Hypocrisy in the Catholic Church

The New Yorker‘s George Saunders once walked into church and found his priest doing… naughty things.

Even more shocking: This is not an altar-boy story:

Normally on Wednesdays I found Father X working at something in the sacristy. This Wednesday, I came up the aisle quietly, so quietly that I discovered Father X and a nun I’ll call Sister Y in the middle of — well, I couldn’t figure out what they were doing. It appeared to be some particularly athletic form of kissing, involving tongues and a lot of snakelike extraneous limb and torso motion, as if this new kind of kissing were filling them with painful electricity.

I stood watching. (In memory, I am frozen in midstep, one sneakered foot in the air, my mouth a little O, like the mouth on a choirboy in a glass Christmas town.)

Then I backed silently out.

Wow wow wow.

There was no way I had just seen that.

What a world, that contained even this.

By now I knew enough about the time in which I was living to know that one of our fundamental narratives was that a critical moment of disillusion could be followed by a bitter but justified downward slide into decadence. Having seen what I had seen, in other words, entitled me to cry Hypocrites! and leave religion behind forever.

This vignette proved, in effect, that the whole religion deal was a sham.

Didn’t it?

It did not. Saunders’ faith remained.

Father X and Sister Y eventually left the Church for unrelated reasons (and not at the same time).

It’s a short read written by someone who is still faithful, despite his finding plenty of reason to doubt.

[tags]atheist, atheism, Christian[/tags]

"> The which had nothing to do with my point that religion, that political machine ..."

Richard Dawkins Will Soon Offer Free ..."
"Depends which attributes we're discussing. The ones that could be abstracted away and used standalone ..."

Richard Dawkins Will Soon Offer Free ..."
""5. To believe that all the prophets are true. However, we are commanded to follow ..."

This Pro-Muslim Video Attempts (and Fails) ..."
"“Except that cancer isn’t an organism”Yes, it is.In a paper published in the July 1 ..."

Here’s Why the Fertility Clinic “Dilemma” ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment