HOME-STATE SHAME: Michigan Democratic Congresswomen to Perform V-Monologues on Capitol Steps

How low can you go? 

Michigan Rep. Lisa Brown (D-West Bloomfield)

Last Thursday in my home state of Michigan, Democratic Congresswoman Lisa Brown was barred from speaking on the House floor, after making a crude reference to her female anatomy during a speech.  Brown had been speaking against a House initiative to ban late-term abortions after the twentieth week of gestation, when she said, “Finally, Mr. Speaker, I’m flattered you’re all so interested in my vagina, but ‘no’ means ‘no’.”

A spokesperson for Michigan Representative James Bolger explained later that she had been banned for failing to maintain decorum.

And fair enough.  It’s easy to imagine the uproar among feminists, had a male Representative spoken in Congress about his own reproductive organs.  He’d have been quickly shunned as vulgar and ill-mannered.  Apologies would have been demanded by the aggrieved females.

Lisa Brown has no plans to quietly take to her seat, however—nor do Democratic women plan to let the issue die.  On Friday, the Dems—supported by controversial playwright Eve Ensler—hastily crafted plans for a presentation of “The Vagina Monologues”, a highly sexualized play centered around women’s gender issues, on the steps of the state capitol in Lansing.  The play has been criticized for its graphic portrayals of sexual encounters, rape, masturbation, and lesbian sex acts.  The Michigan congresswomen’s performance will be held Monday, June 18, from 6:00 to 8:00 p.m. 

According to a new website, VAGINAS TAKE BACK THE CAPITAL, Ensler will join at least 16 Democratic congresswomen in the performance.  Local and state activists and actors have signed on to perform in the play, as well as 16 Democratic politicians.  Politicians who have signed on to perform in the play to date include Sen. Rebekah Warren (D-Ann Arbor), Sen. Gretchen Whitmer (D-East Lansing), Rep. Barb Byrum (D-Onondaga), Rep. Stacy Erwin-Oakes (D-Saginaw), Rep. Dian Slavens (D-Canton Township), Rep. Rashida Tlaib (D-Detroit), Rep. Lisa Brown (D-West Bloomfield), Rep. Vicki Barnett (D-Farmington Hills), and Rep. Joan Bauer (D-Lansing).  The webpage promises that more will be announced soon.

Senator Whitmer, the highest ranking woman in Michigan state government, was quoted in the group’s press release:  “I want my two daughters to know that their Mom and countless other women stood up for them as they grow into the next generation of strong women.” 

Whitmer’s, Brown’s and the other women’s daughters will know:  (1) that their mothers were willing to resort to vulgar political theatre to achieve immoral political goals, and (2) that they, the daughters, were fortunate to have been born at all, since their mothers were willing to kill a developing fetus even after viability in order to protect their own selfish interests.

For Mothers Everywhere: On Scrubbing Toilets and the Challenger Disaster

Twenty-six years ago, on January 28, 1986, the Space Shuttle Challenger broke apart 73 seconds into its flight, disintegrating over the Atlantic Ocean off the coast of central Florida.  All seven of its crew were killed, including the “Teacher in Space,” Christa McAuliffe.

On this sad anniversary, it’s not space flight I want to talk about, though.  I want to talk about jealousy, and about the seasons of life.

When the Challenger exploded, I had three young children at home.  To supplement our family income, I had taken a few neighbors’ children into our home, as well, providing after-school snacks and homework help for the children of working parents.

My life, it seemed at the time, revolved around cleaning toilets and changing diapers.  Oh, sure, I had made the choice to stay home to mother my children.  Together we read stories and baked cookies, sang the ABCs with gusto, embarked on sun-splashed walks in search of caterpillars and wildflowers.  But when would I ever have an opportunity to use my business education, my college degree, the skills for which I’d trained?

It was around that time that I met Dr. Sharon Newman Bordine.  Sharon, a science teacher here in Southeastern Michigan, had been selected as part of NASA’s “Teacher In Space” program.  She was a stand-in for Christa McAuliffe.  Had McAuliffe so much as caught a cold in the weeks leading up to the Challenger’s final flight, Sharon Bordine might well have replaced her on the ill-fated voyage.

But McAuliffe walked smiling and waving onto the Challenger that day.  As John Magee wrote in his poem “High Flight,” quoted by President Ronald Reagan after the disaster, she “slipped the surly bonds of earth…and touched the Face of God.” 

And Dr. Sharon Bordine went on to serve as a NASA Space Ambassador, visiting high schools and science classes and generating enthusiasm for space exploration.  Sharon was a local celebrity, visiting the White House, appearing on television and radio to promote the space program. 

