The Sermon on the Plount (Problems with Inerrancy)

Via The New Testament Stumblr I discovered Jeremiah Bailey’s blog, which had the delightful cartoon below illustrating one of the many problems with inerrancy: the extreme lengths to which it often requires one to go in order to harmonize discrepancies.

"Several years ago I attended an atheist meeting to determine why people reject God. Eventually ..."

The Cruelty of Young-Earth Creationism
"Rev. Kent A. Meyer, Ph.D said: "Just how do they justify lying in the name ..."

The Cruelty of Young-Earth Creationism
"Thanks for this essay and book list! Through high school and college, I constantly dealt ..."

The Cruelty of Young-Earth Creationism
"I think religious studies is one of the premier disciplines for research-based debate. For instance, ..."

Tying Burdens on Students’ Backs and ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • I had to stare at it for a minute. I guess it’s been too long since I really dug into Bib Studies stuff.

  • I had to stare at it for a minute. I guess it’s been too long since I really dug into Bib Studies stuff.

  • patrick.sele

    I don’t see why Jesus shouldn’t have delivered this sermon more than once.

  • patrick.sele

    I don’t see why Jesus shouldn’t have delivered this sermon more than once.

  • @google-722a9e40d0baa1584687baf097fdfcdb:disqus The issue is not whether Jesus taught the same thing more than once. The issue is that these “sermons” and in particuar Matthew’s “Sermon on the Mount” can be seen to represent a weaving together and editing by the Gospel author of sayings of Jesus. There is agreement of wording and of order to an extent that we do not find in the absence of either use of written sources or use of written aids to memorization. And Matthew and Luke agree even on a word that doesn’t seem to have existed in Greek prior to then.

  • @google-722a9e40d0baa1584687baf097fdfcdb:disqus The issue is not whether Jesus taught the same thing more than once. The issue is that these “sermons” and in particuar Matthew’s “Sermon on the Mount” can be seen to represent a weaving together and editing by the Gospel author of sayings of Jesus. There is agreement of wording and of order to an extent that we do not find in the absence of either use of written sources or use of written aids to memorization. And Matthew and Luke agree even on a word that doesn’t seem to have existed in Greek prior to then.

  • Patrick has hit on the second problem with inerrancy to be cartoonized sometime soon.

  • Jeremiah

    Patrick has hit on the second problem with inerrancy to be cartoonized sometime soon.