Atheist Scholar Phil Zuckerman: OK to Criticize Christianity, but Not Islam

Atheist Scholar Phil Zuckerman: OK to Criticize Christianity, but Not Islam January 12, 2016

You should read both the article and the comments.

LINK

I could be wrong, but my hunch is that Zuckerman is probably right. Also, I don’t know this for a fact either, but I suspect that the same fear which stifles atheist criticism of Islam also stifles Christian criticism of Islam. Yes, there are atheist and Christian critics of Islam, but it seems very easy to believe that there are less critics than there would have been if Islam did not have the kind of reputation it does.

Speaking only for myself, I’ve written almost nothing about Islam. I know very little about it, don’t come from a Muslim background, and don’t live in a Muslim country. But supposing I were an ex-Muslim living in the United States, I would probably have to think twice before openly criticizing it.

What do you think?

(H/T: Joe)

"Much is communicated by what one leaves open to interpretation and what one precludes from ..."

A Case for Atheism: Skepticism about ..."
"Yeah, but this goes both ways. I've heard that Scandinavians are less happy than studies ..."

Skepticism about Religion – Part 2: ..."
"Thank you for writing this article on this extensive list of research on the relationship ..."

Skepticism about Religion – Part 2: ..."
"I suspect a 'reason' rather different from George Bernard Shaw's and David Hume's could inform ..."

A Case for Atheism: Skepticism about ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment