CLS v. Martinez: A Disappointing – But Limited – Decision

In lieu of the usual Morning Reports today, I am going to be collecting responses to the CLS v. Martinez case, for which the Supreme Court just issued its decision (you can download the decision at their website).  As regular readers of Cross and Culture and the Evangelical Portal at Patheos will remember, we interviewed Michael McConnell, the former federal judge (and potential Supreme Court nominee) who argued the case before the court.

The different sides will construe the issue at stake in this case differently.  If you ask the Hastings side, it has to do with a Christian group which is asking for special treatment: to be exempted from an “all comers” policy which requires all student groups to be open to all students and yet still receive student status and student funding.  If you ask the CLS side, the issue is whether the state and its organs can withhold certain benefits and subsidies (such as the right to be recognized as a student group, with the access that grants) to those groups which require their members to affirm the fundamental purposes of the group.  Can a state institution exclude a Christian student group because it requires its voting membership to be Christian?

McConnell said this:

“The essential theory underlying Hastings’ position is that allowing a group to meet on campus amounts to a benefit or a subsidy that the university is entitled to grant or withhold on the basis of its own approval or disapproval of the group’s practices. If that is so, if being able to participate on an equal basis with other groups in the common resources of civil life is a benefit or subsidy that the government controls in this way, then there is essentially no more separation between church and state. The government will be able to exercise a kind of power over religious organizations that it has never before exercised in America.”

In other words, if the state can withhold the common resources of our society from Christian groups that “discriminate” because they require their membership or leadership to be Christian, then the door is opened for state manipulation of the church on a massive scale.  Can groups form meaningful associations around shared beliefs, and can those groups be discriminated against by the state?  As McConnell explained:

“The case would be enormously important in a bad way if Hastings were to prevail. For CLS to prevail would simply be to shore up Constitutional protections that the court has been providing for the last thirty or forty years. My guess is that if CLS wins, all of the folks on the other side of the case will say, “Well, of course. This is a very small case.” Yet if Hastings wins, and especially if they win on the theory that the government can withhold “benefits” to any group it disapproves of, the world will be a very different place the day after.”

Well, the decision has been issued, and Hastings won – but, arguably, it is a very narrow win.  In a 5-4 ruling, with the liberals and Kennedy on one side, and Alito, Roberts, Scalia and Thomas on the other side, the court decided that the “all comers” policy is reasonable, given the purposes of the student groups and the totality of circumstances, and not an unlawful abridgement of First Amendment rights.

I will be posting responses here throughout the day, and weaving them together into an article later.  For now I want to note this first-blush response from David French, the Senior Counsel for the Alliance Defense Fund, which argued the case alongside the Christian Legal Society.  French writes:

“Interestingly, rather than resolving the free association issue, the Court seems to have very narrowly decided the case — dealing with an “all-comers policy” that is virtually unique to Hastings.  It appears that the Court has left open the core issue that has bedeviled student groups nationwide, the conflict between free association and nondiscrimination policies that prohibit, among other things, discrimination on the basis of religion and sexual orientation.

“This is pure first blush assessment; more to come as I read through the opinion.  Bottom line: a disappointing decision but one that does not come close to settling core constitutional issues on campus.  In fact, it doesn’t even decide this case since it’s remanded for further proceedings.

More to come, as I make sense of the ruling and gather responses from those involved in the case.  Stay tuned.

About Timothy Dalrymple

Timothy Dalrymple was raised in non-denominational evangelical congregations in California. The son and grandson of ministers, as a young boy he spent far too many hours each night staring at the ceiling and pondering the afterlife.
 
In all his work he seeks a better understanding of why people do, and do not, come to faith, and researches and teaches in religion and science, faith and reason, theology and philosophy, the origins of atheism, Christology, and the religious transformations of suffering

  • http://twitter.com/timdalrymple_/status/17261844503 Timothy Dalrymple

    On the new Supreme Court decision in CLS v. Martinez: A Disappointing – But Limited – Decision http://bit.ly/bAGHZs

  • http://twitter.com/timdalrymple_/status/17262430787 Timothy Dalrymple

    RT @patheos: CLS v. Martinez: A Disappointing – But Limited – Decision #patheos http://bit.ly/bAGHZs

  • Steve Skeete

    The opinion of the majority in CLS v. Martinez is limited and poorly reasoned. However the dissent is devastating.

