Florence King once called George Orwell “Every conservative’s favorite liberal and every liberal’s favorite conservative.” Why? Conservatives invoke his critiques of totalitarianism. Progressives appeal to his attacks on reactionary politics. Orwell is easily bent to many ends — like the Bible.
Here’s an enlightening quote from a review in The New Statesman:
Since whoever we are (save for a few sad Leninists) we all agree with George Orwell, it usually follows that Orwell must agree with us. Whatever our 21st-century predilections, Tory or leftist, conservative or progressive, we discover blessings and endorsements somewhere in Orwell’s words. We grab him for ourselves.
How often do Christians do that with the Bible? We all agree with the Bible, so we assume the Bible must agree with us. By that I mean that we assume the Bible must agree with our unique take on faith and life, even if it’s a marginal opinion without much representation in the history of the church.
As long as we can find a prooftext in there someplace we feel thoroughly entitled to our opinions and regard them as unassailable, backed as they are by The Ultimate Authority. But of course often enough we are only bending it to our own ends. Like Orwell, the Bible just becomes a mirror.