In her new book, Teach Us To Want, Jen Pollock Michel guides us on a journey of understanding who we are when we want, and reintroduces us to a God who gives us the desires of our hearts. Pollock Michel is a regular contributor for Christianity Today’s Her.meneutics and writes for Today in the Word, published by The Moody Bible Institute. Here, she delves into the desires of our hearts.
Why is it important to admit desire?
We need more than spiritual practices that shape our cognition, and more will be required of us than to simply “think rightly.” If we only deal with our thinking, rather than our wanting, we may end up in a frustrated state of spiritual impasse. We could fail to really understand ourselves. We could be prevented from identifying the obstacles that pose the greatest threat to our spiritual lives. And, we may remain ignorant of the passions meant to point us toward our most meaningful participation in God’s mission.
When we begin to examine desire, we make real movement out of our own darkness:
- We understand our persistence in patterns of chronic sin.
I nurture sin in my life because, in some real way, I think it does me a greater good than obedience will.
- We surface attitudes of resistance to God and his work in us.
I am divided between wanting God’s will and wanting my way.
- We identify our disappointments with God—and our failure to trust him.
I fail to surrender myself fully to God because I don’t know if his purposes are good.
- We behold our heart’s allegiance to lesser gods.
I have pet idols that I rely upon for my wholeness.
- We confront our fears and unwillingness to risk.
I refuse to want because I’m afraid of the responsibilities of that wanting.
What can the Lord’s Prayer teach us about desire?
The Lord’s Prayer is like the confluence of two rivers: human longing and divine desire. Praying the Lord’s Prayer allows us to want for both holy and human things, and it is the space where we can be most fully ourselves and yet most fully surrendered to God.
Many scholars recognize this as an inherent architecture of the Lord’s Prayer. First we have three “thee” petitions: God, your name be made holy, your kingdom come, your will be done. These are of course primary to the call to follow Christ, and becoming God’s people means making these our most fundamental desires. But the prayer doesn’t end there. We arrive at three “we” petitions: give us our bread, forgive us as we forgive, lead us not into temptation. The Lord’s Prayer doesn’t deliver us into a higher, holier realm where desires cease to matter. Rather, it offers a sacramental lens for living in the everyday and provides a framework for seeing our desires rightfully ordered.
The Lord’s Prayer is what I would call a holy lexicon of desire: it gives us language for reconciling what is earthly of our lives (and our desires) with what is ultimately eternal.
How might our desires draw us closer to God?
Desire may be the very catalyst we need to move us beyond our spiritual sluggishness. Without desire pulsing through our veins, we are left with apathy, indifference, resignation and numb obligations. Very often, our spiritual practices feel more perfunctory than authentic and real. As we attend to our desires—seeing, confessing, trusting—we can move into God’s greater light:
- We acknowledge our sinfulness and receive more gratefully the grace of Christ.
I do and want wrong—and still, I am fully wanted by God.
- We discover new freedoms in Christ—even the freedom to want, however imperfectly.
I want wrongly, but God, in Christ, is committed to my transformation.
- We excavate our unique gifts and passions.
My desires can illuminate my gifts: in doing what I love, I can feel most alive.
- We clarify our callings and move into God’s mission.
How I uniquely see the world’s brokenness and want for its wholeness is a signpost for my calling.
- We recover greater courage to pray boldly and specifically.
- We mature in our understanding of God’s purposes and priorities.
My heart’s desires align with the character and content of faith as described and modeled in the Scriptures.
- We learn to abide seasons of waiting and disappointment.
I learn to want what God gives when he gives it.
Admitting desire can put us on a path of greater congruence with God’s will. We become people who, like Jesus, “delight to do your will, O my God; your law is within my heart,” (Ps 40:8, cf. Heb 10:7).
How do we respond faithfully when we feel that a desire of our heart has been denied?
When God denies a good desire of our heart, we can’t help but be pained and perplexed, and lament is a perfectly appropriate response. We inhabit an in-between land.
Though Christ has died, is risen and is seated at the right hand of the Father, he has not yet returned to claim eternal, earthly reign. The world is not yet fully redeemed, death is not yet fully conquered, and tears are not yet fully dried. Our longings for good cannot be fully satisfied here and now.
However, we can live faithfully with our disappointed desires by anticipating with hope the good world that is yet to come. Hope does not demand we numb our disappointments.
Rather, hope invites us to confide in God our aches and continue imploring his goodness.
Nevertheless, we don’t give up on good desires unless God seems clearly to have said to us that this is necessary (cf. 2 Cor 12). The bulk of Scriptural witness seems to call us to persistence in prayer (and holy desire), rather than resignation.
What is the relationship between desire, obedience and holiness?
Holiness is consecrated conformity to God. A man or woman who is being made holy is being formed into wholehearted love for God and love for neighbor. With heart, soul, mind and strength, holy people are committed, in word and deed, thought and intention, to the glory of God and the good of the world.
Obedience is an act of our will: we move into holiness by obediently choosing conformity with God. But we can’t will much that we don’t desire. Certainly, we can sustain obedience, for a time, by duty and obligation. And often that is what we must do to begin in obedience.
We do what we must, whether we want to or not. But desire, as it represents something more profound than behavior, is essential to obedience that is truly willing. When we obey because we want to, our obedience promises to be stronger, more lasting, more resilient. We are best off praying for a willing obedience. This produces genuine holiness, not just superficial conformity to God’s law.
Why is it essential to be part of a Christian community as we negotiate our desires?
It is essential to be part of a Christian community because we alone cannot see ourselves.
Spiritual myopia prevents each of us from recognizing ourselves. So we must involve others in the process of seeking answers to the question, “What do I want?” We invite them to mirror our reflections and to reflect our desires back to us. Additionally, the Lord’s Prayer calls us to the regular practice of confession, which, elsewhere in the Bible, seems to be something we do not only in God’s hearing but in the company of others (cf. Jas 5:16).
Furthermore, we need others to believe for us when we doubt, to hope for us when we despair, to fight for us when we prefer surrender. Because our desires would often carry us far from Christ, because it is easiest to prefer our comfort and convenience over the cross, only in Christian community are we sustained for wanting as Jesus did, “who for the joy that was set before him endured the cross, despising the shame, and is seated at the right hand of the throne of God,” (Heb 12:2).
The Scriptures bear witness to the togetherness we need for walking faithfully with God.