fishing’ out the dead bodies. Our presence has more influence than any answer could. that is the dangerous assumption within the matrix of Christianity, that we have all the answers, and that the answers will fix everything. Sometimes the truth will imprison you rather than set you free.

If we think of truth as something that itself leads to an end, than truth will demonstrate its inflexibility by creating bars that we eventually will call home. I think that we have to come to a place where realize Christianity isn’t about offering answers, but rather presence. The answers negate the experience. Salvation in the orthodox sense is an answer, rather the idea of the incarnation was a helpless, powerless baby coming not to give answers, but to be present.

Salvation means healing, not healed.

There is a direct difference in those words, the semantic structure of each word says a lot about the intentions of who is bringing the salvation. Maybe, we can embrace truth as something that progresses and evolves, much like the ancient Eastern religions. Rather than trying to colonize truth and offer it others, maybe we can invite others to race with us discovering the speedily pace of truth that leads us into our own personal evolution.

Much like in the story of Job, God doesn’t respond to Job’s deep struggles with answers, in fact, he avoids them. Maybe like philosophe Slavoj Zizek posits, God is overwhelmed by how messy her creation really turned out. So, rather than offering answers to Job, God sits in the unrest with Job, God doesn’t rail at Job, God shares in the frustration. God and Job are overwhelmed by the experience — Together.

I think the last thing the gospel was meant to be was an answer.

Maybe a reminder that we’re not alone through the junk we go through. Maybe like the fisherman, we are looking for those moments of deadness and picking them up and sadly letting them go.

Notice when Jesus utters the words “I have come to give you life to the full” – he doesn’t say: ” I have come to give you a life filled with answers, with peace, with more money than you can handle, or anything the American dream can offer. The word for full or abundant in the Hebrew means overwhelming, more than you can handle.

A life consumed by life.

But in life, there is sadness, there is struggle, there is pain, there is hope, laughter, friendship, betrayal, and beauty. But, most of the beauty we experience is in the breakdown. Jesus offers consummation. Offers a space where can experience the overwhelming confusion and beauty all at the same time. If we offer people answers, than we deny them the experience of a life to the full.