I have a crush on a boy in my Qur’an class

I thought since I haven’t written about Little Mosque on the Prairie for awhile, why not now? Last night’s episode dealt with crushes. Layla, Baber’s daughter, has a crush on a boy in her Qur’an class. She confides in Rayyan and Amaar on the condition that they not tell her father. Amaar wants to inform Baber whereas Rayyan thinks they should let it be and not say anything unless it gets serious. ( I wonder if him being a man and her being a woman had anything to do with their opinions?) Jokes are thrown around about the consequences of Baber finding out – he’d send Layla to Pakistan or force her to wear a burqa. However, Baber over hears Rayyan and Amaar talking about it but thinks that they have a crush on each other. And the antics follow.

The fact that LMOTP tackled the issue of Muslim teenage crushes, especially that of a teenage daughter of a conservative fundamentalist, is noteworthy. As I was watching, I could not help but think about the latest stories we’ve heard of Muslim teenage daughters being killed or punished severely by their fathers for not being traditional enough. Of course, on the show they could easily joke about the possible consequences that Layla could face if her father were to find out she had a crush on a boy. But what we have seen in the media are not things to joke about. However, they are also not the norm. By making light of the father-daughter dynamic the show did demonstrate father-teenage daughter tensions as similar to those that occur in non-Muslim households. Yes, there are disagreements; yes there are punishments for behaviours deemed inappropriate by the parents. But usually there are no beatings, no threats, no murder. Just like a Muslim household. LMOTP has been trying to show this Muslim father-daughter relationship as the “usual” father-daughter relationship, but with some specific Muslim issues (hijab, male friends, sinful crushes).

As many will have figured out by now, LMOTP portrays a certain group of Muslims who follow Islam in a certain way. Although many Muslims may agree with most of the message, the message is still a conservative one. With Amaar’s concern about Layla’s crush the show tells its viewers that this is something worth concern. I mean, if an imam sees it as telling-a-parent-worthy, then it’s serious. This may be a point of contention for many. What the big deal with a crush after all? Even Rayyan felt there was no need to tall Baber unless it became serious.

But why was it serious for Amaar? What is LMOTP trying to tell us about Muslims and crushes? The most obvious answer which comes to mind is that having crushes is wrong. Wrong because it’s a dangerous road. Crushes in and of themselves are fine. But it’s what they can lead to which must be monitored and prevented by parents. Now, I am not saying that this is bad or good. This is up to the reader/viewer to decide according to their values. However, the sinfulness of crushes certainly did seem to be portrayed in the show. It seems LMOTP continues to tell us how we really should be thinking. Again, you decide what you think of that.

  • Melinda

    Very interesting. “Does My Head Look Big in This?” also tackles the issue of crushes (also with the implication that they lead to bad things), but at least the character in it isn’t afraid to talk to her parents about it.I’m glad that LMOTP shows Muslims to be more “normal” than news stories do, but the show is a bit too conservative for my taste… the main issue with that being that conservativism is shown as the only “real” Islam.

  • ammena

    thanks for this sis… i miss the episodes because of my work hours.. so nice to see a little update and of course the 2 sides to the coin. alhamdulillah.

  • Sakura Kiss

    Good analysis, but now I’m wondering, since it was implied that crushes can lead to “other” things, what exactly are those “things?” I’m just curious.

  • Duniya

    Melinda:I too think the show is too conservative and that they do depict that conservative image as Islam. For instance, the holiday special showed that they wold not celebrate New Years because celebrating was wrong and New Years was not something to celebrate. So instead they had a small get together at Yaser and Sarah’s place. Not all Muslims believe that celebration is unIslamic but this show said it was. As I watched all I could think was “Great! Now people are going to think I’m a bad Muslim when I celebrate!” UGH!! Absolutely too conservative. I still watch it and always seem to find disagreeable elements. Sakura Kiss:They never explicitly say what those ‘things’ are but I think it can be assumed. Because the show as already established that dating is unIslamic. I’m assuming that dating is the forbidden thing crushes could lead to.

  • Safiya Outlines

    Salaam Alaikum,Duniya – You can’t expect a tv show to speak for all of us, we are far too diverse for that. You may find it too conservative, others not – so what’s the solution?Insha Allah, when more of our voices are featured in mainstream media, things will be better. Until then, nothing will be a perfect fit.

  • Anonymous

    on a different note, a wonderful conference is currently underway in Madras(chennai)INDIA with speakers like Yasir Qadhi, Bilal Philips,Abdur Rahim Green and others participating in it.You can follow the live streaming onhttp://www.peacevisionofislam.in/Great talks on Aqida, Dawah and contemporary issues facing the ummah.Believe me, the conference is very well organised and a pleasure to attend.

  • Duniya

    Safiya:True enough. Still won’t stop me from critiquing it though ;)

  • Pingback: Des Temps → Blog Archive → American-Muslim Identity: Advertising, Mass Media + New Media

  • sarah

    thanks for this great post. I was thinking about the fact that the show seemed to depict muslims in a very conservative light but I think the other thing to think about is that it is purposefully set in a small town and so a lot of the non-muslims are pretty conservative too. And of course the fact that whenever amaar’s parent’s get some screen-time you get the sense that it’s both their general big-city frivolity as well as their lack of religious observance that he’s running away from

  • amira

    is having a crush a sin?