You can be skeptical and friendly at the same time.
Follow Patheos Atheist:
Brandon Fibbs honors the 50th anniversary of “Doctor Who,” calling it a “consistent beacon of humanism,” with this fantastic clip compilation:
Hemant Mehta is the editor of Friendly Atheist, appears on the Atheist Voice channel on YouTube, and co-hosts the uniquely-named Friendly Atheist Podcast. You can read much more about him here.
Not quite Humanism, more like Timelordism.
I LOVE Dr Who!
There’s a brilliant scene in the Daemons where the Doctor is arguing with a witch as to whether what is going on is science or magic. After finally convincing her to back down, he starts going on about psychic energies and crystals and the like. But it’s science, because he knows how it works.
…because people can be so, so much more…
I looooooove the Doctor! It makes me happy. Except for that awful Titanic episode as well as the Agatha Christie bee one as well. Those made me depressed.
A delightful video, thanks so much for sharing it
And Van Gogh. But that one I LOVED because of the feelings it inspired.
Such a great TV show.
Thanks for the clip.
I love Dr Who. Just looking out of my office window across the harbour I can see the BBC Wales studio where it is made. Last week I saw the Prince of Wales and Camilla walking strolling along there with a Darlek.
The Van Gogh episode makes me cry EVERY time
(Arthur C.) Clarke’s third law states “Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic”
Am I the only atheist that’s never seen an episode of Dr. Who? I’ve also never seen an episode of Star Trek and I didn’t quite care for The Matrix. Do I get to keep my membership?
Nope, sorry. Turn in your A card.
I’ve never been happy with that because I’ve always felt that a sufficiently advanced culture, when face with technology more advanced than its own, should be able to tell the difference.
We’re atheists, not religious people. We don’t excommunicate members for being different. That’s for religious people. We, on the other hand, sit those different from us down in a chair and force them watch the right shows, damn it!
… I love Dr. Who, but I think that calling it out as a beacon of humanism is a little naive. A large portion of the character is a thinly veiled metaphor for Christ. The more-than-human that comes to save mankind, looking and acting like a man, complete with resurrection. A Christmas special every year, which could be chalked up to secular celebration, but they even start each new season on Easter! They’re not trying real hard to disguise the connection.
The video was taken down. Does anyone have a mirror?
Nope. I have friends who are huge fans and I have never seen an episode. (Though I’ve absorbed enough to at least recognize a lot of the references I come across.) The only Star Trek I’ve seen is a couple movies and a lot of the original series that my ex had (mostly on VHS). I saw the Matrix once and I remember very little of it. Maybe we should break off and start an A- movement.
Yeah, well after seeing this video…I had no idea he was like the British Carl Sagan. It’s officially on deck in my Netflix queue. I can get by without watching the old ones, right?
Sure! I like to throw horseshoes, play ping-pong, and teach myself retro-80′s and Tim Minchin songs on the piano. There’s usually gin involved. Can that be a thing?
Am I the only one around here that doesn’t have a Netflix queue? I hate that.
Yes, you can. Start with the 1st season in 2005, the Ninth Doctor, and go from there. Watch your brain, though. They like to throw curve balls into the plots that don’t hit you in the head until 3 years later.
Please, Christ wishes he was the Doctor.
Cool! I’m a huge Tim Minchin fan! (Though I was never very good on the piano.) My family has a ping-pong tournament every year at Christmas (though I suck at it). But as long as there is an option for an vodka alternative, I’m cool with that.
To be honest, I grew up with the original Doctor Who and the new stuff has never really settled with me… Ecclestone was a good Doctor, Smith is doing well, but Tennant… Kill it with fire, DAMN he was almost as bad as Sylvester McCoy…
Can’t see the video, though, echo the calls for a Mirror
There’s always a vodka alternative. Make no mistake about it…I’m not implying that I’m good on the piano either. On the contrary, I’m a talentless hack. Fortunately though, I’m completely shameless.
It can be rectified with a measly 8 bucks a month.
No, I have Netflix. I meant that queue where you can mark shows for future watching. A couple of my friends have that, but I don’t.
I will have to watch that later. My work blocks the ‘tube
Awww.. video is gone… stoopid copyrights
What’s a “Darlek”? You love it so much you still can’t spell Dalek?
The UK version of Netflix doesn’t include an instant queue. The US version does. Your friends might be either not British or using a proxy.
Why would I be using the UK version of Netflix?
Nu-who made it pretty explicit, but also showed the drawbacks to such associations. If they did it in the classic version, I bet it was purely accidental. =)
And the Doctor doesn’t demand to be worshipped in return for saving the cosmos. In fact he doesn’t even like being saluted.
The interesting thing is that they do address that in the show. The Waters of Mars episode is one where they examine the Doctor’s hubris.
Girl Genius argues that any sufficiently analyzed magic is indistinguishable from science.
Is this video mirrored anywhere? the original has been taken down due to copyright claim
And Florence Ambrose (of Freefall) once graffitied that, regardless of how advanced a society is, science will look like magic to people who don’t understand how it works.
That’s a bit of a stretch.
When Doctor Who was created, the Doctor didn’t regenerate. This was added later to explain why there was a new actor for the role.
I’ll admit, some of the David Tennant episodes did get a little too close to Jesus for me towards , but that was very brief.
Using religious metaphors doesn’t make a show religious. It’s a metaphor that most Westerners understand, but that doesn’t mean we have to buy into it as real. Anyway, in my opinion the Christ imagery was mostly a Russell T. Davies thing, and is not an integral part of the series as a whole.
You get to keep your membership, but you should do yourself a favor and watch both “Doctor Who” and “Star Trek.” They’re both very worthwhile.
No I don’t have one of those, either (I don’t have Netflix).
*applauds* Your daugher (I’m assuming) is cute
The Van Gogh episode was amazing. It makes me cry too.
The Titanic and Christie ones were depressing because I hated them.
Also I don’t think the RTD stuff was about the christian religion, it was just another way that the second half of the Tennant era could constantly heap an insufferable amount of praise on the Doctor.
The first episode I remember that explicitly says the Doctor is traveling all of time and space in order to save people was “Love and Monsters”. Take that for what it’s worth.
Since YouTube has pulled the vid due to copyright claim, I saw a couple o’ folks looking for an alternative. Looks like LiveLeak has it available for the moment: http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=79d_1374040894
And now it’s gone. Oh well. I tried.
Search the title. It’s been put up a half dozen other places but may not stay there for long. I am fighting a copyright issue with a particularly dislikable user.
Search the title on YouTube. It’s been put up a half dozen other places but may not stay there for long. Changes will be made and it will be reuploaded soon.
Follow Patheos on