    The majority, for reasons not clearly explained, chose to deal with the issue in an extremely limited manner. Still, as pointed out in the dissent, the Court has taken an unprecedented turn in ruling for viewpoint discrimination when it argued that Hastings policy of including “all comers” was constitutional.

    To understand the implications of this ruling for the nation one has only to imagine what would happen if outside of Hastings every religious group had to admit persons who disagreed with its major doctrinal positions or risk losing tax exempt status and/or federal funding.

    One can only hope, like the dissenting justices, that this is an “aberration” and that the court will speedily return to its senses.

  • http://www.thomasabo-sale.com/ thomas sabo

    It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!

  • http://www.all-good-batteries.com/ Digital Camera Battery

    It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!http://www.gpbattery.co.uk

  • vivi

    Thanks for the best blog.it was very useful for me.keep sharing such ideas in the future as well.this was actually what i was looking for,and i am glad to came here!pearl jewelry wholesale online; thanks for sharing the such information with us.subsequently,after spending many hours on the internet at last we are uncovered an individual that definitely does know what they are dicussing many thanks a great deal wonderful post.The freshwater pearl jewelry; thank

  • echo
  • http://www.oakleycheap.org Oakley Sunglasses Outlet

    I enjoyed reading your post and I like your take on the issue. Thanks.

    I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading.Nice blog,I will keep visiting this blog very often.

  • http://www.laptopsbatterysupplier.com laptop battery

    very good laptops batteryhttp://www.laptopsbatterysupplier.com/dell-laptop-battery-latitude-d600-c-3_1078.html

  • http://www.jeansuk.me.uk/Cheap-mens-jeans-for-sale/Discount-Dolce-Gabbana-mens-jeans-on-sale/ Dolce Gabbana jeans

    What your talking about Diesel Bootcut Jeansis the spin being given to the case by Michael McConnell…I will not accept that somehow liberty is being suppressed just g star rawbecause religious groups cannot get money from a university. That is a real distortion.”

  • http://www.mbtshoesonlinemall.com MBT sport shoes

    i am hobby visual artist, possibly you would like to show some of my photographs? i think it would be awesome and fit on your site discount MBT shoes on sale
    really admire your site structure! send me a mail please in case you want to colaborate

  • http://www.saleguccinewbags.com donghanjin

    It is also because the beginning of life Guccio Gucci Gucci brand makes the Gucci Shoulder Bags

  • http://www.canadagoosewholesale.org Canada Goose Jackets

    Very nice ,I love reading through your blog

  • http://www.cheapuggclassictallsale.com Ugg Winter Boots

    Nice one, there is actually some good points on this blog some of my readers may find this useful, I must send a link, many thanks.

  • http://3590921.com 3590921

    3590921 beers on the wall. sck was here

  • http://www.cheapsupracanada.com/ Supra Skytop
  • http://www.cheapmonclerss.org/ cheap moncler jackets

    I really appreciate your article, in fact I think you deserve a thumbs up.whyhpIIfBkAwovr

  • http://www.jeansuk.me.uk/Cheap-mens-jeans-for-sale/Discount-Dolce-Gabbana-mens-jeans-on-sale/ Dolce Gabbana jeans

    appreciate your article, in fact I think you deserve a thumbs up.whyhpIIfBkAwovr

  • http://www.2deals.net/ Digital Battery, Charger,DC Power Jack

    This article makes me improve my digital culture, thank you for sharing.

  • http://www.shoes-mylife.com Max Shoes

    I very like you share things,thank you to take the time share.Also hope that the next time can still see your share!!!

  • http://www.mbtskovip.com MBT Amali

    The preferred material for motorcyclists is leather. That’s because leather is flexible and durable enough to help protect you from serious injuries.

    dame MBT sko herre MBT Sko mbt sko
    MBT M.Walk

  • Navie
  • http://www.timberlandbootssaleuk.org/ Timberland Shoes

    hey i really like reading this article! It make feel so real! And your glog is nice, and amaze me in some weird way, but it really make me feel good,though! You should work on your theme, it is not so good !
    Timberland Shoes
    http://www.timberlandbootssaleuk.org/
    Timberland Boots Sale
    Timberland UK boots

  • http://www.onitsukatigermexico66.us/onitsuka-tiger-tokidoki-c-6.html onitsuka tiger tokidoki

    This would fit the pattern of most Japanese booms, onitsuka tiger dx in which consumers adopt products with unprecedented speed and then abandon them just as quickly in order to move on to something else.

