Tolkien Have Mercy

Dănuţ Mănăstireanu drew my attention to the video above. It is striking how its creator felt that this music – Kyrie Eleison – fit well in conjunction with scenes from the Lord of the Rings. What do you make of the juxtaposition?

"It's only hyperbole if he doesn't take his extravagant claims literally, lol."

What Happens When You Review Richard ..."
"Oh, epistemic hyperbole is basically the English language as far as Carrier's concerned."

What Happens When You Review Richard ..."
"Carrier also imports traditional deductive reasoning language into his arguments, suggesting "certainty" of his arguments, ..."

What Happens When You Review Richard ..."
"The thing I've appreciated about Carrier's attempts to use a (modified) form of Bayes' theorem ..."

What Happens When You Review Richard ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Phil Ledgerwood

    It seems to me that they just picked images they thought illustrated the words of the song without actual reference to what the scenes meant in the movies/books. It’s sort of like prooftexting but with pictures. My guess is that they felt the sort of Celtic vibe of their music and the scenes fit together.

    I would like to see the same thing done with “Kyrie” by Mister Mister before I make a final call.

  • John MacDonald

    There’s a good dialogue comparing The Lord of the Rings and Star Wars from the movie Clerks 2 on You Tube, but I can’t provide a link to it because there is too much swearing. lol If you’re of age, go to You Tube and check it out!

  • http://bilbos1.blogspot.com/ Bilbo

    I love the books, hate the movies, like the music, though I don’t think Tolkien (though thoroughly Catholic) would have approved trying to give LOTR an overtly Christian theme.

  • Brandon Roberts

    cool