Recently someone suggested to a group of mostly closeted atheists in the Deep South that maybe they shouldn’t be closeted at all. Maybe they should “come out” because so many Americans are already too judgmental towards non-believers and the only way to counter that is for more of us to openly identify ourselves. That may very well be the case, and I do hope more of us can make that transition with a minimal amount of loss in our personal lives. But there are at least a couple of issues which are lost on people not from our region of the country.
The first should be fairly obvious to anyone who lives where I live: Coming out as an atheist in the Deep South can cost you your friends, your job, and even your family. I know this because I am in touch with hundreds of southern atheists like myself who have experienced significant losses in each one of these areas. Many have suffered losses in more than one of these categories and I even know some who have experienced all three. Never mind the legality of losing your job for being an atheist—it still happens. Court cases can sometimes turn on a character judgment and if a judge or jury believes that being an atheist makes you a bad person, that will affect their perception of you. The same thing is true of employers. Judges and employers are still people and people have biases which affect their perceptions of others.
But there’s another kind of difficulty which people like me face after we identify ourselves as atheists: Even those who still accept us become less comfortable being around us, and that creates an unwanted emotional distance. This consequence is perhaps more subtle than the first but it is much more prevalent. From the moment a friend, family member, or coworker learns this about me, they start editing themselves. They suddenly feel the need to avoid certain subjects or else to preface statements with “Now I know YOU don’t believe this, but I believe that…” Because I live in Mississippi, the chances are good that I’ve already heard whatever you’re about to say at least five times today.
I do not personally require any disclaimers or qualifications, and frankly I’d be happier if you could just not edit yourself at all—just talk to me like you would anybody else with whom you are comfortable. The truth is, however, that they do not only do this for my benefit (if they do then let this be my announcement to STOP IT because I can handle a difference of opinions…I’m quite used to it, I assure you). They also do this because it makes them uncomfortable to know that I don’t share the same assumptions about the world that they do, and this makes them feel they should preface each important statement with an acknowledgement of our differences. But this is terribly awkward, and it creates a distance between us which would never have been there had I not told them at some point in the past that I am not a Christian.
That’s the second reason why many of us don’t openly identify ourselves as atheists. The awkwardness and the unnecessary distance are unpleasant and they never would have been there had we not “come out” in the first place. At times, this awkwardness can even lead some to count us out of things (e.g. conversations, get-togethers, etc) because they would feel the need to be more guarded around us regardless of whether or not we would ever verbalize any disagreement with anything they’d say in such a social setting. We wouldn’t have to—the mere knowledge that we think differently on something as important as religion is enough to scare many away. Religious beliefs are such a sensitive subject for so many that they’d rather not have to deal with the disparity at all if they can avoid it.
Maybe such things don’t bother you. I know many who seem oblivious to this. But some of us are bothered by these things, particularly if they happen within some of our primary relationships (e.g. with our spouses, children, parents, siblings, or close friends). Now, I’ll admit that there comes a time when you have to say something in order to maintain an honest relationship. But hopefully this post will explain why some of us are very reluctant and slow to “come out” of the atheist closet.