Worst Atheist Debate Performances (revised 22-May-15)

In the past, I posted a list of the “Worst Atheist Debaters.” I now think that title was a mistake, since it’s possible that a single debate performance may not be representative of a person’s overall skill in debate. So I am republishing that list now as a list of the “Worst Atheist Debate Performances.”

Like my list of “Best Atheist Debaters,” I don’t know of any way to be fully objective about this sort of thing. Also, like the other list, I fully recognize that others may disagree. Nevertheless, for what it’s worth, here is my list of worst atheist debate performances, organized by topic.

Topic: God’s Existence

Topic: Morality Without God
  • Craig-Kurtz Debate (for an example, see here)
  • Craig-Taylor Debate

Topic: Resurrection of Jesus

  • Habermas-Flew Debate
  • Wood-Loftus Debate (2015)
Note: as with the other list, nothing should be read into the fact that someone’s name does not appear on this list. I haven’t listened to all atheist debate performances; additionally, I am undecided about some of the ones I have listened to.
""BUT no where in his argument does he say anything about the nature or characteristics ..."

Feser’s Case for God – Part ..."
"Of the first three comments on this post, all three object to the introduction of ..."

Kreeft’s Case for God – Part ..."
"As a Canadian not interested in American voting, I cannot speak on whatever goes on ..."

Trump, Evangelicals, and the Single-Issue Voter
"It would appear that such "natural" reasoning is already at play in our moral intuitions. ..."

Trump, Evangelicals, and the Single-Issue Voter

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment