Beauty and the Beastly Pundits: More on Miss USA

Rima Fakih has become an unlikely member of the Islamophobic grab-bag of images. Joining the images of oppressed burqa-wearers and angry men with beards, Miss USA’s victory has become a part of another far-fetched conspiracy. The best part is that we are actually seeing a ridiculous debate about the legitimacy of her victory, and whether or not it is evidence of a secret, home-grown Islamic uprising.

Miss USA Rima Fakih. Image via Brekken/AP.

In an article initially entitled “Is Miss USA a trailblazer or Hezbollah spy?” CNN reinforces every possible stereotype in the book while trying to further spark controversy. Fakih is presented as a Muslim woman on trial by conservative criticism because of her sexuality. The article also places East in a battle with West, when Fakih’s victory is not really representative of a “clash of civilizations.”

Furthermore, rather than using her win as an opportunity to show the diversity of beliefs within the Muslim community, CNN uses this as a chance to depict Fakih as a more “open-minded” Muslim woman (read: “good Muslim”), which is utilized to distance her from the faith.

The rhetoric of the Miss USA debate evokes an alarming amount of stereotypes, and it is very troubling how much blatant racism has been involved under the pretence of good old “straight talk”—here’s looking at you, FOX News! Media outlets are painting her win as more evidence that affirmative action is destroying American values. Images of Fakih as the cunning vixen stealing the crown from the doe-eyed blonde Miss Oklahoma made me think of Ursula in The Little Mermaid, dressed as a beautiful brunette, stealing the prince from the sweet and innocent Ariel.

[Read more...]

Kuwait’s “Arab Times” Apparently Amused by a Maid’s Rape

This was originally published at Migrant Rights.

On April 10th, Kuwait’s Arab Times reported about the rape and kidnapping of an unnamed Indonesian maid by a police officer. This report is an appalling example of the regional papers’ disregard to migrant and women’s rights.

Kuwaiti press in general (except for Ben Garcia, a staff reporter at the Kuwait Times) is quite insensitive in its reporting about human rights violations of migrant workers. For example, Kuwaiti papers very rarely report the names of migrants who commit suicide, printing a couple lines about another poor worker who took his or her last breath, sometime hinting at mental illness as the cause of suicide. Migrant workers are more likely to appear in Kuwaiti press in reports about theft and alcohol consumption than in reports that detail abuse and maltreatment that many workers endure on a daily basis in Kuwait.

This report, which calls kidnapping and rape as having “fun” with a maid, details in a bemused tone about police corruption, abuse of power and cover up.

Below is the report:

[Read more...]

Homeland Insecurities: Nel Hedayat and Afghanistan

The BBC documentary Women, Weddings, War and Me follows 21-year-old British Afghan Nel Hedayat (pictured below) as she returns to Afghanistan 15 years after she and her family left.

Nel Hedayat in Afghanistan. Image via the BBC website.

Nel Hedayat in Afghanistan. Image via the BBC website.

The accompanying article was my first exposure to Hedayat’s experience there, and it provides a different perspective than the documentary did. The article came across as another replay of the broken record of dual British Muslim identities and the experience of women in non-Western countries as unrelentingly tragic, while the women themselves are dismissed as possible agents in their own lives. My view of the documentary is a little more complicated than this, but I’m going to address the article first.

From the first sentence (“Growing up in north London, identity was never really a big issue.”), I was skeptical about the entire project. I may know little about Afghanistan, but I’ve lived in north London for almost twenty years. Identity is an issue and being different is not the norm.

[Read more...]