Many recent comments have raised this question.
Please don’t use this thread as a chance to bash Jackson or Adamson. We’ve got enough of that going elsewhere, and frankly, I’m fairly pleased with both directors and I’m tired of focusing on the negatives.
But if both Middle-Earth and Narnia were coming to the big screen AGAIN… who would you pick to direct them? What directors have the right sensibilities to elevate these transcendant works of literature to transcendant works for the screen?
While we’re at it, if you have any creative ideas about re-making OTHER great films with the participation of alternate directors, what would you like to see?