But Sharon’s saga of privilege and adventure doesn’t end there.  Sharon told me about how she had met her husband, local nursery owner Bruce Bordine, at church, and how Bruce had proposed to her while they were on a church-sponsored pilgrimage, as they sailed on the Sea of Galilee.

The point/counterpoint was discouraging: 

  • SHE:  touring the world, speaking for NASA, and getting engaged in the Holy Land.
  • ME:   hand-picking Play-Doh out of the carpet, running the vacuum, and serving up macaroni and cheese on paper plates.

I was…. Well, I felt…. I thought….  Geez, I was jealous as hell!  I mean, I was hardly a world traveler:  I’d been on a few road trips across theUnited States, I’d crossed the Ambassador Bridge to Canada—but that’s about it.  Adventure?  I couldn’t imagine that in my plebeian, suburban life I would ever have a real adventure.

That was then, this is now.  The kids whom I loved half to death grew up and moved away; and what I wouldn’t give to have back those earnest little hands to wash, those breezy days of hugs and giggles and whispered secrets. 

I’ve had some grand adventures.  I’ve flown across the ocean not once, but six times, and I plan to do it again.  I’ve met the Pope and kissed his ring.  When the time was right, I returned to the workforce.  I’ve had a satisfying career, a joy-filled marriage, and a home that’s comfortable if not extravagant.

It’s just too tempting, as you wipe smudged little faces and tackle yet another mountain of dirty dishes, to forget to thank God for those most precious of life’s blessings.  But today, if I could choose one day to live again, one poignant memory to forever hold up to the light, I’d rush to embrace those soft little bodies, begging for just one more goodnight kiss, one more silly song, one more question. 

Being a mother is, after all, the greatest adventure of all.

R.I.P. Betty Ford: Champion of [Some] Women's Rights

Former First Lady Betty Ford died this week of natural causes, at the age of 93.  One can offer many tributes for this outspoken activist who gave voice to important causes such as breast cancer prevention (she had a mastectomy in 1974) and alcohol and drug addiction (she struggled with alcoholism and was a catalyst in advancing addiction treatment through the Betty Ford Center).

She was a dancer and a divorcee.  She was a prominent force in the Women’s Movement in the 1970s, joining forces with ’70s feminists including Betty Friedan, Gloria Steinem, Bella Abzug and Eleanor Smeal.  And as wife of President Gerald Ford, she had a political platform which extended far beyond that enjoyed by any other female of the time.

History will remember Betty Ford as a devoted mother, a gentle woman who decried the use of physical punishment in the raising of children.  I remember the First Lady’s warmth and graciousness, evident in television interviews during and after the Ford presidency.  But juxtaposed against her tender love and compassion for her own children, a startling counterpoint, is her passionate support for abortion of other people’s children.

I’ve tried to understand how this kind and gentle woman could have so ignored the human rights of the unborn, and I can only conclude that for her (and for many who, for whatever reason, have not thought through the issue) there were two forces at play:

  1. She knew not what she was doing. Remember that Roe v. Wade was only made the law of the land in 1973; before that, abortion was illegal in all but a few states.  I recall that in those early years, the pro-life movement—stunned by the unexpected passage of massive pro-abortion legislation—was just gaining steam.  Pictures of aborted fetuses were not yet commonplace; I don’t think fetal pain studies had been published.  In fact, although some forward thinkers did understand and lobby against the taking of innocent human life, many of us just hadn’t heard the arguments and hadn’t formed our conscience on this newest societal issue.  I, as a young woman during those years, remember a female gynecologist asking me in a matter-of-fact sort of way, upon confirming my first pregnancy, “what I wanted to do.”  She meant, did I want to give birth or to abort?  Praise God Who, in His great mercy, spared me from choosing the latter.
  2. She saw injustice and sought to overcome it. While the pain of the fetus during, say, a dilation and curretage abortion was invisible to all but the abortionist himself, Ford could easily identify with the pain of women who, through no fault of their own, faced discrimination in the workplace and in society at large.  In the face of flagrant violations of women’s inherent rights and dignity, Betty supported the proposed Equal Rights Amendment and lobbied state legislatures to ratify the amendment.  She was unapologetically pro-abortion, believing that unwanted pregnancies ranked high among the causes of women’s marginalization in the world of business and civic affairs.  She didn’t see, and so didn’t consider, the tiny women who struggled as they were torn from their mothers’ wombs.

Betty Ford is gone, and in heaven she will doubtless meet many of the souls whose lives were extinguished because of social policies which she fostered.  If she didn’t understand that these were people back in 1970, she knows it now.

May God have mercy on her soul, and may He welcome her into the heavenly community where, with the angels and saints, she will forever praise the Father, Son and Holy Spirit.