Nebraska’s Supreme Court Has Rejected a Foster Child’s Request for An Abortion

On Friday, the Nebraska Supreme Court refused a 16-year-old girl’s request for an abortion. The girl, who is a ward of the state after being taken away from her abusive parents, lacks a guardian who can provide the required parental consent, leaving her in a legal limbo.

Nebraska’s Supreme Court

According to the ruling, the judges voted 5-2 against her because she was unable to prove that “she is sufficiently mature and well informed to decide on her own whether to have an abortion.”

As Jos at Feministing put it, those justices believe a 16-year-old girl in foster care is old enough to have and raise a child… but not old enough to have an abortion.


One of the lower court judges, the “honorable” Peter C. Batallion, went so far as to tell this teen “when you have the abortion, it’s going to kill the child inside of you,” and asked her if she would “rather do that than risk problems with the foster care people.”

It’s just sickening what this girl is dealing with: Jump through loopholes to terminate the pregnancy so that she doesn’t jeopardize her placement in the foster system (or her own future), or keeping an unwanted ‘child inside of her’ and risk being thrown out by her admittedly conservative foster parents.

To paraphrase a commenter at Raw Story, this is a decision not based in common sense or the girl’s maturity level. It’s a religion-based ruling made by a predominantly male court.

She deserved a better outcome than this.

"The point I don't get in all this is why humanism seeks to identify as ..."

Christian Right Leader Claims, Falsely, “There ..."
"“There’s something wrong when a Catholic school tells a comedian he can’t talk about sexual ..."

Hannibal Buress Kicked Off Stage at Loyola ..."
"“Under his wings shall you find refuge"Just don't expect us to let any of those ..."

Conservatives Say Ohio Town’s Christian Mural ..."
"I didn't throw out my degrees to bolster my argument, but rather to defend against ..."

Women Must Break Free from Religion’s ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment