Tebow on ABC This Week & Focus on Family Msg

After watching George Stephanopoulos do a less-than-stellar job of reining in his disdain during the recent ABC GOP debate (although at this point, I’m not exactly offended by hearing the contenders referred to as “characters”) it doesn’t surprise me at all to read that his Sunday morning show, This Morning, couldn’t resist taking some “good-natured” potshots at their Evangelical viewers by digging on the Bronco’s loss on Saturday. Writes Josh Feldman at Mediaite:

Have we not reached a place free of this yet? For some reason, George Stephanopoulos decided to talk about the notoriously Christian NFL player Tim Tebow on This Week today. He asked George Will how Tebow has become such a polarizing figure in not just sports, but somehow in politics as well. Will called Tebow “an exemplary gentleman” and said he was undeserving of the attacks against him.

Cokie Roberts jumped in, and first joked that God is probably not a big fan of the Denver Broncos, then launched into a strange story about Tebow’s team.

“His team is the Saints, and the archbishop said when the Saints were named the Saints, Archbishop Hannan was asked if that was disrespectful, and he said, ‘No, just remember that most saints are martyrs.’”

Uh…yeah, Cokie…you’re very, very smart, right? Just a tad incoherent. It was downhill from there. You know it was bad when Mediaite judges Paul Krugman’s silence on the matter to be the best move of the program. You can watch the video, there

Not being a big football fan (I do know the New York Giants won tonight…) the Tebow story was more interesting to me as a cultural moment than as a matter of sports or a religious thing. We all knew that if the Broncos continued to win, some Christians, particularly conservative Christians, would go into a really extreme place, assigning all sorts of political and divine meaning to Tebow’s victories, while the otherwise-inclined — some of whom were beginning to exhibit signs of Tebow Derangement Syndrome — were just waiting for a Denver defeat, so they could sneer.

There is a subtle irony to that, of course — one I’m seeing play out in social media and which I presume to be true elsewhere, including among the pundit-class: the very people who made fun of Evangelicals for finding divine validation in Tebow’s wins have no problem assigning divine disapproval to his defeat. All in “good-natured” fun that’s really a most childish spite.

Tim Tebow, by the way, addressed his team’s loss with candor, grace and maturity. But he’s just a big dumb Christian jock, so…you know…

But honestly, the so-brights of the Sunday morning talk-shows (brilliantly dubbed “the Sabbath Gasbags” by Calvin Trillin) are held up to us as the keenest minds in op-edland, and this is all they are? A bunch of perpetual adolescents sitting around sharing their brunch-with-mimosa bon mots with us? Who needs it? When are we going to see some fresh faces and fresh voices on those shows, anyway? These folks seem insulated, isolated and far-too-comfortable pronouncing their pearls to the rest of us, don’t they? I can think of any number of internet folk — columnists, bloggers, podcasters from all over the spectrum — who could manage to be livelier and more interesting than this.

What do you think?

UPDATE
Deacon Greg mentions the Focus on the Family’s pitch for Jesus during the Bronco’s game:

YouTube Preview Image

Greg quotes the WaPo’s Melinda Henneberger who wrote of it in the (terribly named) “She the People” column (hello, 1972):

. . .some of my friends on social media were appalled, saying that if they wanted “that garbage” they knew where to look, thanks.

My own, initially positive, reaction was followed by queasiness of a different sort. Were we Christians really hawking Jesus alongside Cialis now? (If you have an epiphany lasting more than four hours…) Not, as anyone who’s ever visited a holy site can tell you, that the commoditizing of faith is anything new. And in following Jesus’s directive that we spread the Word, televised pitches are nowhere near the most extreme measures we have tried.

On Twitter, I asked whether those who were offended by the ad would have minded as much if they hadn’t known that the conservative Christian group Focus on the Family had sponsored it.

“If I were Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, agnostic or atheist, yes,’’ tweeted back my ‘She the People’ colleague (and Tim Tebow fan) Sandra Fish. “So I am.”

Others said it wasn’t the cute kiddies they minded, but the unstated, not-cute Focus on the Family opposition to gay marriage.

When the commercial aired, I looked up from my book and snarled at it, and my husband — who loves kids and saw nothing but adorable children with an upbeat, positive message — wondered what could possibly have unleashed my inner curmudgeon. “It’s so cute!” he said.

But my husband knows that I am allergic to the appeals of cute children in most commercials. During one of the GOP debates (was it the Bloomberg one?) every debate break introduced another commercial of children lecturing the nation on civil rights and it annoyed me to no end. As the evening wore on I was raising my voice to the television: “go to bed!” I would sharply commend these hectoring little pills.

I don’t want children selling me stuff — not iPhones, not brokerage houses, and certainly not political messages. I hated the “daisy bomb” ad; I hated the “Mithter, can I have another glath of arthenic?” commercial; I hated the “we’re gonna have happiness/we’re gonna have freedom/Obama’s gonna do it” video, as I hate all videos and commercials wherein adults exploit children–using them as protective shields, so to speak–in order to help their in-your-face message go down easier; I don’t want them wagging their little fingers at me while discussing the Bill of Rights. And while I concede that there are much worse commercials using children, I am not looking for a kid-cuteness ad campaign to promote my Lord Jesus Christ.

That’s grown-up work, anyway. Jesus said “let the little children come to me,” he didn’t send them out into the streets preaching, which is frankly dangerous work.

Only one child was ever meant to lead us. We just finished celebrating His birth. Let the rest of them be kids and stop using them to sell me goods or ideas. I never buy it.

About Elizabeth Scalia
  • Stateless Infidel

    “A bunch of perpetual adolescents sitting around sharing their brunch-with-mimosa bon mots with us? … These folks seem insulated, isolated and far-too-comfortable pronouncing their pearls to the rest of us, don’t they? … I can think of any number of internet folk who could manage to be livelier and more interesting than this.”
    Amen Anchoress! Well said too. After many years of watching and yearning for their Received Wisdom, I cannot bear to watch them anymore – at all. Nor can I bear the face or voice of President Pol Pot unless it is on the New Media.
    BTW You are very beautiful, would you marry a very conservative lapsed Catholic?

  • Carol S.

    Amen Sister! You, Jim Hoft, Glenn, Helen , Ace , Ed morrissey and allahpundit; now that would be worth watching! Otherwise, I am keeping the Lord’s day holy.

  • Gail Finke

    I didn’t mind the commercial, although it wasn’t really my taste. Cute and Christ don’t really go together for me! I can’t stand those “He came as a baby” billboards, but so what? They are aimed at someone other than me, someone they really speak to, and IMHO they are much more off-putting than this commercial. It is not doctrinally wrong and it was well-filmed and well-produced, so I have no problem with it.

  • Bro AJK

    Dear Elizabeth,

    Thanks for the link to Tim Tebow’s post-game interview. Mr. Tebow exemplified that aspect of Job: “The Lord giveth and the Lord taketh away; blessed be the Lord,” by praising Jesus Christ.

  • Ann

    You’re so cranky.

  • Ann

    Elizabeth,
    What are your feelings about the children of Fatima?

    [I don't know them well, but it seems to me they were told by Mary to go to authorities with a message (just like Bernadette of Lourdes) not peddled as preachers before the masses by their parents and their church. Perhaps two of them died young in order to be spared that, and Lucia, of course, became cloistered. I would like to go to Lourdes, one day, but I don't spend a lot of time thinking about apparitions. And, as the church herself teaches, I needn't. -admin]

  • http://www.robinhardy.com robin

    Gosh darn, look what I miss not watching TV at all anymore ever.

  • Teresa

    I haven’t watched the Sunday gabfests for at least 20 years and cannot imagine watching George S. who is nothing more than a political hack. As well the commercials using children on TV and radio always cause me to become unhinged. In the year long political campaigns I expect to see more and more of this as cheap politicians get into the game.

  • http://catholicsensibility.wordpress.com/ Todd

    “What do you think?”

    Even if I wasn’t on duty every Sunday morning, I wouldn’t go near tv talk at that time. Corporations selling me spectacle. Who needs it? Most homilies are better preached, even if I do listen for the second or third time on a weekend.

    As for the kiddie PSA, I’m with you. Cute, yes. But the Gospel need not be cute, and even kids would largely deliver a thumbs-down to their younger peers being trotted out for the purpose of indoctrination.

    As for Tim Tebow, he’s just not that good as a quarterback. But I wouldn’t count out his determination to succeed. Clearly, he’s a great leader. He reminds me a good deal of Doug Flutie. But every good NFL team is prepared to exploit weakness in a way that Mr Tebow’s college opponents do not and could not. Eleven players on defense on any NFL team will show him up as long as he remains limited in his skill set, no matter how determined he may be.

    Last comment on the man: we should work on him to switch to Catholicism. I think he’ll do more good for our culture than Newt Gingrich. Plus he’s more appealing as a leader.

  • newton

    “You’re so cranky.”

    Cranky… Elizabeth?

    My daughters are cranky. They get that way when they don’t get their chocolate milk or their apple juice, or they can’t play in the rain outside. They get cranky when they don’t get the candy at the grocery store.

    I’ve known Elizabeth for a few years. I’ve dealt with “cranky”. “Cranky”, she ain’t!

  • newton

    As for football… and I don’t really follow it, either…

    It’s just a game. Every Christian in the land knows it.

    It’s just possible that Tebow’s time has not come yet. Or maybe that his talents are better set for something a lot more Eternal than a game of ball and tumble. Look at his charity work, and tell me if you have seen anything similar from any football player at all in the last ten years. I can see that he’s extremely talented. It’s possible that the road will take him places no one ever expects. He’s still young. (24, I think.)

    When his parents prayed for his safe entrance into the world, they promised they would train him to be a preacher. Well, they have. He probably still has to be that bona fide preacher, and it is probable that the “end game” will be at the podium of a church, not on the football field…

    But the negativity thrown at him is deeply disturbing. Witches throwing curses against him – and for Tom Brady? That was too far, IMHO. Any curse they threw against Tebow should come right back at the witches and their “favored” a thousand-fold.

  • Greta

    My husband Mark is the football nut in this family. He found a nice perspectives on Tebow over at Brutally Honest Blog..
    Nice story on Tebow off the field life
    http://www.brutallyhonest.org/brutally_honest/2012/01/who-among-us-is-this-selfless.html

    And at Acts of Apostasy, a funny reaction to Tebow in prayer pose by those who know a thing or two about calling attention to themselves and seem to hate Tebow calling attention to himself… http://actsoftheapostasy.wordpress.com/2012/01/14/not-all-bronco-fans-are-tebow-fans/

  • LeslieK

    “When the commercial aired, I looked up from my book and snarled at it”

    I agree with you Elizabeth, as a liberal Catholic, I don’t want to hear any mention of Christ or God on TV. That she should be kept private, when we bow our heads in Church.

    [you don't agree with me, then, because I do not think religion must be restricted to church or home. - admin]

  • conservativemama

    I still miss David Brinkley on the Sunday morning shows. I left his show when he did. I left Meet the Press when Tim Russert died.

    And you’re so right. We desparately need new voices in our national conversation. We need people who live and breath beyond the Beltway.


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X