Ontario Court: Doctors Who Oppose Assisted Dying Must Refer Patients

In Canada, where it’s legal for terminally ill patients to end life on their own terms, there’s a potential religious conflict in play: What happens when those patients have doctors who oppose assisted suicide and refuse to help them? A lot of Christian doctors say it violates their religious freedom to end the life of a patient, even one who’s suffering.

There’s finally an answer to that question. Ontario’s Divisional Court ruled on Wednesday that religious doctors who won’t abide by the law must refer terminally ill patients to a doctor who will help end their lives.

Shanaaz Gokool, chief executive of Dying With Dignity, applauded the ruling.

“It’s a stunning decision that really puts the rights of the most vulnerable residents of this province ahead of the rights of clinicians” who object on religious grounds. “It’s a fair balance of rights.”

Ontario has set up a co-ordination centre to help patients seek physicians to assist in death. But some patients, Ms. Gokool said, are not healthy enough to speak and don’t have family or a support team that can contact the centre; they may therefore need their doctor to make the referral.

This is a fantastic decision. Much like Christian pharmacists who won’t fill birth control prescriptions, the government has an obligation to protect the rights of patients. If religious doctors won’t do their jobs, they have to send patients to doctors who will. It’s not like the government is forcing them to end a life. And requesting a referral is a way to strike a balance between opposing sets of beliefs.

(Image via Shutterstock. Thanks to Lorne for the link)

"My parents put me on Ritalin when I was two years oldIFAIK, methylphenidate has never ..."

Indian Woman: I Had to Skip ..."
""Homeopathy goes off the rails..."Wasn't on the rails to begin with."

Here’s Why Homeopathy Is Completely Ineffective ..."
"Yeah, that diet doesn't mesh with my sensory or nutritional needs. (We won't talk about ..."

Here’s Why Homeopathy Is Completely Ineffective ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment