“The final episode of the cold war”

Violence is intensifying in the Ukraine, as a truce between pro-Western protesters and the Russian-dominated government fell apart. The protesters are getting weapons and more regions of the country are rising up.

Read George Will on the relationship between nationalism, democracy, and communism and on the significance of what is happening in Ukraine.  He calls it “the final episode of the cold war.”

From George Will: Is Ukraine the Cold War’s final episode? – The Washington Post:

One hundred years ago this coming Aug. 4, the day Britain declared war on Germany, socialists in the German Reichstag voted for credits to finance the war. Marxists — including Lenin, who that day was in what now is Poland — were scandalized. Marx had preached that the proletariat has no fatherland, only a transnational class loyalty to proletarians everywhere. “In 1918,” wrote Louis Fischer, Lenin’s best biographer, “patriotism and nationalism, born of the ‘subjectivism’ Lenin so disliked, were ideological crimes in Soviet Russia.”

These are history-shaping virtues in Ukraine today. Because the nation-state is the necessary framework for durable political liberty, nationalism is a necessary, although insufficient, impulse sustaining liberty. Marx, whose prophesies were perversely predictive because they were almost invariably wrong, predicted the end of nationalism. Economic forces, he said, determine political, cultural and psychological realities. So capitalism, with its borders-leaping cosmopolitanism, would dilute to the point of disappearance all emotional attachments to nations. Ukraine’s ferment is an emphatic, albeit redundant, refutation of Marxism.

[Keep reading. . .]

 

"I really don't get your first point. Who, exactly, is proposing that it shouldn't count ..."

School Shooting in Florida Kills 17
"Mallory,Actually, when teaching Computer Science, Information Technology, and freshman Math, there weren't many opportunities to ..."

Mallory Millett’s Critique of Her Sister’s ..."
"Both sexes have pitfalls and problems. Male dominance and female dominance are both problematical. That’s ..."

Mallory Millett’s Critique of Her Sister’s ..."
"Laurel,You refused to prove the easiest claim you made. That makes it difficult to equate ..."

Mallory Millett’s Critique of Her Sister’s ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment