Clearly both signs are equally ridiculous because we all know God doesn’t exist.
A rational god worthy of worship would have that preference. There’s no evidence for such a god, alas, and most Christian denominations don’t seem to worship a rational god.
Nice start, but are you trying to re-create http://www.snopes.com/photos/signs/dogheaven.asp ? It could be a funny debate.
Just a heads up: the “in response to this post” link is broken. Looks like it’s got an 05 where it should have an 06.
Ha ha, that was good thanks.
The one on the left has 2 crosses, so it wins.