One Man’s Modus Ponens…Part 2

Here is another argument for God, based on answered prayers:

1. If God exists, then it is very likely that prayers to God for healing from injury or disease would usually be immediately followed by instantaneous and complete healing, except when the injury or disease was the result of self-destructive, foolish, or morally wrong actions on the part of the person who is suffering from the injury or disease.

2. If it is NOT the case that God exists, then it is very unlikely that prayers to God for healing from injury or disease would usually be immediately followed by instantaneous and complete healing, except when the injury or disease was the result of self-destructive, foolish, or morally wrong actions on the part of the person who is suffering from the injury or disease.

3. Prayers to God for healing from injury or disease are usually immediately followed by instantaneous and complete healing, except when the injury or disease was the result of self-destructive, foolish, or morally wrong actions on the part of the person who is suffering from the injury or disease.

Therefore:

4. Other things being equal, it is probable that God exists.

This argument can be reformulated by asserting the negation of premise (3), thus turning the tables and making an argument against the existence of God:

1. If God exists, then it is very likely that prayers to God for healing from injury or disease would usually be immediately followed by instantaneous and complete healing, except when the injury or disease was the result of self-destructive, foolish, or morally wrong actions on the part of the person who is suffering from the injury or disease.

2. If it is NOT the case that God exists, then it is very unlikely that prayers to God for healing from injury or disease would usually be immediately followed by instantaneous and complete healing, except when the injury or disease was the result of self-destructive, foolish, or morally wrong actions on the part of the person who is suffering from the injury or disease.

5. It is NOT the case that prayers to God for healing from injury or disease are usually immediately followed by instantaneous and complete healing, except when the injury or disease was the result of self-destructive, foolish, or morally wrong actions on the part of the person who is suffering from the injury or disease.

Therefore:

6. Other things being equal, it is probable that God does NOT exist.

"Their whole religion is based on the premise that disembodied minds are not only possible ..."

Kreeft’s Case for God – Part ..."
"I was just at a philosophy conference where some people were excited about how Philoponus' ..."

Kreeft’s Case for God – Part ..."
"Matt said:Peoples conceptions of what they are differ widely, with belief in the external world, ..."

Kreeft’s Case for God – Part ..."
"Peoples conceptions of what they are differ widely ... with other minds, some are dualists, ..."

Kreeft’s Case for God – Part ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment