Romney’s son follows “Crate Gate” with another pet that “rides outside”?

From Mitt Romney's son's blog. The caption on this photo read: "Our fearless sidekick. This fish has cheated death more times than I can remember."

I told you this week about the story of Mitt Romney and “Crate Gate,” the 30-year-old story about a family trip where Seamus, the family dog, was forced to ride on the roof in a carrier.

Several people have asked me if maybe it was time to forget about the story, given that it happened 30 years ago. I think that if there was a sense that Romney realized that making a dog ride for 12 hours strapped to the roof of a car was a bad way to treat an animal, then yes, I would say it’s time to forgive and move on. (I don’t know that he has … has he?)

But our pal Rusty, of DogsAgainstRomney.com, just alerted us to a story from Andrew Sullivan at The Daily Beast  about a cross country road trip Mitt Romney’s son Craig and his pals took with another “pet”: a fish, who was kept in a water bottle and strapped to various parts of the moving van for the trip.

Like father, like son? 

The blog where the photo was originally found, www.RoadEndsInWater.blogspot.com, has now been made private. But as most young people have never learned, everything on the internet stays on the internet forever. (In fact, one of Rusty’s pals just shared this link to the cache of the blog. Looks like they had a fun trip. Even got to pet some wolves.)

So yup, a little digging turned up a couple of photos of the fish in the water bottle. I originally posted and then decided to remove the photo that showed the fish bottle hanging from the rearview mirror while someone was driving. In the end, it doesn’t matter. The fish – a Betta – was still in a water bottle, but at least we know it got to ride inside!

I’m still pondering if a fish in a bottle hanging outside (or inside) the car is the same as a dog on a roof? Methinks … not … ? Believe it or not, this is kind of complicated for me. It’s a fish … and I wanted to say “just a fish”. But then again, God’s eye is on the sparrow … “just” a sparrow?

Billy Murray carried a fish in jar around his neck in “What About  Bob” and it was cute – but in Hollywood, there’s someone on the set to oversee the humane treatment of all animals, insects, and other living creatures used in filming. (Even flies.) Gill surely had a constant supply of fresh water and mandatory coffee breaks. Not so much a fish in a water bottle swinging from a rear view mirror.

I’d love to know what you think:  Does a fish feel the same terror riding 70 mph down the highway as Seamus the dog did riding atop the family car? Are Romney’s son and his pals just having some fun, or is this a legitimate case of mistreatment of an animal? (Or in this case, a fish … ) And more importantly, does (and should) the story of Crate Gate affect your voting decision?

And here’s a question: if this fish story got you worked up, does this story also make you feel the same way?

RELATED POST:

  • Story of Romney’s dog tied to roof angers dog lovers (and voters)
    • Pingback: Story of Romney’s dog tied to roof angers dog lovers (and voters) « Heavenly Creatures

      • Kim

        I would never vote for a candidate that mistreated pet–and I am a republican!

    • http://www.dogsagainstromney.com Rusty

      More troubling than whether the fish rode inside or outside is the Romney son’s comment that the fish had “cheated death more times than I can remember.” How does a store bought pet fish “cheat death” repeatedly unless it’s owner deliberately exposes it to that possibility? To me, it’s evidence of a continued callousness toward “lesser” beings – the question is: to the Romney’s, just where is the line drawn between themselves and “lesser” beings?

      Now my puppy brain is tired.

      Rusty

      • Joanne Brokaw

        That is a good point, Rusty!
        Woof!
        Joanne

      • Joanne Brokaw

        PS, Rusty: I actually have been thinking about “lesser” beings, only on a broader perspective. I wanted to say it was “just” a fish. But really, is a fish ever “just” a fish? Don’t all living things deserve what they need to live without pain or struggle? These might seem like silly stories to some, but they are actually stretching me to think outside the box. Or fish tank. ;)

        Joanne

        • Jimmy Gunn

          Cool! It’s good to think about more than just our tiny little slice of the world. I must admit I eat meat but I would be willing to do that less or not at all if circumstances were different. While I can’t claim complete innocence myself, I refuse to engage in needless cruelty and try to help any beings (esp. humans) it is in my little power to help, as you do also I think.


    CLOSE | X

    HIDE | X