Sin: Making Smart People Stupid Since the Garden of Eden

First academia denies that the most vunerable among us as persons, now it want’s to instead give the title to animals.

Hitler loved his dog too.

"Mrs Harris, there were many quotes in the article that were taken out of context ..."

Interviewed Rebecca Bratten Weiss on Connecting ..."
"I'm assuming they are speaking about the politics in the Vatican currently...i.e. Scandals, the St ..."

Interviewed Rebecca Bratten Weiss on Connecting ..."
"" It is clear the Vatican does not care about the Church’s traditional teachings and ..."

Interviewed Rebecca Bratten Weiss on Connecting ..."
"Well, I'm going to assume you've changed the wording a bit and flavored it with ..."

Interviewed Rebecca Bratten Weiss on Connecting ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • K. J.

    Sadly, this isn’t new. Princeton philosopher Peter Singer has been saying this for years. He even wrote an essay, titled “Heavy Petting,” defending bestiality. That’s the school that US News has tied for the #1 ranking. Can’t we do any better than that?

  • James

    It isn’t stupid. In fact, it’s a good deal less stupid (or at least more consistent) than the usual pro-choice view that it is absolutely wrong to kill a two-month-old (that is, post-birth) baby but not at all wrong to kill it five months before its birth and not very wrong to kill an adult nonhuman cetacean or great ape that is probably rather more self-aware than most newborn humans. If you want to define personhood in terms of ‘consciousness’, ‘self-awareness’, ‘intelligence’ or whatever, and you have a shred of intellectual honesty, then eventually you’re going to have to address this problem and decide either that it’s immoral to kill the higher animals or that it’s moral to kill newborn babies. Or both, like Peter Singer. This is not stupid: the reasoning is flawless. It’s just that the premises are wrong, both in the sense of ‘factually incorrect’ and also in the sense of ‘immoral’.