Stupid Apologetics Tricks

Here are some stupid apologetics tricks I’ve come across lately in things I’ve been reading. Feel free to add your own in the combox. If I like it enough, I may just add yours to the list!

Stupid Apologetics Trick #1:

(1) Really crappy debaters used stupid arguments and objections against H.
(2) Therefore, H is true.

Stupid Apologetics Trick #2:

(1) H is true.
(2) Therefore, H is true.

Stupid Apologetics Trick #3:

Step 1. Literally ignore all of the evidence for X .
Step 2. Say there is no evidence for X.

Stupid Apologetics Trick #4:

(1)  H1 sucks as an explanation for X.
(2) Therefore, H2 is true.

Stupid Apologetics Trick #5:

(1) My opponent believes H1.
(2) Here are a bunch of objections to H2.
(3) Therefore, H3 is true.

Stupid Apologetics Trick #6:

(1) E1 is evidence for H1 and against H2.
(2) E2 is evidence for H1 and against H2.
(3) …
(n) En is evidence for H1 and against H2.
(n+1) Therefore, H1 is more probable than H2.

Stupid Apologetics Trick #7:

(1) If X and Y, then H1 is false.
(2) Authority A thinks that H1 is true and X is true.
(3) Authority B thinks that H1 is true and Y is true.
(4) Therefore, H1 is false.

Update (16 May 2014): Edited the conclusion of #1 and added #7.

 

"Fesers book "Scholastic Metaphysics" was written for people in the analytical tradition. Perhaps you can ..."

Feser’s Case for God – Part ..."
"thanks for pitting this up This number is good or calling the house but if ..."

Act now to protect Net Neutrality
"Is that a useful distinction? Certainly the cause of the universe was something exotic and ..."

Taking Atheism Ignorantly
"FWIW, Aquinas himself does not reject the position of Avicenna and Al Gazali that there ..."

Taking Atheism Ignorantly

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment