A number of people, including my CT Movies editor Mark Moring, have asked whether a new Indiana Jones movie can work, given Harrison Ford’s age. But I think an even bigger question than the age of Indy is the question of when the movie will take place.
The two questions are related, of course. And how we answer them is further complicated by the fact that, in addition to the three earlier movies, Ford also played Jones in the framing narrative of an episode of The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles (1992-1994) — and in that episode, Ford and Jones were the same age, i.e. about 50.
I have never seen that show myself, but if this timeline is correct, it would seem that Indy was born on July 1, 1899. That would make him 13 in 1912, which is when the prologue to Last Crusade takes place (there, he is played by the 18-year-old River Phoenix, but hey, if 13-year-old Edward Furlong can play 10-year-old John Connor…). It would also mean Indy was 36 when Temple of Doom took place (Ford turned 41 during filming), 37 when Raiders of the Lost Ark took place (Ford turned 38 during filming), and 39 when Last Crusade took place (Ford turned 46 during filming).
Needless to say, the world was a very different place in the 1960s than it was in the 1930s; the Nazis were gone, and so was the British Empire (seen in Temple of Doom). So in what context could this new film take place? The original movies were nostalgia trips to the days of Saturday-matinee serials — but could that template work for a movie set two or three decades later? How could this new movie possibly be “of a piece” with the other films?
That, to me, is the crucial issue here, much more than Ford’s age.
Incidentally, in all the other episodes of The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles, the framing narratives basically take place “today”, i.e. 1992-1994, and concern a much older version of Indiana Jones; he was played by the late George Hall, a Toronto native who was born in 1916. And for what it’s worth, this older Indy had an eye-patch and apparently lived with his daughter and her family.
So who knows, maybe this new Indiana Jones movie will show us how Indy got that eye-patch — or how he got that daughter!