LINK: Philip Kitcher on Militant Modern Atheism

From the abstract:

Militant modern atheism, whose most eloquent champion is Richard Dawkins, provides an effective and necessary critique of fundamentalist forms of religion and their role in political life, both within states and across national boundaries. Because it is also presented as a more general attack on religion (tout court), it has provoked a severe reaction from scholars who regard its conception of religion as shallow and narrow. My aim is to examine this debate, identifying insights and oversights on both sides.

Two distinct conceptions of religion are in play. For Dawkins and his allies (most notably Dan Dennett) religions are grounded in doctrines, propositions about supernatural entities, events and processes which the devout believe. Their beliefs prompt them to actions, which they support or rationalize by reference to the doctrines. Dawkins and Dennett view the acceptance of the doctrines as resting on cognitive misfiring — these are delusions to be outgrown or spells to be broken.

By contrast, the religious scholars who criticize the militant atheists often view religion as centered in social practices that inform and enrich human lives. To the extent that there are doctrines that atheists might subject to epistemic evaluation, these are to be viewed as pieces of scaffolding, that are, in principle, dispensable.

I argue that militant modern atheism is incomplete (and likely counter-productive) so long as it fails to attend systematically to the roles religion fulfills in human lives. Yet it is important to achieve public clarity about the literal falsehood of the doctrines on which fundamentalists rely. The challenge is to develop a well-articulated and convincing version of secular humanism. Meeting that challenge is, I claim, one of the central problems of philosophy today.

Unfortunately, online access to this paper is not free (see here for options), but I did find several discussions of Kitcher’s paper on the web:

http://metamagician3000.blogspot.com/2010/10/kitcher-and-dennett-on-new-atheism.html
http://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2010/10/07/kitcher-versus-dennett-is-new-atheism-counterproductive-2
http://metamagician3000.blogspot.com/2010/10/currently-reading-philip-kitchers.html
http://metamagician3000.blogspot.com/2010/10/currently-reading-philip-kitchers_11.html
http://metamagician3000.blogspot.com/2010/10/curently-reading-philip-kitchers.html
http://metamagician3000.blogspot.com/2010/10/currently-reading-philip-kitchers_13.html
http://metamagician3000.blogspot.com/2010/10/currently-reading-philip-kitchers_15.html
http://metamagician3000.blogspot.com/2010/10/currently-reading-philip-kitchers_21.html

About Jeffery Jay Lowder

Jeffery Jay Lowder is President Emeritus of Internet Infidels, Inc., which he co-founded in 1995. He is also co-editor of the book, The Empty Tomb: Jesus Beyond the Grave.


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X