  • http://www.newyorknds.com r4 card

    your artical give me much more useful information. thanks for your help. i’ll suggest my friends to read your artical.Nice one, there is actually some good points ony readers may find this useful, I must send a link, many thanks.Took me awhile to read all the comments, but I really love the article. It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!

  • http://www.greenfieldboots.com/ UGG Greenfield

    It’s really a nice and helpful piece of information. I’m glad that you info with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

  • http://www.cheap4sneakers.com cheap sneakers

    60% OFF http://www.cheap4sneakers.com cheap sneakers and jordans sneakers and cheap jordans shoes and jordans on sale ,wholesale jordans and wholesale shox and cheap shox.

  • http://www.dressiton.com cheap wedding dresses

    Great and useful designs you have posted .

  • http://www.suprafootwear.us supra shoes

    wholesale jordans and wholesale shox and cheap shox.

  • http://www.cleaninghouselondon.co.uk/carpet-cleaning-services-london Carpet Cleaning London

    Really amazing article! I really like it because it is one hell of good piece! I will be happy to find more from your published papers in the near future on the same topic. I did search for two hours and I did not found what I was searching for.An article that is so perfectly and fully written like yours is.

  • http://www.officialsofts.com/ Microsoft Office

    I will keep your new article. I really enjoyed reading this post, thanks for sharing.

  • http://thomassabo.gabrielslife.org/ thomas sabo

    Are you an animal lover? thomas sabo offers a variety of animal design charms. You can go for rare and exotic to cute and cuddly. All animal charms are sterling silver that is polished for beautiful shine.thomas sabo charm bracelet There is a charm that represents the birthstone for every month. They are beautiful and will dazzle even the most unobservant eye. Along with this, why not add the zodiac sign.thomas sabo jewellery charm bracelet created in a Cameo style. Each one is carved to represent the individual personalities of every sign.

  • http://www.mbtshoes-mbtscarpe.com mbt scarpe

    NFL, the nationwide Football League, could be the most effective level of certified American football within of your United States. Cheap NFL Jerseys The cozy pastime movements also allows make NFL Jerseys a complete whole great offer an amazing offer more collectively using a complete whole great offer an amazing offer more popular.

  • http://www.uggcom.org cheap ugg boots

    You can definitely see your expertise in the paintings you write. The arena hopes for even more passionate writers such as you who aren’t afraid to mention how they believe. At all times go after your heart.

  • http://www.macmakeupwholesalestore.com mac makeup wholesale

    Thanks so much for giving everyone an exceptionally brilliant chance to read articles and blog posts from this web site.

  • http://www.topfakeoakleysunglasses.com fake oakley sunglasses

    Hello, this is a very nice blog. Although i don’t understand everything of what your saying, i still enjoyed reading it. Hopefully you will write something more on this subject in the future?

  • http://www.monclerjacketswholesaler.com/ moncler jackets

    Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So nice to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this website is something that is needed on the web, someone with a little originality. useful job for bringing something new to the internet!

  • http://www.uggscheapsale.co.uk uggscheapsale

    Australians own their UGG trademark “#dongzdsk”because American lost lawsuit when they tried to register UGG in Australia owing to the UGG stems from Australia. The name of UUG was evolved from “ugly boots” since the Australians thought it ugly that time. Beijing at the same time.
    cheap uggs
    UGG Bailey Button Triplet Boots

  • http://www.uggscheapsale.co.uk ugg boots

    UGG 2011 Spring and Summer collection “#dongzdsk”once you see them. You can find colorful UGG wedge sandals, strappy sandals decorated with studs and buckles. Of course, sports shoes and flip flops are indispensible. Believer it or not, a pair of UGG spring and summer will bring you enormous surprises and happiness.
    cheap ugg boots
    cheap ugg boots uk

  • http://aa759753.com a759753

    I’ve said that least 759753 times. The problem this like that is they are just too compilcated for the average bird, if you know what I mean