This Pro-Life Christian Website Has an Unusual Commenting Policy…

If you run a website like this one, you have to consider how you want to handle comments. I prefer letting my posts speak for themselves and allowing commenters to agree or criticize as they see fit. Regular readers know I welcome religious voices (or critical atheist voices, for that matter) and I remove trolls to the best of my abilities.

LifeSiteNews, a Christian website covering stories appealing to social conservatives (pro-life, anti-gay, you get the drift) has plenty of stories worth picking apart, but they’re not interested in a true dialogue. Their commenting guidelines actually state in writing how little they care about voices that disagree with them:

I’m all for thoughtful, respectful comments and I definitely understand a firm line on moderation. But I just don’t understand this:

LifeSiteNews gives priority to pro-life, pro-family commenters and reserves the right to edit or remove comments.

That’s a fancy way of saying “Don’t comment here unless you already agree with us.” Forget banning trolls; they don’t even want to see sane, well-thought-out ideas from people who want to provide an alternative, opposing perspective.

So I just have to ask: Why bother?

What’s the point of a comment thread if the invitation is basically extended only to those who already agree with you? Why write opinion pieces if you’re not looking to start a conversation? Wouldn’t you just be better off closing comments for good?

Incidentally, this came up only because reader Dennis told me he tried to post a response to this awful article, but his comment didn’t even go into moderation. He was banned from the get-go, it seems, because he’s an atheist who is known to disagree with the site’s views.

I’ve asked LifeSiteNews why they do this. I’ll update this post if I hear back.

"So you are willing to let them die because they aren't your responsibility or your ..."

Here’s Why the Fertility Clinic “Dilemma” ..."
"This is only anecdotal, of course, but they did show it here in the shadow ..."

Does Anybody Know Who Roy Moore’s ..."
"What would be abusive is to force me to carry a dead fetus to term ..."

Here’s Why the Fertility Clinic “Dilemma” ..."
"Expecting religious moral absolutists to understand the nuance of the reality of abortion is like ..."

Catholic Priest: It’s Unethical to Install ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment