Ridley Scott’s Moses movie will be “shocking”, says Bale

I guess the makers of Exodus couldn’t let the new trailers for Noah get all the Bible-epic attention this week. Christian Bale, currently promoting the crime thriller Out of the Furnace, gave an interview to Hitfix recently in which he let slip a comment or two about Exodus, the currently-shooting Ridley Scott film in which Bale is playing Moses:

“It’s an intriguing piece, because it’s very few people that I’ve met that have actually read the Torah, the Pentateuch, the five books of Moses, all the way through,” Bale said. “Most people read snippets. If you read it all the way through, it’s harsh. It’s really ‘Old Testament.’ And violence in the extreme. He was not a man of any half measures whatsoever.”

Towards the end of the just-published article, Bale adds: “There’s a lot of shocking stuff about it.” And by “it”, he seems to be referring not just to the books of Moses, but to the film that is currently being fashioned out of those books.

Does anyone want to guess at what sort of “shocking” and “extreme” violence this film might have?

If it sticks to the Exodus and the events immediately following it, as Cecil B. DeMille’s The Ten Commandments (1956) did, this film could show how Moses really punished the Hebrews for worshiping the golden calf. (In DeMille’s film, the punishment comes from God, and God alone, without any human agency.)

And if it covers the 40 years of wandering in the wilderness, which DeMille skipped over, this film could show how the Israelites stoned a man to death for gathering wood on the Sabbath (an incident that was depicted in 1974’s Moses the Lawgiver).

I could totally see Ridley Scott zeroing in on stories like those and fleshing them out to show religion’s darker side, as it were. But, given how skittish movie studios can be with material that directly challenges the audience’s comfort zone, and given that this film was originally conceived as a battle epic of some sort, it’s possible that the violence will consist primarily of the battles that the Israelites fought against the Amalekites and others — which is another thing that DeMille skipped over.

As ever, we’ll just have to wait until the film is finished to see what Bale is referring to — which, in this case, means waiting until December of next year.

But given some of the statements that Russell Crowe and others have made about the title character in Noah, it does seem that we could have two films next year that use familiar Bible stories to raise disturbing questions about the relationship between violence and religion, and the extent to which the people who speak on God’s behalf sometimes go too far, even as they get certain very important things right.

November 19 update: Thanks to commenter “KEN” for alerting me to an interview that Bale did with Details recently. An excerpt:

DETAILS: What’s your take on Moses, one of the most iconic men—and beards—in history?
Christian Bale: I prefer to call him Moshe. Otherwise it’s like “Moooooses,” and everyone immediately thinks of Chuck Heston. Ridley and myself, we’d like to present a different interpretation. I’d never sat down and read the five books of the Torah—the Pentateuch—and there is some shocking stuff. Things you certainly never hear in Sunday school. He’s a fascinating guy, with all of the vulnerabilities and extraordinary capacities that come with being very human—almost too human, and quite harsh in his emotions. It’s a raw story when you break it down.

DETAILS: So, are we talking action-figure-ready Moses?
Christian Bale: I certainly wouldn’t want to call it an action film, though he fought a number of battles throughout his life. Let me put it this way: Any of us living today who arrived back then would be scared shitless.

Can’t argue with that.

Incidentally, regarding Bale’s reference to the late “Chuck Heston”: Did you know that they actually worked on a movie together? In 1990, they co-starred in a TV-movie adaptation of Treasure Island directed by Heston’s son. Bale, who was only 15 at the time, played Jim Hawkins, while Heston played Long John Silver.

One more bit of trivia: Joseph Gordon-Levitt provided the voice of Jim Hawkins for the Disney cartoon Treasure Planet (2002), which set the Robert Louis Stevenson story in space, a decade before he co-starred with Bale in The Dark Knight Rises (2012). And the latter film ended by revealing that Gordon-Levitt’s name was Robin. So both the Batman and the Robin in that film were former Jim Hawkinses.

It’s all connected, I tell you. It’s all connected.

About Peter T. Chattaway

Peter T. Chattaway was the regular film critic for BC Christian News from 1992 to 2011. In addition to his award-winning film column for that paper, his news and opinion pieces have appeared in such publications as Books & Culture, Christianity Today, Bible Review and the Vancouver Sun. He has also contributed essays to the books Re-Viewing The Passion: Mel Gibson’s Film and Its Critics (Palgrave Macmillan, 2004), Scandalizing Jesus?: Kazantzakis’s The Last Temptation of Christ Fifty Years on (Continuum, 2005) and The Bible in Motion: A Handbook of the Bible and Its Reception in Film (De Gruyter, 2016).

  • KEN

    In case you are still wondering… Exodus is going to be in 3D. The first 3D movie shot with 6K RED Epic Dragon. https://twitter.com/HybridVigorFilm/status/402214537018888193

  • KEN
  • KEN

    Obviously Bale kept in touch with the Hestons. According to Treasure Island DVD commentary by Fraser Heston, when Heston Sr. passed away, Bale, who was busy shooting Public Enemies in Chicago, flew across the country only to attend the funeral.

  • Phil Rohrer

    I’m really interested in finding out more about this film. I hope that it doesn’t veer as far from the Biblical account as the Noah movie apparently did (after hearing reviews from friends, I decided not to financially support it by spending money on a ticket). The timing of the Moses film’s release makes it particularly interesting to me and the other employees at the theatre where I work, because we have been immersed in studying all things Moses related for a few years now. We just put a new show on stage called “Moses”. I’m anxious to see Hollywood’s take on the story! http://www.sight-sound.com/WebSite/family-entertainment.do

  • Ralph Ellis

    Re: Moses and Eden – the exciting REAL story.

    (The Ridley Scott film, got it all wrong.)

    Firstly, The Exodus.

    The biblical Exodus did happen. Compare this list of historical events about the Hyksos Pharaohs:

    These people were called shepherds.
    They wore earrings and curly sidelocks of hair.
    They were circumcised.
    There was darkness and storms for three days (Tempest Stele)
    There was an ashfall, with the air thick enough to kill people (Thera)
    There was a battle (civil war) with the Egyptians.
    Tribute of gold, cloth and oil was given to make the shepherds leave (Tempest Stele)
    Some 500,000 of these shepherds went on the Exodus.

    They left from Pi Rammase (Avaris)
    There was a tsunami (Thera).
    They trashed Jericho.
    They went to Jerusalem (Manetho)

    A familiar story? Yes, the Israelites were the Hyksos Pharaohs and people. And Josephus Flavius, the greatest historian of Judaism, confirms this assertion. But if the Israelite Exodus was actually the Hyksos Pharaoh’s Exodus out of Egypt, then we also know why the biblical Plagues occurred. Just before the Exodus, the island of Santorini exploded, and covered the eastern Mediterranean with ash.

    This is why Moses says that he took ash from a fire, and scattered it all over Egypt (Exodus 9:10). There could not be a better description of the long-range ash-fall from the volcanic eruption at Santorini. So yes – the entire history of the eruption of Santorini (Thera), and the entire Hyksos Exodus event out of Egypt, is narrated within the record of the biblical Exodus.

    Please see:
    Jesus, Last of the Pharaohs
    Tempest and Exodus
    Scota, Egyptian Queen of the Scots


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X