Plantinga on the Alleged “Irrationality” of Atheism

 I want to comment on Gary Gutting's recent interview of Alvin Plantinga in the New York Times. Unless otherwise indicated, the quotations are quotations of Plantinga. Still, that’s not nearly sufficient for atheism. In the British newspaper The Independent, the scientist Richard Dawkins was recently asked the following question: “If you died and arrived at the gates of heaven, what would you say to God to justify your lifelong atheism?” His response: “I’d quote Bertrand Russell: ‘Not e … [Read more...]

Craig-Carroll Debate

I missed the opening statements, but watched the rest of the debate live. Based on what I saw, Carroll did as well in his debate with Craig as Shelley Kagan did in his. Off the top of my head, this is the best debate performance I have ever seen by an atheist scientist. … [Read more...]

Breaking News: WLC Disses Aquinas

During the Q&A period of tonight's Craig-Carroll debate on God and cosmology, WLC said this (or something very close to it): "Aquinas' metaphysical principles are just dubious."Shhhhh... Don't tell Ed Feser. … [Read more...]

Theism, Naturalism, and the Total Evidence: Torley’s Reply to Me

About a year ago, I commented on the exchange between John Loftus and Vincent Torley. Torley has just posted his reply at Uncommon Descent. Check it out!LINKI hope to write a reply eventually, but it may be a couple of months before I am able to do so. … [Read more...]

Angra Mainyu Responds to WLC and Murray on Animal Pain

His response is spread over three posts. Here are the links.IntroductionPart 1Part 2 … [Read more...]

Feser Insults Readers of www.infidels.org

Here's the insult. And one’s more gullible followers—people like the www.infidels.org faithful who have been buying up The God Delusion by the bushel basket—will be thrilled to have some new piece of smart-assery to fling at their religious friends in lieu of a serious argument. LINKSpeaking of "smart-assery," Pot, meet kettle.I'm not sure why Feser thinks that the readers of www.infidels.org or this blog (secularoutpost.infidels.org) blindly agree with whatever the New Atheists have wr … [Read more...]

Do Christian Apologists Spend Too Much Time Focusing on their Weaker Opponents?

Refuting the "New Atheists" is all the rage among Christian apologists these days. Among professional philosophers of religion, however, it's well-known that the new atheists are not the best representatives for atheism. So why do Christian apologists continue to harp on the new atheists and ignore what atheist professional philosophers of religion have to say? For example, you'd think, after the 1,000th refutation of Richard Dawkins, that they would move onto something else.  You'd be wrong. … [Read more...]

Apologist Bingo!

Hemant Mehta blogs about this clever, funny way to combat an apologist:LINKETA: I love one of the comments in the combox at that site: I'm giggling at the thought of an audience member jumping up in the middle of the talk and shouting "Bingo!" … [Read more...]


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X